Mumbai University LLB · Criminal Procedure

BNSS, JJ Act, POCSO and Probation

Every past-year question in the BNSS compilation with a model answer, arranged by module and topic. Law as at November 15th 2026.

How to use this document

Every question from the BNSS past-paper compilation appears below with a model answer, in the order of the compilation: Module, then Topic, then Short Answers, Short Notes, Situational and Long Answers. Answers state the law under the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS), the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS) and the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 (BSA). The corresponding CrPC, IPC or Evidence Act section appears in brackets, so that answers to older questions framed under the CrPC remain usable.

Question type Marks Answer format
Short Answers 2 One word, a phrase, or a section with a one-line definition
Short Notes 6 12 points
Situational 6 Issue; Law; Application; Conclusion, one line each
Long Answers 13 26 points under sub-headings, closing with the leading case or the rationale

The year tags show the sitting in which a question was set: s = summer (April–May), w = winter (October–December), and a suffix such as "-2" marks a second paper in the same sitting. The asterisks after the year tags are copied from the compilation and count the repetitions of the question. Each question then carries a priority label: High for three or more asterisks, Medium for one or two and no label for none. Revise High questions first; the table at the end lists the 25 most-asked.

Section numbers were checked against the India Code texts of the BNSS, BNS and BSA (each as on October 6th 2025), the CrPC, the POCSO and JJ Acts (both as on July 1st 2026) and the Probation of Offenders Act (as on June 1st 2026). The index at the end lists every provision examined, with its heading as printed in the Act, and every case cited.

Citation conventions: "s 35(1) BNSS (s 41 CrPC)" gives the current section followed by the repealed one. Case names are in italics with the year of decision. Where a CrPC provision has no BNSS counterpart, or the mapping is doubtful, the answer says so.

Writing the answer in the hall: open with the section and its statutory wording; give one scoreable element per point (an ingredient, condition, exception, time limit or safeguard); use a table for any question asking for a distinction; and close a long answer with the leading case or the purpose of the provision.

Module 1

Topic 1.1

Object, purpose and history of the BNSS, 2023

Short Answers2 marks each

Explain the object of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023.

To consolidate and amend the law of criminal procedure, replacing the CrPC, 1973 (in force July 1st 2024), with speedy, technology-enabled and victim-centred procedure.

How does BNSS, 2023 ensure faster trials?

Fixed timelines (charge within 60 days, judgment within 30–45 days), a cap of two adjournments, electronic summons and evidence and trial in absentia of proclaimed offenders.

Long Answers13 marks each

"B.N.S.S. is a law which is apt in contemporary times." Explain this statement with reference to the features of this law.

Background
  • BNSS, 2023 received assent on December 25th 2023 and came into force on July 1st 2024, repealing the CrPC, 1973 (s 531 BNSS).
  • It forms one package with the BNS, 2023 (substantive law) and the BSA, 2023 (evidence).
  • It retains the structure of the CrPC (531 sections) but rewrites provisions on technology, timelines, victims and police accountability.
Technology
  • s 2(1)(a), s 2(1)(i): defines audio-video electronic means and electronic communication, so that every stage may be conducted electronically.
  • s 173(1): e-FIR by electronic communication, to be signed by the informant within three days.
  • ss 64, 71: summons may be served electronically.
  • ss 105, 185: search and seizure must be recorded by audio-video means; the recording goes to the Magistrate.
  • s 254, s 530: evidence may be taken, and trials and proceedings held, in electronic mode.
Timelines for speedy justice
  • s 230: copies of the police report to the accused within 14 days.
  • ss 250, 262: discharge application within 60 days; ss 251, 263: charge framed within 60 days of the first hearing.
  • s 258: judgment within 30 days of arguments, extendable to 45 days.
  • s 346 proviso: no more than two adjournments at the instance of a party.
  • s 193(2): investigation of rape and child sexual offences within two months; s 184(6): medical report of a rape victim within seven days.
Victim-centred procedure
  • s 173(1): Zero FIR, registered irrespective of the area in which the offence was committed.
  • s 193(3)(ii): police must inform the victim of the progress of investigation within 90 days.
  • s 360 proviso: no withdrawal from prosecution without hearing the victim.
  • s 398: every State must notify a witness protection scheme (new).
Police accountability and liberty
  • s 37: a designated police officer in each district and station must maintain and display details of arrested persons.
  • s 35(7): no arrest for an offence punishable with less than three years of a person who is infirm or above 60 without permission of an officer not below the rank of DSP.
  • s 479: a first-time undertrial is released on bond after serving one-third of the maximum sentence.
New tools against organised and absconding offenders
  • s 356: trial in absentia of a proclaimed offender, with notice and a State-appointed advocate.
  • ss 86, 107: attachment of proceeds of crime and of a proclaimed offender's property, including property abroad.
  • s 176(3): forensic team visits the scene for every offence punishable with seven years or more.
Criticisms
  • s 187(2): police custody of 15 days may be taken in parts during the first 40 or 60 days, which widens custodial exposure.
  • s 43(3) permits handcuffing and s 172 permits detention for disobeying police directions, both open to misuse.
  • Hussainara Khatoon v State of Bihar (1979) held speedy trial to be part of Article 21; the BNSS's timelines give that right statutory form, which is the main ground for calling it apt for present conditions.

Topic 1.2

Definitions (s 2) and basic distinctions

Short Answers2 marks each

Define "inquiry".

s 2(1)(k) BNSS (s 2(g) CrPC): every inquiry, other than a trial, conducted under the Sanhita by a Magistrate or Court.

What do you mean by investigation?

s 2(1)(l) BNSS (s 2(h) CrPC): all proceedings for the collection of evidence by a police officer or a person (not a Magistrate) authorised by a Magistrate; a special Act's inconsistent provisions prevail.

Inquiry and Investigation.

Investigation (s 2(1)(l)) is collection of evidence by police; inquiry (s 2(1)(k)) is a judicial proceeding by a Magistrate or Court, other than trial.

Distinguish between 'Inquiry' and 'trial'.

Inquiry ends in discharge, commitment or an order (e.g. maintenance); trial (undefined) begins with the charge or the particulars and ends in conviction or acquittal.

What is a judicial proceeding?

s 2(1)(m) BNSS (s 2(i) CrPC): any proceeding in the course of which evidence is or may be legally taken on oath.

Cognizable and Non-cognizable Offence.

s 2(1)(g): police may arrest without warrant (First Schedule); s 2(1)(o): police may not arrest without warrant, and may investigate only with a Magistrate's order (s 174(2)).

Define bailable offence.

s 2(1)(c) BNSS (s 2(a) CrPC): an offence shown as bailable in the First Schedule or made bailable by other law; bail is a right (s 478).

Define Non-Bailable offence.

s 2(1)(c): any offence other than a bailable offence; bail is discretionary (s 480).

Define 'offence' under the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.

s 2(n) CrPC (s 2(1)(q) BNSS): any act or omission made punishable by law for the time being in force, including acts under s 20 of the Cattle-trespass Act, 1871.

Explain petty offences.

s 229 BNSS (s 206 CrPC): an offence punishable only with fine not exceeding 5,000 rupees (1,000 rupees under the CrPC); the accused may plead guilty by post or through a pleader.

Summons Case and Warrant Case.

s 2(1)(z): warrant-case is one punishable with death, life or imprisonment exceeding two years; s 2(1)(x): summons-case is any other case.

Complaint.

s 2(1)(h) BNSS (s 2(d) CrPC): an oral or written allegation to a Magistrate that a person has committed an offence, with a view to action; excludes a police report.

Oral complaints under Cr.P.C. means.

A complaint made by word of mouth to a Magistrate (s 2(1)(h)); the Magistrate examines the complainant on oath and reduces it to writing (s 223).

Police report.

s 2(1)(t) BNSS (s 2(r) CrPC): the report forwarded by a police officer to a Magistrate under s 193(3) on completion of investigation (the charge-sheet or final report).

Define the terms "place" and "victim".

Place (s 2(1)(s)): includes a house, building, tent, vehicle and vessel. Victim (s 2(1)(y)): a person who suffered loss or injury by the act or omission of the accused, including the guardian or legal heir.

Metropolitan area.

s 8 CrPC: an area with population over ten lakh declared by the State; the BNSS abolishes metropolitan areas and Metropolitan Magistrates.

Define registered medical practitioner.

Explanation to s 51 BNSS (s 53 CrPC): a practitioner with a recognised medical qualification under the National Medical Commission Act, 2019, entered in a National or State Medical Register.

Define officer in charge of police station.

s 2(1)(r) BNSS (s 2(o) CrPC): includes, in the officer's absence, the next senior officer present above the rank of constable or any officer the State Government directs.

Short Notes6 marks each

Difference between warrant case and summons case.

Point Warrant case Summons case
Definition s 2(1)(z): death, life or imprisonment over 2 years s 2(1)(x): not a warrant case (2 years or less)
Procedure ss 261–273 (Magistrate) or ss 248–260 (Sessions) ss 274–282
Charge Formal written charge framed (s 263) No charge; particulars stated (s 274)
Discharge Discharge available (ss 262, 268) No discharge; release if accusation groundless (s 274 proviso)
Absence of complainant Complaint case continues for non-compoundable offence (s 272) Accused may be acquitted (s 279)
Conversion Cannot become a summons case Magistrate may convert to warrant procedure (s 282)

Rights of victims under BNSS, 2023.

  • s 2(1)(y): victim includes guardian or legal heir; the words "for which the accused has been charged" are dropped.
  • s 173(1): Zero FIR and e-FIR may be lodged at any station.
  • s 173(2): free copy of the FIR.
  • s 176(1) proviso: statement of a rape victim recorded by audio-video means.
  • s 183(6): statement of a woman victim of sexual offences recorded by a woman Magistrate where practicable.
  • s 193(3)(ii): progress of investigation communicated within 90 days.
  • s 230: copy of police report and documents to the victim represented by an advocate.
  • s 18(8): victim may engage an advocate to assist the prosecution.
  • s 360 proviso: hearing before withdrawal from prosecution.
  • ss 395, 396: compensation by court and under the State victim compensation scheme; s 397: free first aid and treatment in all hospitals for victims of listed sexual offences and acid attack.
  • s 413 proviso: appeal against acquittal, lesser offence or inadequate compensation; Mallikarjun Kodagali v State of Karnataka (2018).
  • s 398: witness protection scheme.

Long Answers13 marks each

Distinguish between Investigation, Inquiry and Trial.

Point Investigation Inquiry Trial
Definition s 2(1)(l): collection of evidence s 2(1)(k): proceeding other than trial Not defined; judicial determination of guilt
Conducted by Police, or person authorised by Magistrate Magistrate or Court Magistrate or Sessions Court
Nature Administrative and executive Judicial or quasi-judicial Judicial
Begins FIR (s 173) or Magistrate's order (s 175(3)) Complaint, report or information Framing of charge, or particulars in summons case
Ends Police report (s 193) Discharge, commitment or order Conviction or acquittal
Evidence on oath Not on oath (s 180) May be on oath Always on oath
Use of statements Only to contradict (s 181; s 148 BSA) Substantive in the proceeding Substantive evidence
Judicial proceeding No Yes (s 2(1)(m)) Yes
Stage First Second, or parallel (e.g. s 196 inquiry) Last
Examples Search, arrest, statements, inquest (s 194) Maintenance (s 144), nuisance (s 152), committal Sessions, warrant, summons, summary trials
Accused present Not necessary Not always Necessary, subject to ss 355, 356
Outcome binding No; Magistrate may disagree Order binds parties Judgment final, subject to appeal
Authority H.N. Rishbud v State of Delhi (1955): investigation ends with the report Hardeep Singh v State of Punjab (2014): inquiry is distinct from trial Trial begins after framing of charge (Hardeep Singh)

Topic 1.3

Constitution and powers of criminal and executive courts (ss 6–29); prosecutors; powers of superior police officers (s 30); aid to Magistrates and police (ss 31–34)

Short Answers2 marks each

Who is a Public Prosecutor?

A person appointed under s 18 BNSS (s 24 CrPC), including a person acting under the directions of a Public Prosecutor (s 2(1)(v)); an advocate of at least seven years' practice.

What punishment can a Chief Judicial Magistrate give?

s 23(1) BNSS (s 29(1) CrPC): any sentence authorised by law except death, life imprisonment or imprisonment exceeding seven years.

Short Notes6 marks each

Classes of criminal courts.

  • s 6 BNSS (s 6 CrPC): besides the High Courts and courts under other laws, there are four classes of criminal courts.
  • Courts of Session (s 8).
  • Judicial Magistrates of the first class (s 9).
  • Judicial Magistrates of the second class (s 9).
  • Executive Magistrates (s 14).
  • Change: Metropolitan Magistrates (s 16 CrPC) and Assistant Sessions Judges (s 9(3) CrPC) are abolished.
  • s 7: every State is a sessions division or consists of sessions divisions; each division is a district or consists of districts.
  • s 10: in every district a Chief Judicial Magistrate and, if needed, Additional CJMs are appointed by the High Court.
  • s 11: Special Judicial Magistrates may be appointed for particular cases or classes of cases.
  • s 13: CJM is subordinate to the Sessions Judge; other Judicial Magistrates are subordinate to the CJM.
  • s 14: State Government appoints the District Magistrate, Additional DM, Sub-divisional Magistrates and Executive Magistrates.
  • ss 22, 23: sentencing powers are graded by class, and death sentences of a Court of Session need High Court confirmation (s 407).

Prosecutors.

  • s 18 BNSS (s 24 CrPC): Public Prosecutors and Additional PPs for the High Court are appointed by the Central or State Government after consulting the High Court.
  • s 18(3)–(5): for each district the District Magistrate, in consultation with the Sessions Judge, prepares a panel from which the State appoints.
  • s 18(6): where a regular cadre of prosecuting officers exists, appointment is from the cadre.
  • s 18(7): eligibility is at least seven years' practice as an advocate.
  • s 18(8): Special Public Prosecutor, with at least ten years' practice, for a case or class of cases.
  • s 18(8) proviso: the victim may engage an advocate to assist the prosecution.
  • s 19 (s 25 CrPC): Assistant Public Prosecutors conduct prosecutions in Magistrates' courts.
  • s 19(3) proviso: a police officer may not be appointed APP if he took part in the investigation or is below the rank of Inspector.
  • s 20 (s 25A CrPC): State Directorate of Prosecution, headed by a Director, with Deputy Directors in districts.
  • s 20(7)–(9): the Director monitors cases punishable with ten years or more; Deputy Directors scrutinise police reports in cases of 7 to ten years; Assistant Directors monitor cases below seven years.
  • s 338 (s 301 CrPC): the PP in charge of a case may appear and plead without written authority.
  • s 339 (s 302 CrPC): a Magistrate may permit any other person to conduct the prosecution.

Public Prosecutor.

  • s 2(1)(v) BNSS (s 2(u) CrPC): a person appointed under s 18, including one acting under a PP's directions.
  • s 18(1): High Court PPs appointed by the Government after consulting the High Court.
  • s 18(3)–(5): district PPs appointed from a panel prepared by the DM with the Sessions Judge.
  • s 18(7): minimum seven years' practice; Special PP ten years (s 18(8)).
  • s 248 (s 225 CrPC): every Sessions trial is conducted by a Public Prosecutor.
  • s 338: appears and pleads without written authority; a private advocate acts under his directions.
  • s 360 (s 321 CrPC): may withdraw from prosecution with consent of the court, after hearing the victim.
  • s 483(1) proviso: notice to the PP before bail in grave offences.
  • s 419 (s 378 CrPC): files appeals against acquittal on direction of the Government.
  • He is an officer of the court, not a partisan of the police.
  • Shiv Kumar v Hukam Chand (1999): the PP must present the case fairly and not seek a conviction at any cost.
  • Sheonandan Paswan v State of Bihar (1987): withdrawal must be in good faith and in the public interest.

Powers and jurisdiction of metropolitan magistrate.

  • s 8 CrPC: a metropolitan area was any area with population over ten lakh, declared by the State.
  • s 16 CrPC: courts of Metropolitan Magistrates were established in every metropolitan area.
  • s 17 CrPC: a Chief Metropolitan Magistrate and Additional CMMs were appointed by the High Court.
  • s 18 CrPC: Special Metropolitan Magistrates could be appointed for particular cases.
  • s 19 CrPC: the CMM was subordinate to the Sessions Judge; other MMs to the CMM.
  • s 29(4) CrPC: the CMM had the powers of a CJM, and an MM those of a JMFC.
  • An MM could try summarily under s 260 CrPC.
  • An MM took cognizance under s 190 CrPC and could commit cases to Sessions under s 209.
  • His local jurisdiction extended over the metropolitan area.
  • BNSS: ss 6–23 omit metropolitan areas and Metropolitan Magistrates.
  • Their work now falls to Judicial Magistrates of the first class and the CJM.
  • s 8 BNSS: the State may still divide sessions divisions, but no separate metropolitan hierarchy exists.

Sessions Court.

  • s 8(1) BNSS (s 9 CrPC): the State Government establishes a Court of Session for every sessions division.
  • s 8(2): presided over by a Sessions Judge appointed by the High Court.
  • s 8(3): the High Court may appoint Additional Sessions Judges; Assistant Sessions Judges are abolished.
  • s 8(4): a Sessions Judge of one division may be an Additional SJ of another.
  • s 8(6): sits at places the High Court notifies; it may sit elsewhere with consent of parties.
  • s 8(8): urgent applications in the Judge's absence go to an Additional SJ or the CJM.
  • s 22(2) (s 28 CrPC): may pass any sentence authorised by law; death requires High Court confirmation (s 407).
  • s 213 (s 193 CrPC): takes cognizance only on commitment by a Magistrate, unless a law provides otherwise.
  • ss 248–260: trial is conducted by a Public Prosecutor.
  • s 415(3): hears appeals from convictions by Magistrates.
  • ss 438, 440: revisional powers concurrent with the High Court.
  • ss 482, 483: anticipatory and regular bail powers.

Aid to magistrate and police.

  • s 31 BNSS (s 37 CrPC): every person is bound to assist a Magistrate or police officer reasonably demanding aid.
  • s 31(a): to take or prevent the escape of a person authorised to be arrested.
  • s 31(b): to prevent or suppress a breach of the peace.
  • s 31(c): to prevent any injury attempted to be committed to public property.
  • s 32 (s 38 CrPC): any person may aid a person other than a police officer executing a warrant, if the executor is near.
  • s 33 (s 39 CrPC): every person aware of listed offences (offences against the State, murder, dacoity, robbery and others) must inform the Magistrate or police.
  • s 33(2): the duty applies to offences committed outside India which would be listed offences in India.
  • s 34 (s 40 CrPC): village officers and residents must report proclaimed offenders, suspicious deaths and listed offences.
  • BNS s 222 (s 187 IPC): omission to assist a public servant when bound by law is punishable.
  • BNS s 239 (s 202 IPC): intentional omission to give information of an offence by a person bound to inform is punishable.
  • Section 31 applies only to a reasonable demand by a Magistrate or police officer.
  • The provisions make the public a partner in keeping order and secure the duty in law.

Long Answers13 marks each

Classify the various Criminal Courts and state the powers of each of the Courts provided under the Cr.P.C.

Classification
  • s 6 BNSS (s 6 CrPC): besides High Courts and courts under other laws, the classes are Courts of Session, JMFC, JMSC and Executive Magistrates.
  • The Supreme Court has appellate and constitutional jurisdiction (Arts 32, 134, 136), but is not a class under s 6.
  • The BNSS omits Metropolitan Magistrates and Assistant Sessions Judges, both present under the CrPC.
  • s 7: territorial divisions into sessions divisions and districts.
High Court
  • s 22(1) (s 28(1) CrPC): may pass any sentence authorised by law.
  • Confirms death sentences (ss 407–412), hears appeals (s 415), revisions (s 442), transfers (s 447).
  • s 528 (s 482 CrPC): inherent power to prevent abuse of process and secure ends of justice.
  • s 483: special powers regarding bail; s 482: anticipatory bail.
Court of Session
  • s 8: one for every sessions division, with Sessions and Additional Sessions Judges.
  • s 22(2): any sentence authorised by law; death subject to High Court confirmation.
  • Tries offences shown in the First Schedule as triable by it, on commitment (s 213).
  • Appellate (s 415(3)), revisional (s 440) and bail (ss 482, 483) powers.
Judicial Magistrates
  • s 10: Chief Judicial Magistrate and Additional CJM in every district.
  • s 23(1): CJM may pass any sentence except death, life imprisonment or imprisonment over seven years.
  • s 23(2): JMFC may impose imprisonment up to three years, fine up to 50,000 rupees or community service.
  • s 23(3): JMSC may impose imprisonment up to one year, fine up to 10,000 rupees or community service.
  • Community service is a new punishment (BNS s 4(f)) available to Magistrates.
  • s 11: Special Judicial Magistrates exercise first or second class powers in particular cases.
  • s 283: CJM and JMFC may try cases summarily.
Executive Magistrates
  • s 14 (s 20 CrPC): District Magistrate, Additional DM, Sub-divisional Magistrates and Executive Magistrates.
  • s 15: Special Executive Magistrates for particular areas or functions.
  • Powers are preventive: security for peace (ss 126–129), dispersal of assemblies (s 148), nuisance (s 152), urgent orders (s 163), land disputes (s 164).
General provisions on sentence
  • s 24 (s 30 CrPC): imprisonment in default of fine may not exceed the Magistrate's powers.
  • s 25 (s 31 CrPC): sentences for several offences at one trial run consecutively unless the court directs otherwise.
  • ss 26–29: powers are conferred, continued and withdrawn by the High Court or the State Government.
  • The graded hierarchy keeps grave offences before senior courts and gives each accused a forum of appeal, which secures a fair trial under Article 21.

Topic 1.4

Arrest of persons (ss 35–62) and rights of the arrested person

Short Answers2 marks each

What is the procedure of arrest?

s 43 BNSS (s 46 CrPC): touching or confining the body unless the person submits; force if he resists; arrest memo attested and countersigned (s 36); grounds and right to bail communicated (s 47).

In which case can a police officer arrest without warrant?

s 35(1) BNSS (s 41 CrPC): cognizable offence in his presence; credible information of a cognizable offence (with conditions for offences up to seven years); proclaimed offender; possession of stolen property; escape from custody; deserter.

Give any two rights of an accused person.

To be informed of the grounds of arrest (s 47; Art 22(1)); to be produced before a Magistrate within 24 hours (s 58; Art 22(2)).

Short Notes6 marks each

Rights of Accused.

  • Art 22(1); s 47 BNSS (s 50 CrPC): to be informed of the grounds of arrest.
  • s 47(2): in a bailable offence, to be told of the right to bail and to arrange sureties.
  • s 48 (s 50A CrPC): arrest to be intimated to a relative or friend, and the arrestee informed of this right.
  • s 38 (s 41D CrPC): to meet an advocate of choice during interrogation, though not throughout.
  • s 53 (s 54 CrPC): medical examination soon after arrest.
  • s 58; Art 22(2): production before a Magistrate within 24 hours, excluding journey time.
  • s 46 (s 49 CrPC): no more restraint than necessary to prevent escape.
  • s 341 (s 304 CrPC); Art 39A: free legal aid at State expense.
  • s 230 (s 207 CrPC): free copies of the police report and documents within 14 days.
  • Art 20(3): protection against self-incrimination; Nandini Satpathy v P.L. Dani (1978).
  • Art 20(2); s 337 (s 300 CrPC): no second trial for the same offence.
  • Hussainara Khatoon v State of Bihar (1979): speedy trial is part of Article 21.

Situational6 marks each

Rahul is arrested for a serious offense and is subjected to continuous police interrogation without being informed of his right to legal aid. His lawyer is denied access when he tries to meet him at the police station. (a) What rights does an arrested person have regarding legal aid under BNSS, 2023? (b) What legal consequences can the police face for denying legal assistance?

  • Issue: whether denial of counsel and of information about legal aid during interrogation is lawful.
  • Law: Art 22(1) (counsel of choice); Art 39A; s 38 BNSS (meet advocate during interrogation); s 341 (legal aid at State expense); s 12 Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987; Khatri v State of Bihar (1981); D.K. Basu v State of West Bengal (1997).
  • Application (a): Rahul must be told of his right to free legal aid at first production, and may meet his advocate during interrogation; State of Maharashtra v Mohd Ajmal Kasab (2012).
  • Application (b): statements so obtained lose evidentiary value; officers face departmental action and contempt (D.K. Basu), public law compensation (Nilabati Behera v State of Orissa, 1993), and prosecution under BNS s 198 for disobeying law.
  • Conclusion: the denial is illegal; Rahul may seek habeas corpus, compensation and action against the officers.

Mr. Ajay was arrested by the police but was not taken for medical examination. (a) Was the action of the police correct? (b) Explain the provisions in BNSS relating to examination of an arrested person by a medical officer.

  • Issue: whether medical examination of an arrested person is mandatory.
  • Law: s 53 BNSS (s 54 CrPC): every arrested person shall be examined soon after arrest by a government medical officer, or a registered medical practitioner if none is available; a female by or under a female medical officer; injuries and their approximate time recorded; a copy given to the arrestee or nominee. s 51: examination at police request for evidence.
  • Application: s 53 uses "shall" and leaves no discretion; D.K. Basu also requires examination every 48 hours in custody.
  • Conclusion: the police action was incorrect; Ajay may apply to the Magistrate for examination, and the omission can support a claim of custodial violence.

Long Answers13 marks each

Write about the powers of police to arrest a person and the rights of an arrested person.

Meaning and power to arrest
  • Arrest is not defined; it means deprivation of liberty by legal authority, effected under s 43 BNSS (s 46 CrPC).
  • s 35(1)(a): police may arrest without warrant a person committing a cognizable offence in their presence.
  • s 35(1)(b): on complaint, credible information or reasonable suspicion of a cognizable offence punishable up to seven years, only if arrest is necessary to prevent further offences, for investigation, to prevent tampering or inducement or to secure presence in court; reasons recorded.
  • s 35(1)(c): on credible information of an offence punishable with more than seven years or death.
  • s 35(1)(d)–(j): proclaimed offenders, possession of stolen property, obstruction or escape, deserters, extradition offences, released convicts in breach and requisitions from other officers.
  • s 35(2): no arrest without warrant in a non-cognizable offence.
  • s 35(3)–(6) (s 41A CrPC): notice of appearance where arrest is not required; arrest on non-compliance.
  • s 35(7) (new): no arrest of an infirm person or one above 60 for an offence below three years without permission of a DSP.
  • s 39 (s 42 CrPC): arrest of a person who refuses name and residence in a non-cognizable offence.
  • s 170 (s 151 CrPC): arrest to prevent a cognizable offence.
Manner of arrest
  • s 36 (s 41B CrPC): officer wears clear identification; arrest memo attested by a witness and countersigned by the arrestee.
  • s 43(1): touching or confining the body unless the person submits; s 43(2): all necessary means if he resists, but not causing death unless the offence is punishable with death or life.
  • s 43(3) (new): handcuffs only for listed grave or habitual offenders.
  • s 37 (new): designated police officer displays the names of arrested persons.
Rights of the arrested person
  • s 47; Art 22(1): to be told the grounds of arrest and, in bailable offences, the right to bail.
  • s 48: arrest intimated to a nominated relative or friend; entry made in a register.
  • s 38: to meet an advocate of choice during interrogation.
  • s 53: medical examination soon after arrest.
  • s 58; Art 22(2): production before a Magistrate within 24 hours.
  • s 46: no unnecessary restraint; s 56: reasonable care of health and safety.
  • s 341; Art 39A: free legal aid.
  • Art 20(3): right to silence; Nandini Satpathy (1978).
Judicial safeguards
  • Joginder Kumar v State of UP (1994): arrest must be justified by necessity, not merely by power.
  • Arnesh Kumar v State of Bihar (2014): checklist before arresting for offences up to seven years.
  • D.K. Basu v State of West Bengal (1997): eleven requirements on arrest and custody, now largely codified in ss 36–53 and enforced by contempt and compensation.

  • s 62 (s 60A CrPC): no arrest may be made except in accordance with the Sanhita or another law providing for arrest.

Sequence of a lawful arrest

Stages in order, with the governing BNSS sections

  1. Ground under s 35 (or warrant) and recorded reasons.
  2. Identification of officer; arrest memo (s 36).
  3. Arrest by touch or submission (s 43); search (s 49).
  4. Grounds and bail right communicated (s 47); relative informed (s 48).
  5. Medical examination (s 53).
  6. Production before Magistrate within 24 hours (s 58); remand under s 187.

Starting pointStepResult

Source: Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023

Law relating to arrest in case of a female and a judicial officer.

Arrest of a female
  • s 43(1) proviso BNSS (s 46(1) CrPC): her submission to custody on oral intimation is presumed.
  • s 43(1) proviso: unless the officer is female, the police shall not touch her for making the arrest.
  • s 43(5) (s 46(4) CrPC): no arrest after sunset and before sunrise, save in exceptional circumstances.
  • s 43(5): in such circumstances a woman officer must obtain prior permission of the JMFC by written report.
  • s 49(2) (s 51(2) CrPC): search only by another female, with strict regard to decency.
  • s 51(2), s 53 proviso: medical examination only by or under a female medical practitioner.
  • s 179(1) proviso: a woman witness is examined at her residence.
  • s 52 (s 53A CrPC): separate procedure for examination of a person accused of rape.
  • Sheela Barse v State of Maharashtra (1983): separate lock-ups for women, guarded by women constables; interrogation in presence of women officers.
  • State of Maharashtra v Christian Community Welfare Council (2003): the sunset rule is directory in exceptional cases, if reasons are recorded.
  • Violation of these safeguards exposes officers to departmental action and contempt (D.K. Basu).
  • The safeguards protect a woman's dignity and privacy under Article 21.
  • Rights common to all arrestees (ss 47, 48, 53, 58) also apply.
Arrest of a judicial officer
  • The BNSS has no express provision; the law rests on Delhi Judicial Service Association v State of Gujarat (1991).
  • A judicial officer may be arrested only after intimation to the District Judge or the High Court.
  • If immediate arrest is necessary, only a technical or formal arrest may be made.
  • The arrest must be communicated at once to the District and Sessions Judge and the Chief Justice of the High Court.
  • He shall not be taken to a police station without prior order of the District and Sessions Judge.
  • He must be given facilities to communicate with family, legal advisers and judicial officers.
  • No statement, panchnama or medical test may be taken except in the presence of his legal adviser or a judicial officer of equal or higher rank.
  • He shall not be handcuffed unless he offers violent resistance or there is imminent danger to life.
  • If drunk, the test is by blood test in a government hospital.
  • Violation of the guidelines is contempt of court.
  • s 218 BNSS (s 197 CrPC): sanction is needed to prosecute a Judge for acts in official duty.
  • Judges (Protection) Act, 1985: protects judges from proceedings for official acts.
  • The guidelines protect judicial independence from police pressure; Delhi Judicial Service Association (1991) is the leading authority.

When can a police arrest without a warrant?

Statutory grounds: s 35(1) BNSS (s 41 CrPC)
  • (a) a person who commits a cognizable offence in the presence of a police officer.
  • (b) a person against whom a reasonable complaint, credible information or reasonable suspicion exists of a cognizable offence punishable up to seven years, if the officer has reason to believe he committed it.
  • (b)(ii) and arrest is necessary: to prevent further offence, for proper investigation, to prevent disappearance or tampering of evidence, to prevent inducement or threat to witnesses or to secure attendance in court.
  • (b) the officer must record reasons for arresting, and for not arresting.
  • (c) credible information of a cognizable offence punishable with more than seven years or death, with reason to believe.
  • (d) a proclaimed offender under the Sanhita or by order of the State.
  • (e) a person in possession of property reasonably suspected to be stolen.
  • (f) a person who obstructs a police officer in duty or escapes from lawful custody.
  • (g) a person reasonably suspected of being a deserter from the armed forces.
  • (h) a person concerned in an act outside India which would be an offence in India (extradition).
  • (i) a released convict breaching rules under s 394(5).
  • (j) a person for whose arrest a requisition is received from another police officer.
Limits
  • s 35(2): no arrest without warrant in a non-cognizable offence, except under s 39.
  • s 35(3): where arrest is not required, a notice of appearance must issue.
  • s 35(5)–(6): compliance with the notice bars arrest unless reasons are recorded; non-compliance permits arrest.
  • s 35(7): permission of a DSP for arresting the infirm or those above 60 for offences below three years.
  • s 39: arrest on refusal to give name and residence.
  • s 40: a private person may arrest for a non-bailable cognizable offence in his presence, or a proclaimed offender, and must hand him to police within six hours.
  • s 170: arrest to prevent a designed cognizable offence that cannot otherwise be prevented.
  • s 55: an officer may depute a subordinate by written order specifying the offence.

  • s 58 (s 57 CrPC): a person arrested without warrant may not be detained beyond 24 hours without a Magistrate's order under s 187.

Safeguards and authority
  • ss 36, 47, 48, 53, 58 apply to every arrest without warrant.
  • Joginder Kumar v State of UP (1994): power to arrest is distinct from justification to arrest.
  • Arnesh Kumar v State of Bihar (2014): checklist and Magistrate's scrutiny for offences up to seven years.
  • Satender Kumar Antil v CBI (2022): non-compliance with s 41A CrPC (now s 35(3) BNSS) entitles the accused to bail.
  • The scheme balances investigative need against personal liberty under Article 21.

Explain the use of handcuffs during arrests under BNSS, 2023. What restrictions are imposed?

Statutory provision
  • s 43(3) BNSS (new; no CrPC counterpart): the officer may use handcuffs, considering the nature and gravity of the offence.
  • Applies while arresting, or while producing the person before court.
  • Habitual or repeat offenders.
  • Persons who have escaped from custody.
  • Offenders in organised crime or terrorist acts.
  • Drug-related crime or illegal possession of arms and ammunition.
  • Murder, rape or acid attack.
  • Counterfeiting coins and currency notes, or human trafficking.
  • Sexual offences against children, or offences against the State.
Restrictions
  • The list is exhaustive; for any other offence handcuffs may not be used.
  • Even within the list, use is discretionary and must be justified by the nature and gravity of the offence.
  • s 46 (s 49 CrPC): no more restraint than necessary to prevent escape.
  • s 43(2): force only in proportion to resistance.
  • Reasons for handcuffing must be recorded in the case diary (Prem Shankar Shukla).
  • Undertrials produced in court from custody may not be handcuffed without the court's permission (Citizens for Democracy).
  • Women and juveniles are to be protected from such restraint (ss 43(1) proviso; s 10 JJ Act).

  • s 62: arrest and its incidents must conform strictly to the Sanhita.

  • On first production the Magistrate must ask whether the arrestee was ill-treated, and may act on a complaint of unlawful handcuffing.
Case law
  • Sunil Batra v Delhi Administration (1978): bar fetters violate Article 21 unless absolutely necessary.
  • Prem Shankar Shukla v Delhi Administration (1980): handcuffing is prima facie inhuman; permissible only where there is clear danger of escape.
  • Citizens for Democracy v State of Assam (1995): handcuffs only with the Magistrate's permission and recorded reasons.
  • D.K. Basu v State of West Bengal (1997): custodial safeguards enforceable by contempt and compensation.
  • Unlawful handcuffing entitles the person to compensation under Article 21.
Evaluation
  • Supporters regard s 43(3) as codifying police practice for dangerous offenders.
  • Critics argue that the list is wide (e.g. any "habitual" offender) and dilutes Prem Shankar Shukla.
  • Section 43(3) must be read with Article 21, so that the case-law requirement of necessity and recorded reasons continues to apply.

Explain the procedure of arrest of women and a proclaimed offender. Discuss the rights of the arrestee in general.

Arrest of women
  • s 43(1) proviso: submission on oral intimation presumed; only a female officer may touch her.
  • s 43(5): no arrest between sunset and sunrise except in exceptional circumstances.
  • s 43(5): then by a woman officer with prior permission of the JMFC on written report.
  • s 49(2): search by a female with strict regard to decency.
  • s 53 proviso: medical examination by or under a female medical officer.
  • Sheela Barse v State of Maharashtra (1983): separate lock-ups and women constables.
Arrest of a proclaimed offender
  • s 84 (s 82 CrPC): the court publishes a proclamation requiring appearance within at least 30 days.
  • s 84(4): for offences punishable with ten years or more, life or death, the court may declare him a proclaimed offender.
  • s 35(1)(d): police may arrest a proclaimed offender without warrant.
  • s 40(1): a private person may arrest a proclaimed offender and hand him to police within six hours.
  • s 85 (s 83 CrPC): attachment of his property; s 86 (new): identification and attachment of his property abroad.
  • s 356 (new): trial in his absence if he absconds to evade trial.
  • BNS s 209 (s 174A IPC): non-appearance in response to a proclamation is punishable.

  • s 87 (s 84 CrPC): claims and objections to attachment may be made within six months of attachment.

Rights of the arrestee
  • s 47; Art 22(1): grounds of arrest and right to bail.
  • s 48: intimation to a relative or friend.
  • s 38: advocate during interrogation.
  • s 53: medical examination.
  • s 58; Art 22(2): production within 24 hours.
  • s 46: no unnecessary restraint; s 56: health and safety.
  • s 341; Art 39A: free legal aid.
  • s 36: arrest memo with witness.
  • s 37: names displayed by designated police officer.
  • Art 20(3): protection against self-incrimination.
  • s 187: no detention beyond 24 hours without a Magistrate's order.
  • D.K. Basu v State of West Bengal (1997) supplies the governing custodial safeguards, now largely codified in the BNSS.

Topic 1.5

Process to compel appearance and production of things (ss 63–124)

Short Answers2 marks each

When may a search warrant be issued?

s 96 BNSS (s 93 CrPC): where a person summoned under s 94 will not produce the thing; where its possessor is unknown; or where a general search or inspection will serve the inquiry.

What is proclaimed offender?

A person declared so by the court under s 84(4) BNSS (s 82(4) CrPC) after failing to appear under a proclamation, where accused of an offence punishable with ten years or more, life or death.

Short Notes6 marks each

Summons.

  • s 63 BNSS (s 61 CrPC): in writing, in duplicate, signed by the presiding officer and sealed, or in encrypted or other electronic form with the seal's image or a digital signature.
  • s 64(1) (s 62 CrPC): served by a police officer or court officer, personally, by delivering one duplicate.
  • s 64(2) (new): a summons bearing the court's seal may be served by electronic communication.
  • s 64(3): the person served signs a receipt on the other duplicate.
  • s 65 (s 63 CrPC): on a company, served on a director, manager, secretary or other officer or by registered post.
  • s 66 (s 64 CrPC): if the person cannot be found, by leaving a duplicate with an adult member of his family residing with him ("adult male member" under the CrPC).
  • s 67 (s 65 CrPC): if still not served, by affixing a duplicate on a conspicuous part of his residence.
  • s 68 (s 66 CrPC): on a Government servant, through the head of his office.
  • s 69 (s 67 CrPC): outside local limits, through the Magistrate of that area.
  • s 70 (s 68 CrPC): proof of service by affidavit; electronic service is proved by the record of transmission.
  • s 71 (s 69 CrPC): summons to a witness may also be sent by registered post or electronic communication.
  • s 90 (s 87 CrPC): a warrant may issue in lieu of summons; non-attendance is punishable under BNS s 208 (s 174 IPC).

Discuss the processes to Compel Appearance under BNSS.

  • Summons (ss 63–71): the mildest process, served personally, electronically, on a family member or by affixing.
  • Warrant of arrest (ss 72–83): written, signed and sealed, in force until cancelled or executed (s 72).
  • s 73: the court may endorse the warrant for release on security (bailable warrant).
  • ss 74–76: directed to police officers, or to any person when no officer is available.
  • ss 79–83: execution anywhere in India; forwarding beyond jurisdiction; production without delay (s 78).
  • Proclamation (s 84): published requiring appearance within at least 30 days.
  • Attachment (s 85): of movable or immovable property of the absconder.
  • s 86 (new): identification and attachment of the proclaimed person's property abroad.
  • s 90: warrant in lieu of or in addition to summons, where the person may abscond or fails to appear.
  • s 91: bond for appearance from a person present in court.
  • s 92: arrest on breach of a bond for appearance.
  • s 94: summons to produce a document, thing or electronic device; s 96: search warrant.

Situational6 marks each

Mr. Roy files a complaint against Mr. Roshan for threatening him by sending messages through his mobile phone. (a) Can the police officer issue a summons to produce the mobile phone for the purpose of investigation? (b) Can the Court issue a summons during the trial to produce the mobile phone? Explain.

  • Issue: whether the accused's phone can be compelled by summons at investigation and at trial.
  • Law: s 94 BNSS (s 91 CrPC): a court, or an officer in charge of a police station by written order, may require any person to produce a document or thing, now expressly including electronic communication devices likely to contain digital evidence; ss 106, 185: seizure and search by police; Art 20(3); State of Gujarat v Shyamlal Mohanlal Choksi (1965).
  • Application (a): the officer in charge may issue a written order under s 94; but Shyamlal holds that the power to compel production does not extend to the accused, so the police should seize the phone under s 106 or search under s 185, recorded by audio-video (s 105).
  • Application (b): the court may summon the phone from any third party; against the accused it may issue a search warrant (s 96) instead; the phone is physical evidence, so its seizure does not offend Art 20(3) (Selvi v State of Karnataka, 2010).
  • Conclusion: a summons lies against a third party; against Roshan the lawful route is seizure or a search warrant.

Nana, an undertrial accused, is not attending the court even after the charge sheet is submitted. (a) What is the procedure to compel Nana to attend trial? (b) Whether in the absence of Nana a trial can be conducted? Explain.

  • Issue: means of securing an absconding accused, and whether trial may proceed in his absence.
  • Law: s 90 (warrant in lieu of summons); s 92 (arrest on breach of bond); s 491 (forfeiture of bond); ss 84, 85 (proclamation and attachment); s 355 (trial in absence where attendance dispensed with); s 356 (trial in absentia of proclaimed offender).
  • Application (a): the court issues a non-bailable warrant, forfeits his bail bond and cancels bail (s 483(3)); if he still absconds, it issues a proclamation and attaches property.
  • Application (b): s 355 permits trial in absence only if attendance is dispensed with and a pleader appears; under s 356, once declared a proclaimed offender who absconds to evade trial, the trial may proceed after 90 days from framing of charge, after two warrants 30 days apart, newspaper publication, notice to a relative and an advocate appointed at State expense.
  • Conclusion: Nana can be compelled by warrant and proclamation, and may be tried in absentia if declared a proclaimed offender.

Long Answers13 marks each

What are the various processes to compel appearances and production of things and what are the consequences of non-appearance?

Summons (ss 63–71)
  • s 63 (s 61 CrPC): in writing, in duplicate, signed and sealed or in electronic form.
  • s 64: personal service by police or court officer; electronic service permitted.
  • ss 65, 68: service on companies through officers, and on Government servants through the head of office.
  • ss 66, 67: substituted service on an adult family member, or by affixing on the residence.
  • ss 70, 71: proof of service; service on witnesses by registered post or electronically.
Warrant of arrest (ss 72–83)
  • s 72 (s 70 CrPC): written, signed, sealed; remains in force until cancelled or executed.
  • s 73: endorsement for release on security (bailable warrant).
  • ss 74–76: directed to police officers or any other person; notification of substance (s 77).
  • s 78: person arrested brought before the court without delay.
  • ss 79–81: execution anywhere in India, and outside jurisdiction through the local Magistrate.
  • ss 82, 83: procedure on arrest and before the Magistrate of the place of arrest.
Proclamation and attachment (ss 84–89)
  • s 84: proclamation requiring appearance within at least 30 days, published by reading, affixing and newspaper.
  • s 84(4): declaration as proclaimed offender for offences punishable with ten years or more, life or death.
  • s 85: attachment of movable and immovable property.
  • s 86 (new): identification and attachment of property outside India.
  • ss 87–89: claims and objections within six months, restoration and appeal.
Other rules regarding processes (ss 90–93)
  • s 90: warrant in lieu of or in addition to summons.
  • s 91: bond for appearance from a person present in court.
  • s 92: arrest on breach of a bond.
Production of things (ss 94–110)
  • s 94: summons or written order to produce a document, thing or electronic device.
  • s 96: search warrant where production is not expected or the possessor is unknown.
  • s 97: search of places suspected to contain stolen property or forged documents.
Consequences of non-appearance
  • BNS s 208 (s 174 IPC): non-attendance in obedience to a summons is punishable.
  • BNS s 209 (s 174A IPC): non-appearance under a proclamation is punishable; more severely for a proclaimed offender.
  • s 491: forfeiture of bond and recovery of the penalty from the accused and sureties.
  • s 356 (new): trial and judgment in absentia of a proclaimed offender; Hussainara Khatoon (1979) supports this as a means to end delay caused by absconding accused.

Sequence of processes

Stages in order, with the governing BNSS sections

  1. Summons (s 63).
  2. Bailable warrant (s 73), then non-bailable warrant (s 90).
  3. Proclamation (s 84) and attachment (s 85).
  4. Declaration as proclaimed offender (s 84(4)).
  5. Trial in absentia (s 356).

Starting pointStepResult

Source: Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023

Topic 1.6

Preventive and precautionary measures for keeping the peace and good behaviour (ss 125–143)

Short Notes6 marks each

Security from persons disseminating seditious matters.

  • s 127 BNSS (s 108 CrPC): an Executive Magistrate who receives information may act against a person within his local limits.
  • The person must disseminate, attempt or abet dissemination of the matter, orally, in writing or in any other manner.
  • s 127(1)(a)(i): matter punishable under BNS ss 152, 196, 197 or 299 (formerly ss 124A, 153A, 153B, 295A IPC).
  • s 127(1)(a)(ii): matter concerning a Judge acting in official duties that amounts to criminal intimidation or defamation.
  • s 127(1)(b): making, publishing or selling obscene matter referred to in BNS s 294.
  • The Magistrate may require him to show cause why he should not execute a bond for good behaviour for up to one year.
  • Proviso: no proceedings against the editor, proprietor, printer or publisher of a registered publication except by order of the State Government or an empowered officer.
  • s 130 (s 111 CrPC): written order stating the information, amount of bond, term and sureties.
  • s 135 (s 116 CrPC): inquiry into the truth of the information, as in a summons case.
  • ss 136, 137: order to give security, or discharge if security is unnecessary.
  • s 141 (s 122 CrPC): imprisonment in default of security.
  • Sedition as such is omitted from the BNS; Kedar Nath Singh v State of Bihar (1962) confined it to incitement to violence, and S.G. Vombatkere v Union of India (2022) kept s 124A IPC in abeyance; BNS s 152 now punishes acts endangering sovereignty, unity and integrity.

Topic 1.7

Maintenance of wives, children and parents (ss 144–147)

Short Notes6 marks each

Maintenance of Wife, Children and Parents.

  • s 144 BNSS (s 125 CrPC): a secular, summary remedy available whatever the parties' religion.
  • Pre-condition: a person with sufficient means neglects or refuses to maintain the claimant.
  • s 144(1)(a): wife unable to maintain herself; "wife" includes a divorced woman who has not remarried.
  • s 144(1)(b): legitimate or illegitimate minor child, whether married or not.
  • s 144(1)(c): major child (other than a married daughter) unable to maintain itself owing to physical or mental abnormality or injury.
  • s 144(1)(d): father or mother unable to maintain himself or herself.
  • Proviso: the father of a minor married daughter pays until she attains majority if her husband lacks sufficient means.
  • No ceiling on the amount; interim maintenance and expenses during pendency, decided within 60 days of notice.
  • s 144(4): no allowance to a wife living in adultery, refusing without sufficient reason to live with her husband or living apart by mutual consent; a husband's second marriage or keeping a mistress is just ground for her to live apart.
  • s 144(3): on default, warrant for levy and imprisonment up to one month for each month's default, if applied for within one year.
  • s 145: filed where the respondent is, where he or the wife or parent resides, or where he last lived with the wife; before the Family Court where one exists (s 7, Family Courts Act, 1984).
  • Mohd Ahmed Khan v Shah Bano Begum (1985) and Mohd Abdul Samad v State of Telangana (2024): the remedy extends to Muslim women; Rajnesh v Neha (2020): maintenance is payable from the date of application.

Situational6 marks each

X's son and daughter are seeking maintenance from X. The son is major whereas the daughter is minor and married. Advise them.

  • Issue: whether a major son and a minor married daughter may claim maintenance from their father.
  • Law: s 144(1)(b) BNSS (s 125 CrPC): minor child, married or not; s 144(1)(c): major child only if unable to maintain itself owing to physical or mental abnormality or injury; proviso on minor married daughters.
  • Application: the son, a major, has no claim unless he suffers such disability; the daughter, though married, is a minor, and X must pay until she attains majority if her husband lacks sufficient means.
  • Conclusion: the daughter's claim succeeds on proof of her husband's lack of means; the son's claim fails unless disability is shown.

X was married to Y according to Hindu rites. At the time of marriage Y was already married. After some time Y went away from X and neglected to maintain her. (a) Can X file a maintenance application against Y? (b) Before which authority is an application for maintenance filed?

  • Issue: whether a woman whose marriage is void for bigamy is a "wife" under s 144, and the forum.
  • Law: s 144 BNSS; ss 5(i), 11 Hindu Marriage Act, 1955; Yamunabai Anantrao Adhav v Anantrao Shivram Adhav (1988); Badshah v Urmila Badshah Godse (2014); s 145; s 7 Family Courts Act, 1984.
  • Application (a): under Yamunabai a woman in a void marriage is not a legal wife; but Badshah holds that where the husband concealed his subsisting marriage, he cannot take advantage of his own wrong, and the second wife may claim; X, deceived by Y, may apply.
  • Application (b): before the Judicial Magistrate of the first class where she resides, where Y resides or where they last lived together; in Mumbai and other areas with a Family Court, before the Family Court.
  • Conclusion: X may apply; her claim succeeds if Y concealed his first marriage.

Mrs. Tara is working as Deputy Manager and her husband Mr. Indrajeet is working as Manager in ABC company. They are living separately. Mrs. Tara wants maintenance from her husband for herself and for her two children living with her. The elder child is 19 years old and physically challenged, and the younger is 16 years old.

  • Issue: whether an earning wife and her children, one a major with disability, may claim maintenance.
  • Law: s 144(1)(a)–(c) BNSS; Rajnesh v Neha (2020) (income of both spouses, and the standard of living, are considered); Shailja v Khobbanna (2018) (capacity to earn alone does not defeat a claim).
  • Application: Tara earns, so she must show her income cannot maintain the standard she enjoyed with Indrajeet; the gap between a Deputy Manager's and a Manager's salary may be small, so her own claim may fail or be modest; she must also show sufficient reason for living apart (s 144(4)); the 16-year-old is a minor and entitled; the 19-year-old is entitled under s 144(1)(c) because of disability.
  • Conclusion: maintenance will be granted for both children, with Indrajeet's share fixed after considering both parents' incomes; Tara's own claim depends on proof of disparity.

Long Answers13 marks each

Explain the provisions relating to maintenance for wives, children and parents with relevant case law.

Nature
  • s 144 BNSS (s 125 CrPC): a summary, secular remedy to prevent vagrancy and destitution.
  • It applies to all persons whatever their personal law, and does not decide civil rights finally.
Who may claim
  • (a) wife unable to maintain herself, including a divorced wife who has not remarried (Explanation (b)).
  • (b) legitimate or illegitimate minor child, married or not.
  • (c) major child (not a married daughter) unable to maintain itself owing to physical or mental abnormality or injury.
  • (d) father or mother unable to maintain themselves; a childless step-mother may claim (Kirtikant D. Vadodaria v State of Gujarat, 1996).
  • Proviso: father of a minor married daughter, where her husband lacks means.
  • Explanation (a): "minor" means a person under 18 (Indian Majority Act, 1875).
Conditions and defences
  • The respondent must have sufficient means and must have neglected or refused to maintain.
  • "Sufficient means" includes earning capacity of an able-bodied man.
  • s 144(4): wife living in adultery, refusing without sufficient reason to live with husband or living apart by mutual consent.
  • Husband's second marriage or keeping a mistress is just ground for the wife to live apart.
  • ss 144(5), 146(3): an order is cancelled if the wife lives in adultery, refuses without reason to live with her husband, or lives apart by mutual consent, or, for a divorced wife, on remarriage or surrender of her rights.
Procedure
  • s 145(1): jurisdiction where the respondent is, where he or the wife or parent resides, or where he last resided with the wife.
  • s 145(2): evidence taken in the respondent's presence, or that of his pleader, as in a summons case.
  • s 145(2) proviso: ex parte order if he wilfully avoids service; may be set aside within three months.
  • s 144(1) proviso: interim maintenance and expenses; application decided within 60 days of notice.
  • s 144(2): maintenance runs from the date of order or, if ordered, from the date of application.
  • s 146: alteration of allowance on change of circumstances.
Enforcement
  • s 144(3): warrant for levy as a fine; imprisonment up to one month per month's default.
  • The application to enforce must be made within one year of the amount falling due.
  • s 147: order enforceable wherever the respondent is.
Case law
  • Mohd Ahmed Khan v Shah Bano Begum (1985): s 125 overrides personal law; Danial Latifi v Union of India (2001) upheld the 1986 Act consistently.
  • Mohd Abdul Samad v State of Telangana (2024): a divorced Muslim woman may claim under s 125 CrPC.
  • Badshah v Urmila Badshah Godse (2014) and Chanmuniya v Virendra Kumar Singh Kushwaha (2011): "wife" is construed broadly to advance social justice.
  • Rajnesh v Neha (2020): affidavits of disclosure, payment from the date of application and avoidance of overlapping orders; the provision is a measure of social justice under Article 15(3) and Article 39.

Topic 1.8

Maintenance of public order and tranquillity and public nuisance (ss 148–167)

Short Answers2 marks each

Public nuisance as defined u/s 133 of Cr.P.C.

s 152 BNSS (s 133 CrPC): a DM, SDM or Executive Magistrate may conditionally order removal of an unlawful obstruction or nuisance to a public place, way, river or channel, an unwholesome trade, a dangerous building, tank or animal; public nuisance itself is defined in BNS s 270 (s 268 IPC).

Situational6 marks each

'A' and 'B' are neighbours and a water channel flows adjacent to the land of both of them. 'A' obstructs the water flow for his own use, depriving 'B' of water. 'B' does not have time to approach the civil court as his agricultural activities are at their peak and water is urgently required. (a) Can 'B' usefully take recourse to any provision of the CrPC? How? (b) What is the legislative intention of such provisions in the CrPC?

  • Issue: whether a private dispute over use of water can be resolved by an Executive Magistrate.
  • Law: s 166 BNSS (s 147 CrPC): where a dispute about an alleged right of use of land or water is likely to cause a breach of the peace, the Executive Magistrate may inquire and order that the right be allowed or prohibited; s 164 (s 145 CrPC): possession disputes; s 152 (s 133 CrPC) if the channel is public.
  • Application (a): B applies to the Executive Magistrate under s 166, shows the dispute threatens the peace and that the water was used within three months before (or seasonally); the Magistrate may order A not to obstruct the flow until a civil court decides otherwise.
  • Application (b): the provisions aim at preventing breach of the peace by quick, summary relief; they do not decide title, which remains for the civil court (R.H. Bhutani v Mani J. Desai, 1968, on s 145).
  • Conclusion: B has an effective remedy under s 166 BNSS, subject to a later civil suit.

Topic 1.9

Preventive action by the police (ss 168–172)

Short Answers2 marks each

What is preventive action by police?

ss 168–172 BNSS (ss 149–152 CrPC): police may interpose to prevent cognizable offences, arrest to prevent a designed cognizable offence, prevent injury to public property and detain persons resisting lawful directions (s 172).

Situational6 marks each

The police receive information about a likely breach of peace and take preventive action by detaining certain persons without formal arrest. (a) Whether such action is justified under BNSS? (b) Explain the scope of preventive powers of police.

  • Issue: whether police may detain persons without arrest to prevent a breach of the peace.
  • Law: s 168 (interpose to prevent cognizable offences); s 169 (communicate information of a design); s 170 (s 151 CrPC) (arrest without warrant where a cognizable offence is designed and cannot otherwise be prevented; release within 24 hours unless further detention is authorised); s 172 (new: persons must obey lawful directions; police may detain or remove those who resist and produce them before a Magistrate or release them within 24 hours); s 126 (security proceedings before an Executive Magistrate); Art 22.
  • Application (a): a mere apprehension of breach of peace does not permit detention without arrest; detention is lawful only under s 170 (with arrest safeguards) or s 172 (for resisting a lawful direction); otherwise it is illegal detention under Art 21 and 22 (Rajender Singh Pathania v State (NCT of Delhi), 2011).
  • Application (b): powers are limited to interposition, arrest for a designed cognizable offence, protection of public property (s 171) and enforcement of lawful directions; Ahmed Noormohmed Bhatti v State of Gujarat (2005) upheld s 151 CrPC only with these limits.
  • Conclusion: the detentions are unjustified unless they meet s 170 or s 172; the proper course for a feared breach of peace is to inform the Executive Magistrate under s 126.

Topic 1.10

Information to the police and their powers to investigate (ss 173–196)

Short Answers2 marks each

Define FIR.

Not defined; the first information of a cognizable offence given to the officer in charge of a police station and recorded under s 173 BNSS (s 154 CrPC), which sets investigation in motion.

What is the time limit for filing a chargesheet under BNSS?

No general outer limit ("without unnecessary delay", s 193(1)); two months for rape and child sexual offences (s 193(2)); failing filing within 60 or 90 days, the accused gets default bail (s 187(3)).

Short Notes6 marks each

FIR.

  • s 173(1) BNSS (s 154 CrPC): information of a cognizable offence, given orally or by electronic communication, to the officer in charge.
  • Oral information is reduced to writing, read over and signed by the informant.
  • e-FIR: information by electronic communication is recorded on signature of the informant within three days.
  • Zero FIR: recorded irrespective of the area where the offence was committed, and transferred to the station with jurisdiction.
  • Proviso: information of listed sexual offences by a woman is recorded by a woman officer; a disabled victim's information is recorded at her residence and videographed.
  • s 173(2): a copy is given free of cost to the informant or victim.
  • s 173(3) (new): for offences punishable with 3 to seven years, a preliminary inquiry within 14 days, with permission of an officer not below DSP.
  • s 173(4): on refusal to record, the informant may send the substance to the Superintendent of Police.
  • s 175(3): the Magistrate may order investigation on an application supported by affidavit.
  • Lalita Kumari v Govt of UP (2014): registration is mandatory if information discloses a cognizable offence.
  • The FIR is not substantive evidence; it may corroborate the informant (BSA s 160; s 157 Evidence Act) or contradict him (BSA s 148; s 145 Evidence Act).
  • Unexplained delay in lodging the FIR may cast doubt on the prosecution (Thulia Kali v State of Tamil Nadu, 1972).

Confession before Magistrate.

  • s 183(1) BNSS (s 164 CrPC): any Magistrate of the district in which the information is registered, whether or not he has jurisdiction in the case, may record a confession or statement during investigation or before trial.
  • It may be recorded by audio-video electronic means, in the presence of the accused's advocate.
  • A police officer on whom Magistrate's powers are conferred may not record a confession.
  • s 183(2): the Magistrate must explain that the person is not bound to confess and that it may be used against him.
  • The Magistrate must have reason to believe the confession is voluntary.
  • s 183(3): if the person declines to confess, the Magistrate shall not authorise police custody.
  • s 183(4): recorded in the manner of examination of the accused (s 316), signed by him, with the Magistrate's certificate of voluntariness.
  • s 183(5): the record is forwarded to the Magistrate who will inquire into or try the case.
  • Shivappa v State of Karnataka (1995): police must be absent from the chamber, and time given for reflection.
  • BSA s 22 (s 24 Evidence Act): a confession caused by inducement, threat or promise is irrelevant.
  • BSA s 23 (ss 25, 26 Evidence Act): a confession to police, or in police custody unless before a Magistrate, is inadmissible.
  • A retracted confession requires corroboration in material particulars (Pyare Lal v State of Rajasthan, 1963).

Inquest.

  • s 194(1) BNSS (s 174 CrPC): on information of suicide, killing by another, by an animal or machinery, an accident, or suspicious death, the officer in charge informs the nearest Executive Magistrate.
  • He proceeds to the place and investigates in the presence of two or more respectable inhabitants.
  • He prepares a report of the apparent cause of death, wounds, fractures and marks of injury and the weapon likely used.
  • The report is signed by the officer and the witnesses.
  • s 194(2): the report is forwarded to the DM or SDM within 24 hours (new).
  • s 194(3): post-mortem is compulsory where a woman dies within seven years of marriage by suicide or in suspicious circumstances, or on a relative's request.
  • s 194(4): Executive Magistrates are empowered to hold inquests.
  • s 195 (s 175 CrPC): the officer may summon persons acquainted with the facts.
  • s 196(2) (s 176(1A) CrPC): where a person dies or disappears, or a woman is raped, in police custody or other custody authorised by a court, an inquiry by the Magistrate of the area is mandatory in addition to the police investigation.
  • s 196: the Magistrate may have a buried body disinterred and must inform relatives of the inquiry.
  • Pedda Narayana v State of Andhra Pradesh (1975): the inquest is limited to the apparent cause of death, not the identity of the assailant.
  • The inquest report is not substantive evidence; it may be used to contradict its maker.

Use of statement recorded by police during investigation.

  • s 180 BNSS (s 161 CrPC): police may orally examine any person acquainted with the facts; the statement may be recorded in writing or by audio-video means.
  • s 180(3) proviso: the statement of a woman victim of listed sexual offences is recorded by a woman officer.
  • s 181(1) (s 162 CrPC): the statement shall not be signed by its maker.
  • It cannot be used for any purpose at any inquiry or trial, save as provided.
  • Exception: the accused may use it to contradict a prosecution witness under BSA s 148 (s 145 Evidence Act).
  • With the court's permission, the prosecution may also use it to contradict its own witness.
  • It may be used in re-examination only to explain matters raised in cross-examination.
  • s 181(2): it does not affect a dying declaration under BSA s 26(a) (s 32(1) Evidence Act).
  • It does not affect discovery evidence under BSA s 23(2) proviso (s 27 Evidence Act).
  • Explanation: an omission in the statement may amount to a contradiction if significant.
  • Tahsildar Singh v State of UP (1959): only statements that contradict, not mere omissions, may be put to the witness.
  • The rule guards against statements obtained by police pressure being treated as evidence.

Situational6 marks each

A confession is made by a suspect before a magistrate, but he later claims he was forced by the police. The confession was recorded in the magistrate's chamber in the presence of police officers. (a) Is this confession admissible under BNSS, 2023? Why or why not? (b) What safeguards must a magistrate ensure before recording a confession under BNSS, 2023?

  • Issue: whether a confession recorded in the presence of police is voluntary and admissible.
  • Law: s 183 BNSS (s 164 CrPC); BSA ss 22, 23 (ss 24–26 Evidence Act); Shivappa v State of Karnataka (1995); Babubhai Udesinh Parmar v State of Gujarat (2006).
  • Application (a): the presence of police officers destroys the assurance of freedom from police influence; the confession is presumed involuntary and is inadmissible, and the retraction strengthens that inference.
  • Application (b): police excluded from the chamber; warning that he need not confess and that it may be used against him; time for reflection; questions to test voluntariness; record in the s 316 manner, signed, with certificate; audio-video recording and the advocate's presence where possible; no remand to police if he declines.
  • Conclusion: the confession cannot be relied on; it may at most be disregarded entirely.

An offence was committed in Zebranagar police station jurisdiction, but still Mr. Suryakant wants to register an FIR in Kamalnagar police station as for some reason he cannot leave Kamalnagar for the next one week. (a) Is it legal to register the FIR outside the jurisdiction of the police station? (b) Whether the police are bound to take the FIR? Discuss the procedure if the police refuse to register an FIR.

  • Issue: validity of a Zero FIR and remedies for refusal.
  • Law: s 173(1) BNSS (information recorded "irrespective of the area where the offence is committed"); s 173(4); s 175(3); Lalita Kumari v Govt of UP (2014); Satvinder Kaur v State (Govt of NCT of Delhi) (1999).
  • Application (a): Kamalnagar police must register a Zero FIR and transfer it to Zebranagar for investigation.
  • Application (b): registration is mandatory where a cognizable offence is disclosed; on refusal Suryakant may send the substance in writing or electronically to the SP (s 173(4)), then apply to the Magistrate under s 175(3) with an affidavit, or file a complaint under s 223; a writ lies only after these remedies (Sakiri Vasu v State of UP, 2008).
  • Conclusion: registration at Kamalnagar is legal and obligatory.

A goes to the police station to lodge a complaint that his mobile phone has been stolen. The police officer refuses to register an FIR, saying it is a minor issue. (a) Is the police officer justified in refusing to register the FIR? (b) What remedies are available to A under CrPC?

  • Issue: whether police may refuse an FIR for a "minor" cognizable offence.
  • Law: theft is cognizable (BNS s 303(2) (s 379 IPC)); s 173 BNSS (s 154 CrPC); Lalita Kumari v Govt of UP (2014).
  • Application (a): once a cognizable offence is disclosed, the officer has no discretion based on the value or seriousness; theft is outside the categories where a preliminary inquiry is allowed.
  • Application (b): substance to the SP (s 154(3) CrPC; s 173(4) BNSS); application to the Magistrate (s 156(3) CrPC; s 175(3) BNSS); complaint to the Magistrate (s 200 CrPC; s 223 BNSS); an e-FIR on the State portal; departmental complaint against the officer.
  • Conclusion: the refusal is unjustified; A may pursue the above remedies.

A few ruffians stabbed Mr. A and left him injured on the street. Two persons with the help of an auto driver take him to the nearest private hospital and request them to start the treatment. The hospital refuses to treat him as it appears to be a criminal case. (a) Define victim. What is the right of a victim under BNSS, 2023? (b) State the liability of the private hospital in this respect.

  • Issue: the victim's rights, and whether a private hospital may refuse emergency treatment in a medico-legal case.
  • Law: s 2(1)(y) BNSS (victim); ss 396, 397 (compensation; free treatment for victims of listed offences); BNS s 200; Art 21; Parmanand Katara v Union of India (1989).
  • Application (a): A is a victim; he may claim compensation under the victim compensation scheme (s 396), interim relief and first aid, and participate through the progress reports and appeal rights; s 397 mandates free treatment only for listed sexual offences and acid attack, not stabbing.
  • Application (b): Parmanand Katara holds that every doctor, government or private, must give emergency aid at once without waiting for police formalities; refusal violates Art 21 and medical ethics, exposing the hospital to compensation in a writ or civil action and disciplinary action against doctors; BNS s 200 applies only to s 397 victims.
  • Conclusion: the hospital's refusal is unlawful and it is liable to compensate A.

Long Answers13 marks each

What is an F.I.R.? Explain the procedure of investigation by a police officer right from filing of an FIR till submission of the final report.

First Information Report
  • s 173(1) BNSS (s 154 CrPC): information of a cognizable offence, oral or electronic, to the officer in charge.
  • Reduced to writing, read over and signed; an e-FIR must be signed within three days.
  • Zero FIR: recorded irrespective of jurisdiction and transferred.
  • Women victims of sexual offences are heard by a woman officer; disabled victims at home, on video.
  • s 173(2): free copy to the informant or victim.
  • s 173(3): preliminary inquiry within 14 days for offences punishable with 3 to seven years.
  • s 173(4), s 175(3): remedies on refusal before the SP and the Magistrate.
Investigation
  • s 175(1) (s 156 CrPC): the officer in charge may investigate a cognizable case without a Magistrate's order.
  • s 176(1) (s 157 CrPC): report forthwith to the Magistrate; proceed to the spot.
  • s 176(1) proviso: rape victim's statement at her residence by a woman officer, with audio-video recording.
  • s 176(3) (new): for offences punishable with seven years or more, a forensic expert visits the scene, with videography.
  • s 179: attendance of witnesses; women, persons under 15 or above 60, and disabled persons are examined at home.
  • s 180: examination of witnesses; recording by audio-video permitted.
  • s 181: statements not signed, and usable only to contradict.
  • s 183: confessions and statements recorded by a Magistrate of the district.
  • s 184: medical examination of a rape victim; report forwarded within seven days.
  • s 185: search without warrant on recorded grounds, recorded by audio-video; copies to the Magistrate within 48 hours.
  • s 106: seizure of property suspected to be stolen or connected with an offence.
  • s 187: if investigation cannot be completed in 24 hours, the accused is produced for remand; police custody up to 15 days in parts within the first 40 or 60 days.
  • s 192: case diary of each day's proceedings, bound and paginated.
  • s 194: inquest in cases of unnatural death.
  • ss 189, 190: release on bond if evidence is deficient, or forwarding to the Magistrate if sufficient.
Final report
  • s 193(1)–(2): report without unnecessary delay; within two months for rape and child sexual offences.
  • s 193(3): contents include parties, witnesses, offence, custody status, medical report and the sequence of custody of electronic devices; the victim is informed of progress within 90 days.
  • s 193(9): further investigation even after the report; during trial, to be completed within 90 days unless extended (Vinay Tyagi v Irshad Ali, 2013).
  • On a closure report the Magistrate must hear the informant (Bhagwant Singh v Commissioner of Police, 1985); Lalita Kumari (2014) makes registration of the FIR the mandatory starting point.

Sequence of investigation

Stages in order, with the governing BNSS sections

  1. FIR (s 173) and report to Magistrate (s 176).
  2. Visit to scene, forensics, inquest (ss 176, 194).
  3. Witnesses, confessions, medical examination (ss 179–184).
  4. Search, seizure, arrest and remand (ss 185, 106, 187).
  5. Police report (s 193) and further investigation if needed.

Starting pointStepResult

Source: Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023

Describe the powers of Police to investigate cognizable offences.

Source of power
  • s 175(1) BNSS (s 156 CrPC): officer in charge may investigate a cognizable case within his local limits without a Magistrate's order.
  • s 175(2): no proceeding is questioned on the ground that the officer lacked jurisdiction.
  • s 175(1) proviso (new): the SP may direct a DSP to investigate, considering the nature and gravity of the offence.
  • s 178 (s 159 CrPC): the Magistrate may direct investigation or himself hold a preliminary inquiry.
Powers during investigation
  • s 176(1): power to proceed to the spot and investigate facts and circumstances.
  • s 176(1)(b): may decline to investigate a non-serious case, recording reasons.
  • s 176(3): collection of forensic evidence by experts for offences of seven years and above.
  • s 179: requiring attendance of witnesses within the station's or adjoining limits.
  • s 180: oral examination of witnesses and recording of statements.
  • s 182 (s 163 CrPC): no inducement, threat or promise may be offered.
  • s 183: getting confessions recorded by a Magistrate.
  • s 184: medical examination of a rape victim with her consent.
  • s 51: medical examination of the accused at the officer's request.
  • s 52: examination of a person accused of rape.
  • s 349 (new scope): Magistrate may order any person, not only an arrested person, to give specimen signatures, handwriting, finger impressions or voice samples.
  • s 185: search without warrant on recorded grounds, with audio-video recording.
  • s 186 (s 166 CrPC): requisitioning an officer of another station to search.
  • s 106: seizure of property connected with an offence.
  • s 107 (new): applying to the court for attachment of proceeds of crime.
  • s 35, s 187: arrest and remand to police custody.
Control and limits
  • s 176(1): report to the Magistrate forthwith.
  • s 192: maintenance of a case diary, which the court may inspect.
  • s 193: completion and submission of the police report.
  • s 175(3): Magistrate's power to order investigation on a complaint.
  • King-Emperor v Khwaja Nazir Ahmad (1945): investigation is the police's domain; courts do not interfere except under inherent power.
  • State of Haryana v Bhajan Lal (1992): the High Court may quash investigation only in the categories it laid down, which balances police autonomy with judicial control.

Explain the powers and duties of the police under BNSS, 2023.

Powers
  • s 35: arrest without warrant in cognizable offences on the stated grounds.
  • s 35(3): issue notice of appearance instead of arrest.
  • s 43(3): use of handcuffs for listed offenders.
  • s 49: search of an arrested person; s 50: seizure of offensive weapons.
  • s 94: written order to produce documents and electronic devices.
  • s 106: seizure of property; s 107: proceeds of crime attachment through court.
  • s 168, s 170: prevention of cognizable offences and arrest to prevent them.
  • s 172: enforcing lawful directions; detaining persons who resist.
  • s 173, s 175: register FIR and investigate cognizable offences.
  • ss 179, 180: summon and examine witnesses.
  • s 185: search without warrant on recorded grounds.
  • s 194: hold inquests.
Duties
  • s 173: register every FIR disclosing a cognizable offence; give a free copy.
  • s 36: wear identification and prepare an arrest memo.
  • s 37: maintain and display details of arrested persons.
  • s 47: inform the arrestee of grounds and of the right to bail.
  • s 48: inform a relative or friend of the arrest.
  • s 53: arrange medical examination of the arrestee.
  • s 56: take reasonable care of the arrestee's health and safety.
  • s 58: produce the arrestee before a Magistrate within 24 hours.
  • s 176(1): report the case to the Magistrate forthwith.
  • s 192: maintain a case diary.
  • s 193(3): complete investigation, file the report and inform the victim within 90 days.
  • s 105, s 185(5): video-record searches and send copies to the Magistrate within 48 hours.
  • s 31, s 33: the corresponding public duty to aid and inform police supports these functions.
  • Prakash Singh v Union of India (2006) directed police reforms to secure accountability, which the BNSS's recording and reporting duties advance.

Topic 1.11

Jurisdiction of the criminal courts in inquiries and trials (ss 197–209)

Situational6 marks each

'X' is wounded in Delhi and dies of his wounds in Mumbai. (a) The offence of causing X's death would be inquired into by which court, the court in Delhi or Mumbai? (b) What is the provision of Cr.P.C. relating to jurisdiction of criminal courts in the above-mentioned case?

  • Issue: the place of inquiry and trial where the act and its consequence occur in different areas.
  • Law: s 197 BNSS (s 177 CrPC): ordinarily the court within whose local jurisdiction the offence was committed; s 199 BNSS (s 179 CrPC): where an act is an offence by reason of a consequence, the court where the act was done or the consequence ensued; illustration (A wounded in one place, dies in another).
  • Application: the act (wounding) occurred in Delhi and the consequence (death) in Mumbai; both courts are competent.
  • Conclusion: either the Delhi or the Mumbai court may inquire into and try the offence; if in doubt, the High Court decides (s 206 BNSS; s 186 CrPC).

A is wounded within the local limits of the jurisdiction of Court X and dies within the local limits of the jurisdiction of Court Z. Which Court is competent to try the offence, Court X or Court Z?

  • Issue: forum where the injury and the death occur in different jurisdictions.
  • Law: s 199 BNSS (s 179 CrPC) and its illustration; s 198 (s 178 CrPC) (offence partly in one area and partly in another).
  • Application: the wounding is the act and the death the consequence; jurisdiction lies at either place.
  • Conclusion: both Court X and Court Z are competent; the prosecution may proceed in either.

Module 2

Topic 2.1

Requisite conditions for initiating proceedings (ss 210–233): cognizance, complaint to Magistrate, pardon, personal attendance

Short Answers2 marks each

What is the effect of withdrawal from a prosecution?

s 360 BNSS (s 321 CrPC): with the court's consent, after hearing the victim; before charge the accused is discharged, after charge (or in a case needing none) acquitted.

Variation of conditions of pardon.

No power to vary exists; a pardon under s 343 BNSS (s 306 CrPC) is conditional on full and true disclosure, and on the PP's certificate of breach the person is tried under s 345 (s 308 CrPC), his statement being usable against him.

Dispensing with personal attendance of accused.

s 228 BNSS (s 205 CrPC): when issuing summons, the Magistrate may permit appearance by pleader; s 355 (s 317 CrPC): at any stage of inquiry or trial, if attendance is unnecessary and the accused is represented.

How can a corporation or registered society represent itself as an accused before a court?

s 342 BNSS (s 305 CrPC): by appointing a representative, who acts for it at the inquiry or trial; the appointment is made by a writing signed by its head or authorised officer.

Short Notes6 marks each

Complaint to magistrate.

  • s 2(1)(h) BNSS (s 2(d) CrPC): oral or written allegation to a Magistrate seeking action; excludes a police report.
  • Explanation: a police report disclosing a non-cognizable offence is deemed a complaint.
  • s 210(1)(a) (s 190 CrPC): the Magistrate may take cognizance on a complaint.
  • s 223(1) (s 200 CrPC): the complainant and witnesses present are examined on oath; the substance is reduced to writing and signed.
  • s 223(1) proviso (new): no cognizance without giving the accused an opportunity of being heard.
  • Examination is dispensed with where a public servant or court makes the complaint.
  • s 223(2) (new): against a public servant, cognizance requires his explanation and a report from his superior.
  • s 224 (s 201 CrPC): a Magistrate not competent returns the complaint or directs it to the proper court.
  • s 225 (s 202 CrPC): postponement of process for inquiry or investigation; mandatory where the accused resides beyond his jurisdiction.
  • s 226 (s 203 CrPC): dismissal, with brief reasons, if there is no sufficient ground.
  • s 227 (s 204 CrPC): issue of summons or warrant if there is sufficient ground.
  • Pepsi Foods Ltd v Special Judicial Magistrate (1998): summoning an accused is a serious matter requiring application of mind.

Long Answers13 marks each

How is a complaint made to a Magistrate? Explain the procedure of commencement of proceedings before the Magistrate.

Complaint
  • s 2(1)(h) BNSS: an oral or written allegation to a Magistrate that some person has committed an offence, with a view to action.
  • It need not be in any form, but must allege facts constituting an offence.
  • A police report on a non-cognizable offence is deemed a complaint.
Cognizance
  • s 210(1) (s 190 CrPC): cognizance on a complaint, a police report or information or knowledge of the Magistrate.
  • s 213 (s 193 CrPC): the Sessions Court takes cognizance only on commitment.
  • ss 215–222: bars on cognizance without a court's complaint, sanction or complaint by the aggrieved person.
  • s 218: sanction for public servants is deemed granted if not decided within 120 days (new).
Examination of complainant (s 223)
  • The complainant and witnesses present are examined on oath, and the substance is signed by them and the Magistrate.
  • Proviso (new): the accused must be heard before cognizance is taken.
  • No examination is needed where a public servant or court files the complaint, or the case is transferred.
  • s 223(2): complaint against a public servant needs his account and his superior's report.
Magistrate not competent
  • s 224: a written complaint is returned for presentation to the proper court; an oral one is directed there.
Postponement of process (s 225)
  • The Magistrate may inquire himself or direct investigation by police or another person.
  • Inquiry is mandatory where the accused resides beyond his jurisdiction (Vijay Dhanuka v Najima Mamtaj, 2014).
  • In a Sessions-triable case, he must call all the complainant's witnesses and examine them on oath.
Dismissal (s 226)
  • If there is no sufficient ground for proceeding, the complaint is dismissed with brief reasons.
  • Smt Nagawwa v Veeranna Shivalingappa Konjalgi (1976): the accused has no role at this stage, and dismissal lies only where the complaint is absurd or discloses no offence.
Issue of process (s 227)
  • Summons in a summons case; summons or warrant in a warrant case.
  • No summons issues until the list of prosecution witnesses is filed.
  • Process fees must be paid where prescribed, failing which the complaint may be dismissed.
Appearance and copies
  • s 228: the Magistrate may dispense with personal attendance and permit appearance by pleader.
  • s 229: special summons in petty cases, permitting a plea of guilty by post or pleader.
  • ss 230, 231: copies of the police report or of statements and documents to the accused (within 14 days in police cases).
  • s 232: commitment to the Court of Session within 90 days, extendable to 180 days.
  • s 233: where a complaint case and a police investigation concern the same offence, the inquiry is stayed and both are tried together.
  • Pepsi Foods Ltd v Special Judicial Magistrate (1998): criminal law cannot be set in motion as a matter of course; the order summoning an accused must reflect application of mind.

Sequence of a complaint case

Stages in order, with the governing BNSS sections

  1. Complaint (s 2(1)(h)) and hearing of the accused (s 223 proviso).
  2. Examination of complainant on oath (s 223).
  3. Inquiry or investigation (s 225), or dismissal (s 226).
  4. Process (s 227) and appearance (s 228).
  5. Copies (s 231) and commitment, if Sessions-triable (s 232).

Starting pointStepResult

Source: Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023

Topic 2.2

Charge (ss 234–247)

Short Answers2 marks each

What is meant by Charge?

s 2(1)(f) BNSS (s 2(b) CrPC): includes any head of charge when it contains more heads than one; a precise written statement of the offence alleged, framed under ss 234–236.

When can charges be altered?

s 239 BNSS (s 216 CrPC): at any time before judgment is pronounced; the altered charge is read and explained, with adjournment or a new trial if the accused would be prejudiced.

Situational6 marks each

A entices B, the wife of C, away from C with intent to commit adultery with B, and then commits adultery with her. (a) Can A be separately charged with the above-mentioned offences committed by him? (b) In the case mentioned, can B be tried at Delhi?

  • Issue: separate charges for enticement and adultery; place of trial.
  • Law: s 241 BNSS (s 218 CrPC) (separate charge for every distinct offence); s 243 (s 220 CrPC) (same transaction); Joseph Shine v Union of India (2018) (s 497 IPC struck down; no BNS equivalent); BNS s 84 (s 498 IPC); ss 197–199 (place of trial).
  • Application (a): under the CrPC illustration A could be charged separately under ss 497 and 498 IPC (adultery has no BNS equivalent; s 498 IPC is now BNS s 84); after Joseph Shine and the BNS, adultery is not an offence, so A can be charged only under BNS s 84.
  • Application (b): B is the woman enticed and is not an offender under s 84; she cannot be tried anywhere; A may be tried at Delhi if any part of the enticement or detention occurred there (s 198).
  • Conclusion: only one charge lies against A, and B cannot be tried.

Mr. A has committed four offences of embezzlement within a period of one year. (a) Can A be tried for all offences at one trial? (b) What are the contents of a valid charge?

  • Issue: joinder of offences of the same kind; contents of a charge.
  • Law: s 242 BNSS (s 219 CrPC): offences of the same kind within 12 months may be tried together, up to five (three under the CrPC); s 235(2) (s 212(2) CrPC): in criminal breach of trust or misappropriation, a gross sum between two dates within one year may be charged as one offence; ss 234–236.
  • Application (a): all four may be tried at one trial under s 242 (and under the CrPC, three at one trial, or all four as one gross-sum charge under s 212(2)).
  • Application (b): the charge states the offence, its name or definition, the law and section, the time, place and person or thing, the manner where necessary and any previous conviction relied on.
  • Conclusion: a single trial is lawful; the charge must contain these particulars.

Amit and Raj were playing cards at home. In a sudden quarrel, Amit pushed Raj, who fell, hit his head on the table and died. Amit panicked and ran away. (a) What offence has Amit committed under B.N.S.S.? (b) What factors will the court consider to decide whether it is murder or culpable homicide?

  • Issue: the offence and the charge to be framed for a death caused by a push in a sudden quarrel.
  • Law: BNS ss 100, 101, 105, 106 (culpable homicide, murder, its punishment, death by negligence); Exception 4 to s 101 (sudden fight); s 244 BNSS (s 221 CrPC) (alternative charges where doubtful); State of AP v Rayavarapu Punnayya (1976).
  • Application (a): the offence is under the BNS, not the BNSS; with no intention to kill and no weapon, the act is at most culpable homicide not amounting to murder (s 105), or causing death by negligence (s 106); the court may frame alternative charges under s 244.
  • Application (b): intention or knowledge, premeditation, weapon used, force and part of the body struck, nature of the injury, suddenness of the quarrel, and whether undue advantage was taken; flight is relevant conduct (BSA s 6) but does not prove intention.
  • Conclusion: Amit is liable under BNS s 105, for an act done with knowledge that it is likely to cause death but without intention, or under s 106, not s 103 (murder).

Long Answers13 marks each

Discuss the procedure for framing of charges under Section 211 of the CrPC and explain the significance of charge framing in ensuring a fair trial.

Meaning
  • s 2(1)(f) BNSS (s 2(b) CrPC): charge includes any head of charge.
  • It is the formal notice to the accused of the precise accusation he must meet.
Contents: s 234 BNSS (s 211 CrPC)
  • s 234(1)–(3): states the offence; its specific name, or a definition if none; the law and section.
  • s 234(4)–(5): framing a charge declares that every legal condition of the offence is fulfilled; it is written in the language of the court.
  • s 234(7): previous conviction is stated where it affects punishment.
  • s 235 (s 212 CrPC): time, place and person or thing; for breach of trust, a gross sum within one year.
  • ss 236, 237: manner of commission where necessary; words read in their legal sense.
Procedure of framing
  • s 250 (s 227 CrPC): in Sessions, discharge application within 60 days of commitment; discharge if no sufficient ground.
  • s 251(1)(b) (s 228 CrPC): charge framed within 60 days of the first hearing on charge, if there is ground to presume the offence.
  • s 251(2): the charge is read and explained, physically or by audio-video means and the plea recorded.
  • ss 262, 263 (ss 239, 240 CrPC): in warrant cases on police report, discharge application within 60 days and charge within 60 days.
  • ss 268, 269 (ss 245, 246 CrPC): in complaint warrant cases, after prosecution evidence.
  • s 274 (s 251 CrPC): no formal charge in summons cases; particulars of the offence are stated.
Joinder of charges
  • s 241 (s 218 CrPC): a separate charge and separate trial for every distinct offence.
  • s 242: offences of the same kind within 12 months, up to five, in one trial.
  • s 243 (s 220 CrPC): offences in the same transaction tried together.
  • s 244 (s 221 CrPC): alternative charges where it is doubtful which offence is made out.
  • s 246 (s 223 CrPC): persons accused of the same offence or same transaction may be charged jointly.
Alteration and errors
  • s 239: alteration at any time before judgment; adjournment or new trial if prejudice results.
  • s 240: recall of witnesses after alteration.
  • s 238 (s 215 CrPC): an error or omission is immaterial unless it misled the accused and caused failure of justice.
  • s 510 (s 464 CrPC): no finding is invalid for absence of or error in a charge, unless failure of justice is caused.
Significance for a fair trial
  • It gives the accused notice of the accusation, which Articles 21 and 22 require.
  • It confines the evidence and the defence to the matters charged and prevents surprise.
  • State of Maharashtra v Som Nath Thapa (1996): at framing, strong suspicion on the material suffices; a mini-trial is not held.
  • Willie (William) Slaney v State of Madhya Pradesh (1956): the test of a defective charge is prejudice to the accused, which ties framing directly to fairness.

Topic 2.3

Trial before various courts (Sessions ss 248–260; warrant cases ss 261–273; summons cases ss 274–282; summary trial ss 283–288)

Short Answers2 marks each

Which are different types of trial?

Sessions trial (ss 248–260); warrant trial by Magistrate, on police report (ss 261–266) or complaint (ss 267–270); summons trial (ss 274–282); summary trial (ss 283–288).

For which offences is warrant trial followed?

Warrant cases (s 2(1)(z): death, life or imprisonment over two years) triable by a Magistrate under the First Schedule; those triable by the Court of Session follow the Sessions procedure.

For which offences can summons trial be conducted?

Summons cases, i.e. offences punishable with imprisonment up to two years or fine (s 2(1)(x)); procedure under ss 274–282 BNSS (ss 251–259 CrPC).

What is summary trial?

An abridged trial by a CJM or JMFC under s 283 BNSS (s 260 CrPC) for petty offences, following the summons procedure, with a brief record and no imprisonment over three months.

Explain discharge.

Release of the accused before charge where the material discloses no sufficient ground (ss 250, 262, 268 BNSS); unlike acquittal, it does not bar fresh proceedings on new material.

Short Notes6 marks each

Summary trials.

  • s 283(1) BNSS (s 260 CrPC): the CJM and any JMFC may try summarily; Metropolitan Magistrates no longer exist.
  • Offences not punishable with death, life or imprisonment over two years.
  • Theft under BNS ss 303(2), 305, 306 and receiving or retaining stolen property (s 317(2)), where the value does not exceed 20,000 rupees (2,000 rupees under the CrPC).
  • Assisting concealment of stolen property (s 317(5)), house-trespass offences (s 331(2), (3)), insult to provoke breach of peace (s 352), criminal intimidation (s 351(2), (3)).
  • Abetment and attempt of these offences, and offences under s 20 of the Cattle-trespass Act, 1871.
  • s 283(2) (new): after hearing the accused, a Magistrate may try summarily any offence punishable up to three years; this decision is not appealable.
  • s 284 (s 261 CrPC): a JMSC authorised by the High Court may try offences punishable only with fine or up to six months.
  • s 285(1) (s 262 CrPC): the summons-case procedure applies.
  • s 285(2): no sentence of imprisonment exceeding three months.
  • If summary trial appears undesirable mid-way, witnesses are recalled and the case reheard in the regular manner.
  • s 286 (s 263 CrPC): brief record of particulars (serial number, date, parties, offence, plea, finding, sentence).
  • s 287 (s 264 CrPC): where the accused does not plead guilty, a brief statement of reasons is recorded.

Situational6 marks each

Raju and Dev along with their three friends commit dacoity at P.K. Jewellers shop. After their arrest and completion of investigation, a chargesheet is filed in the sessions court. The trial begins. (a) Can Dev plead for a discharge in this case? Explain. (b) Can Raju apply for a tender of pardon? When?

  • Issue: availability of discharge in a Sessions case, and tender of pardon to a co-accused.
  • Law: dacoity is triable by the Court of Session (BNS s 310(2) (s 395 IPC)); s 250 BNSS (s 227 CrPC); Union of India v Prafulla Kumar Samal (1979); ss 343, 344 BNSS (ss 306, 307 CrPC).
  • Application (a): Dev may apply for discharge within 60 days of commitment; the judge discharges him only if the record and documents disclose no sufficient ground, i.e. not even grave suspicion; once the charge is framed and the trial begun, discharge is no longer available.
  • Application (b): pardon is tendered, not applied for as of right; after commitment, the Sessions Court may tender pardon under s 344 at any time before judgment, on condition of full and true disclosure; Raju is then examined as a prosecution witness (s 343(4)).
  • Conclusion: Dev's discharge depends on the material and timing; Raju may be tendered a pardon by the Sessions Court before judgment.

Long Answers13 marks each

Sessions Trial: the law and procedure.

Basis
  • Offences shown in the First Schedule as triable by the Court of Session (e.g. murder, rape, dacoity).
  • s 213 (s 193 CrPC): cognizance only on commitment by a Magistrate.
  • s 232 (s 209 CrPC): commitment within 90 days of cognizance, extendable to 180 days.
Stages: ss 248–260 BNSS (ss 225–237 CrPC)
  • s 248: every trial is conducted by a Public Prosecutor.
  • s 249: the PP opens the case, describing the charge and the evidence.
  • s 250(1) (new): discharge application within 60 days of commitment.
  • s 250(2): discharge if no sufficient ground, with reasons (Union of India v Prafulla Kumar Samal, 1979).
  • s 251(1): if there is ground to presume the offence, the charge is framed within 60 days of the first hearing.
  • s 251(1)(a): if the offence is not exclusively Sessions-triable, the case may be transferred to the CJM.
  • s 251(2): charge read and explained, physically or by audio-video means; plea taken.
  • s 252: conviction on a plea of guilty, at the judge's discretion.
  • ss 253, 254(1): if the accused claims trial, a date is fixed and prosecution evidence taken; witnesses may be examined by audio-video means.
  • s 254(3): cross-examination may be deferred.
  • s 351 (s 313 CrPC): the accused is examined to explain incriminating circumstances.
  • s 255: acquittal if there is no evidence that the accused committed the offence.
  • s 256(1): otherwise the accused enters on his defence.
  • s 256(2): process for defence witnesses, unless sought for vexation or delay.
  • s 257: arguments by the prosecutor and the defence.
  • s 258(1): judgment within 30 days of arguments, extendable to 45 days for recorded reasons.
  • s 258(2): hearing on sentence after conviction, unless probation is given.
  • s 259: previous conviction proved only after conviction on the main charge.
  • s 260: procedure for defamation of high functionaries on the Public Prosecutor's complaint.
General rules applied
  • s 344: the Sessions Court may tender pardon before judgment.
  • s 346 proviso: no more than two adjournments at a party's request.
  • s 366(2): trials of rape and POCSO offences in camera.
  • Allauddin Mian v State of Bihar (1989): the hearing on sentence is a real hearing, and its omission vitiates the sentence.

Sequence of a Sessions trial

Stages in order, with the governing BNSS sections

  1. Commitment (s 232); opening by PP (s 249).
  2. Discharge (s 250) or charge (s 251).
  3. Plea (ss 251–252); prosecution evidence (s 254).
  4. Examination of accused (s 351); acquittal (s 255) or defence (s 256).
  5. Arguments (s 257); judgment and sentence (s 258).

Starting pointStepResult

Source: Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023

State the procedure of trial of warrant cases by Magistrate.

Scope
  • s 2(1)(z): warrant case: death, life or imprisonment over two years; Magistrates try those not reserved for Sessions.
  • Two procedures: cases on police report (ss 261–266) and cases instituted otherwise (ss 267–270).
Cases instituted on police report (ss 261–266; ss 238–243 CrPC)
  • s 261: Magistrate ensures compliance with s 230 (copies to the accused).
  • s 262(1): discharge application within 60 days of supply of documents.
  • s 262(2): discharge if the charge is groundless, after considering the report and hearing the parties; the accused may be examined by audio-video means.
  • s 263(1): charge framed within 60 days of the first hearing, if there is ground to presume the offence.
  • s 263(2): charge read and explained; plea taken.
  • s 264: conviction on a plea of guilty.
  • s 265(1)–(2): date for prosecution evidence; summons to witnesses.
  • s 265(3): evidence taken; witnesses may be examined by audio-video means.
  • s 266: defence evidence and written statement filed on record.
Cases instituted otherwise than on police report (ss 267–270; ss 244–247 CrPC)
  • s 267(1): Magistrate hears the prosecution and takes its evidence.
  • s 267(2): summons to prosecution witnesses on application.
  • s 268(1): discharge if no case is made out that would warrant conviction.
  • s 268(2): discharge at any earlier stage if the charge is groundless.
  • s 269(1): charge framed if there is ground to presume the offence.
  • s 269(2)–(4): plea taken; prosecution witnesses recalled for cross-examination.
  • s 270: defence evidence.
Conclusion of trial (ss 271–273)
  • s 271(1): acquittal if not guilty.
  • s 271(2): on conviction, hearing on sentence, unless dealt with under s 401 (probation).
  • s 271(3): previous conviction proved where alleged and denied.
  • s 272 (s 249 CrPC): absence of complainant in a compoundable or non-cognizable case may lead to discharge before charge.
  • s 273 (s 250 CrPC): compensation to the accused for an accusation without reasonable cause.
  • s 346: no more than two adjournments at a party's request.
Authority
  • Union of India v Prafulla Kumar Samal (1979): discharge tests whether there is grave suspicion, not proof.
  • The structure gives warrant cases greater safeguards than summons cases because the punishment is heavier.

Explain the process of Summary trials under BNSS.

Who may try
  • s 283(1) BNSS (s 260 CrPC): the CJM and any JMFC.
  • s 284: a JMSC specially authorised by the High Court, for offences punishable only with fine or up to six months.
  • Metropolitan Magistrates, empowered under the CrPC, are omitted.
Offences
  • Offences not punishable with death, life or imprisonment over two years.
  • Theft (BNS ss 303(2), 305, 306) and receiving stolen property (s 317(2)) up to 20,000 rupees in value.
  • Assisting concealment of stolen property (s 317(5)); house-trespass (s 331(2), (3)).
  • Insult to provoke breach of peace (s 352); criminal intimidation (s 351(2), (3)).
  • Abetment and attempt of these; offences under s 20 Cattle-trespass Act, 1871.
  • s 283(2) (new): offences punishable up to three years, after hearing the accused, with reasons; this decision is not appealable.
Procedure
  • s 285(1): procedure for summons cases applies (ss 274–282).
  • No formal charge; particulars are stated and the plea recorded.
  • On a plea of guilty, the Magistrate may convict.
  • Evidence is recorded briefly.
  • s 285(2): no imprisonment exceeding three months.
  • If the case appears unsuitable, witnesses are recalled and the case reheard regularly.
Record and judgment
  • s 286: record of serial number, date of offence and report, parties, offence, plea, finding, sentence and date of termination.
  • s 287: where the accused does not plead guilty, a brief statement of the reasons for the finding.
  • s 288: record and judgment in the language of the court.
  • The record and judgment are signed by the Magistrate.
Remedies
  • Appeal lies against conviction, save for petty sentences barred by s 417.
  • Revision lies to the Sessions Court or High Court (s 438).
  • The decision to try summarily under s 283(2) is not appealable.
  • The Magistrate's power to imprison is limited to three months, which protects the accused from the abridged process.
Assessment
  • Summary trial reduces arrears in petty cases and saves court time.
  • Its brevity demands care that the accused is not prejudiced.
  • Meters and Instruments Pvt Ltd v Kanchan Mehta (2017) encouraged summary trial of cheque-dishonour cases, showing its use for high-volume petty litigation.

Explain various trials under BNSS. State the differences in procedure.

Types of trial
  • Sessions trial (ss 248–260): offences triable by the Court of Session, on commitment; conducted by a PP.
  • It provides discharge (s 250), charge (s 251), evidence, defence and judgment with a hearing on sentence (s 258).
  • Death sentences need High Court confirmation (s 407).
  • Warrant trial (ss 261–273): offences over two years triable by Magistrates.
  • Separate procedures for police report and complaint cases; discharge and formal charge available.
  • Complaint cases require prosecution evidence before charge (s 267).
  • Summons trial (ss 274–282): offences up to two years.
  • No charge; particulars stated (s 274); proviso permits release where the accusation is groundless.
  • May be converted to a warrant trial (s 282).
  • Summary trial (ss 283–288): petty offences listed in s 283, and up to three years under s 283(2).
  • Summons procedure; brief record; maximum three months' imprisonment.
  • Suits high-volume petty cases.
Point Sessions Warrant Summons Summary
Court Sessions Judge CJM or JMFC Any Magistrate CJM, JMFC, empowered JMSC
Offences First Schedule "Court of Session" Over 2 years, Magistrate-triable Up to 2 years Listed petty offences; up to 3 years under s 283(2)
Prosecutor Public Prosecutor mandatory APP or complainant APP or complainant APP or complainant
Charge Formal (s 251) Formal (ss 263, 269) None (s 274) None
Discharge s 250 ss 262, 268 Release under s 274 proviso Release under s 274 proviso
Absent complainant Not applicable Discharge only in limited cases (s 272) Acquittal (s 279) Acquittal (s 279)
Record and sentence Full record; any sentence (death confirmed by HC) Full record; within s 23 limits Full record; within s 23 limits Brief record; maximum 3 months

Topic 2.4

Plea bargaining (ss 289–300)

Short Answers2 marks each

What is Plea Bargaining?

A pre-trial process under ss 289–300 BNSS (ss 265A–265L CrPC) by which the accused pleads guilty voluntarily in return for a reduced sentence and compensation to the victim.

Short Notes6 marks each

Plea Bargaining.

  • s 289(1) BNSS (s 265A CrPC): applies to offences punishable with up to seven years, after a police report or a Magistrate's cognizance on complaint.
  • Excluded: offences affecting the socio-economic condition of the country (notified), and offences against a woman or a child (CrPC: child below 14).
  • s 290(1) (new): application within 30 days of the framing of charge.
  • s 290(2), (4): the accused files an affidavit of voluntariness and of no previous conviction for the same offence; the court examines him in camera.
  • s 290(4)(a); s 291 (s 265C CrPC): the court allows up to 60 days to work out a mutually satisfactory disposition with the prosecutor, the investigating officer and the victim.
  • s 292: report of the disposition signed by the participants.
  • s 293(a): compensation to the victim as agreed.
  • s 293(b): release on probation or admonition where the law permits.
  • s 293(c)–(d): half of the minimum sentence (one-fourth for a first offender); where no minimum, one-fourth of the maximum (one-sixth for a first offender).
  • ss 294, 295: judgment delivered in open court is final; only an SLP or writ lies.
  • s 297: period of detention set off; s 299: the accused's statements cannot be used for any other purpose.
  • State of Gujarat v Natwar Harchandji Thakor (2005) recognised plea bargaining as part of fair, speedy justice.

Situational6 marks each

A person is accused of attempt to murder and applies for plea bargaining to get a reduced sentence. The prosecution objects, stating that the offence is non-bailable and serious. (a) Can plea bargaining be allowed for a non-bailable offence like attempt to murder under BNSS, 2023? (b) What types of offences qualify for plea bargaining?

  • Issue: eligibility of attempt to murder for plea bargaining.
  • Law: s 289 BNSS; BNS s 109 (s 307 IPC): attempt to murder is punishable with up to ten years, or life if hurt is caused.
  • Application (a): the bar arises from the punishment exceeding seven years, not from the offence being non-bailable; the application must be rejected.
  • Application (b): offences punishable up to seven years, other than notified socio-economic offences and offences against a woman or a child, by an accused without a previous conviction for the same offence.
  • Conclusion: plea bargaining is not available.

Ayushi filed an application for plea-bargaining. (a) What is the time limit for filing the application of Plea Bargaining? (b) What are the exceptions for filing an application for plea bargaining?

  • Issue: time limit and exclusions under Chapter XXIII.
  • Law: s 290(1) BNSS (within 30 days of framing of charge); ss 289, 290(4), 300.
  • Application (a): Ayushi must apply within 30 days of the framing of charge; the CrPC prescribed no limit.
  • Application (b): no plea bargaining where the offence is punishable with death, life or over seven years; where it affects the socio-economic condition of the country (e.g. offences under the Dowry Prohibition Act and Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act notified in 2006); where committed against a woman or child; where the accused has a previous conviction for the same offence; or where the accused is a child under the JJ Act (s 300).
  • Conclusion: her application is maintainable only within these limits.

A person is accused of penetrative sexual assault under the POCSO Act and applies for plea bargaining to get a reduced sentence. The prosecution objects, stating that the offence is grievous in nature. (a) Can plea-bargaining be allowed for grievous offences like penetrative sexual assault under the POCSO Act? (b) Which types of offences are eligible for plea-bargaining under the POCSO Act?

  • Issue: plea bargaining for offences under the POCSO Act.
  • Law: s 289 BNSS; s 4 POCSO (minimum ten years; 20 years if the child is below 16).
  • Application (a): the offence is excluded twice, by punishment over seven years and as an offence against a child.
  • Application (b): every POCSO offence is by definition committed against a child, so none qualifies; the Act's child-protective purpose is consistent with this.
  • Conclusion: plea bargaining is barred for all POCSO offences.

Long Answers13 marks each

Explain the concept of Plea Bargaining under the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), 2023. Discuss its objectives, eligibility criteria, and the procedure prescribed under the Act.

Concept
  • A process in which the accused pleads guilty in exchange for a lesser sentence, with compensation to the victim.
  • Introduced by the Criminal Law (Amendment) Act, 2005 as Chapter XXIA CrPC; now Chapter XXIII, ss 289–300 BNSS.
  • Indian law permits sentence bargaining only, not charge bargaining.
Objectives
  • Reduce pendency and delay in criminal courts.
  • Reduce the number of undertrials in jails.
  • Secure compensation and closure for the victim.
  • Encourage first-time offenders to reform.
Eligibility
  • s 289(1): offence punishable with up to seven years.
  • A police report has been filed, or a Magistrate has taken cognizance on complaint.
  • Excludes notified socio-economic offences.
  • Excludes offences against a woman or a child.
  • s 290(4): excludes an accused previously convicted of the same offence.
  • s 300: excludes a child under the JJ Act.
Procedure
  • s 290(1): application within 30 days of framing of charge, with an affidavit of voluntariness.
  • s 290(3)–(4): notice to the prosecutor or complainant; examination of the accused in camera.
  • s 290(4): if involuntary or if the accused has a previous conviction, the case proceeds to trial.
  • s 290(4)(a): up to 60 days to work out a mutually satisfactory disposition, including compensation.
  • s 291: the court ensures the process is voluntary throughout.
  • s 292: report signed by the presiding officer and all participants.
  • s 293: compensation; probation or admonition where permissible.
  • s 293: half of the minimum sentence (one-fourth for first offenders), or one-fourth of the maximum (one-sixth for first offenders).
  • s 294: judgment in open court, signed by the presiding officer.
Effect
  • s 295: the judgment is final; only an SLP (Art 136) or writ (Arts 226, 227) lies.
  • s 297: period already undergone is set off.
  • s 299: statements made in the application are not used for any other purpose.
  • State of Gujarat v Natwar Harchandji Thakor (2005) treated plea bargaining as a legitimate part of the right to speedy trial; earlier, Kachhia Patel Shantilal Koderlal v State of Gujarat (1980) had condemned informal bargains, which the statutory safeguards now answer.

Module 3

Topic 3.1

Mode of taking and recording evidence and general provisions as to inquiries and trials (ss 307–366)

Short Answers2 marks each

Who is an accomplice?

A guilty associate in the crime (principal or abettor); undefined, but a competent witness whose uncorroborated testimony may support a conviction (BSA s 138; s 133 Evidence Act).

What do you mean by compounding of offences?

Settlement of a listed offence by the victim with the accused under s 359 BNSS (s 320 CrPC), with or without the court's permission; it has the effect of acquittal.

Short Notes6 marks each

Accomplice.

  • "Accomplice" is not defined in the BNSS or BSA; it denotes a participant in the crime, whether principal or abettor.
  • Receivers of stolen property are accomplices of the thief.
  • A victim, a decoy or a trap witness is not an accomplice (State of Bihar v Basawan Singh, 1958).
  • BSA s 138 (s 133 Evidence Act): an accomplice is a competent witness against the accused.
  • A conviction is not illegal merely because it rests on uncorroborated accomplice evidence.
  • BSA s 119, illustration (b) (s 114(b) Evidence Act): the court may presume an accomplice unworthy of credit unless corroborated in material particulars.
  • The two provisions are reconciled by a rule of prudence requiring corroboration.
  • R v Baskerville (1916): corroboration must be independent and connect the accused with the crime.
  • Rameshwar v State of Rajasthan (1952): the rule of prudence has hardened into a rule of law in practice.
  • Sarwan Singh v State of Punjab (1957): the evidence must first be credible, and then corroborated.
  • An approver is an accomplice granted pardon under s 343 BNSS (s 306 CrPC) and examined as a witness (s 343(4)).
  • Corroboration of one accomplice by another is weak and needs caution.

In Camera Trial.

  • s 366(1) BNSS (s 327 CrPC): criminal courts are open to the public.
  • Proviso: the presiding officer may exclude the public, or any person, at any stage.
  • s 366(2): inquiry and trial of rape and related offences (BNS ss 64–68, 70, 71) and POCSO ss 4, 6, 8, 10 are held in camera.
  • Such trials are conducted, as far as practicable, by a woman judge or Magistrate.
  • s 366(3): no matter relating to such proceedings may be printed or published without the court's permission.
  • The ban may be lifted subject to keeping the names and addresses of the parties confidential.
  • BNS s 72 (s 228A IPC): disclosure of the identity of a rape victim is punishable.
  • POCSO s 37: trials of child sexual offences are in camera, in the presence of the parents or a trusted person.
  • JJ Act s 74: the identity of a child in conflict with law or in need of care must not be disclosed.
  • Naresh Shridhar Mirajkar v State of Maharashtra (1966): courts have inherent power to hold proceedings in camera where justice requires.
  • State of Punjab v Gurmit Singh (1996): in-camera trial of rape cases is mandatory and preserves the victim's dignity.
  • Nipun Saxena v Union of India (2018): the victim's identity must not be revealed in any form.

Person once convicted or acquitted not to be tried for same offence.

  • Art 20(2): no person shall be prosecuted and punished for the same offence more than once.
  • s 337(1) BNSS (s 300(1) CrPC): a person tried by a competent court and convicted or acquitted, while that verdict stands, may not be tried again for the same offence.
  • Nor on the same facts for any other offence for which a different charge might have been made (s 244(1)) or on which he might have been convicted (s 244(2)).
  • s 337(2): he may, with the State's consent, be tried for a distinct offence for which a separate charge might have been made under s 243(1).
  • s 337(3): he may be tried again where the act caused consequences, not known at the first trial, that make it a different offence (e.g. death after hurt).
  • s 337(4): he may be tried again where the first court was not competent to try the later offence.
  • s 337(5): a person discharged under s 281 may not be tried again without the court's consent.
  • s 337(6): the rule does not affect s 26 of the General Clauses Act, 1897 or s 208 BNSS.
  • Explanation: dismissal of a complaint or discharge is not an acquittal.
  • Pre-conditions: a competent court, a full trial, a conviction or acquittal still in force and the same offence.
  • Maqbool Hussain v State of Bombay (1953): proceedings before customs authorities are not a prosecution.
  • Kolla Veera Raghav Rao v Gorantla Venkateswara Rao (2011): s 300 CrPC is wider than Art 20(2), since it bars a second trial even where no punishment followed.

Long Answers13 marks each

Discuss the provisions regarding compounding of offences under Cr.P.C.

Meaning
  • Compounding is a settlement between the victim and the accused that ends the prosecution.
  • s 359(9) BNSS (s 320(9) CrPC): only offences listed in s 359 may be compounded.
Two tables
  • s 359(1) (Table 1): compoundable by the person specified, without the court's permission.
  • Examples: voluntarily causing hurt (BNS s 115(2)), wrongful restraint (s 126(2)), theft (s 303(2)), defamation (s 356(2)).
  • s 359(2) (Table 2): compoundable only with the court's permission.
  • Examples: criminal breach of trust (s 316(2)), cheating and dishonestly inducing delivery (s 318(4)).
General rules
  • s 359(3): abetment of, or attempt at, a compoundable offence is compoundable in the same way.
  • s 359(4)(a): for a minor or person of unsound mind, a competent person may compound with the court's permission.
  • s 359(4)(b): if the victim is dead, his legal representative may compound with the court's permission.
  • s 359(5): after commitment or conviction with appeal pending, only with leave of the court concerned.
  • s 359(6): the High Court or Sessions Court may allow compounding in revision.
  • s 359(7): no compounding where previous conviction exposes the accused to enhanced punishment.
  • s 359(8): compounding has the effect of acquittal.

  • Compounding may be effected at any stage before judgment, subject to the leave requirements above.

  • The court must be satisfied that the composition is voluntary and by the person entitled to compound.
Non-compoundable offences and quashing
  • Offences against society, such as murder, rape and dowry death, are non-compoundable.
  • Gian Singh v State of Punjab (2012): the High Court may quash non-compoundable offences of a private character on settlement under s 482 CrPC (now s 528 BNSS).
  • Quashing is not permitted for heinous offences or offences under special statutes such as the Prevention of Corruption Act.
  • Narinder Singh v State of Punjab (2014): guidelines for quashing on settlement, including for attempt to murder (BNS s 109 (s 307 IPC)).
  • Parbatbhai Aahir v State of Gujarat (2017): summary of principles for quashing.
  • Ramgopal v State of MP (2021): the power extends to cases after conviction, for private offences.
  • Shimbhu v State of Haryana (2014): a compromise in a rape case cannot reduce the sentence.
Comparison and rationale
  • Compounding requires the victim's consent; withdrawal under s 360 is by the Public Prosecutor.
  • Compounding is distinct from plea bargaining, in which the accused is convicted.
  • Settlements may be recorded through Lok Adalats for compoundable offences.
  • The rationale is that private wrongs are better settled by reconciliation, which also relieves courts of arrears.

Topic 3.2

Provisions as to accused persons of unsound mind (ss 367–391)

Long Answers13 marks each

Explain the procedure of trying an accused person who is of unsound mind in a criminal court.

Basis
  • Incapacity to make a defence at trial is distinct from the defence of insanity at the time of the act (BNS s 22 (s 84 IPC)).
  • Trying a person who cannot understand the proceedings violates the fair-trial guarantee of Article 21.
Inquiry before a Magistrate: s 367 BNSS (s 328 CrPC)
  • If the Magistrate has reason to believe the accused is of unsound mind and incapable of making a defence, he inquires into that fact.
  • The accused is examined by the Civil Surgeon or another medical officer, who is examined as a witness.
  • The Magistrate may refer him to a psychiatrist or clinical psychologist; a dissatisfied party may appeal to a Medical Board.
  • If he is incapable but a prima facie case exists, the proceedings are postponed.
  • If no prima facie case exists, the accused is discharged and dealt with under s 369.
Trial before a court: s 368 (s 329 CrPC)
  • If at trial the accused appears incapable of defence, the court first tries the fact of unsoundness and incapacity.
  • The court considers medical and other evidence and records a finding.
  • If incapable, the trial is postponed.
  • If, on the record, no prima facie case exists, the court discharges him instead.
Release and resumption: ss 369–371 (ss 330–332 CrPC)
  • s 369: release on security if he can be cared for and prevented from harming himself or others.
  • If release is not possible, he is kept in a facility or place of safety and the State Government is informed.
  • s 370: the inquiry or trial resumes when he ceases to be of unsound mind.
  • s 371: on reappearance, if capable, the proceedings continue; if not, s 369 applies again.
Unsoundness at the time of the act: ss 372–374 (ss 333–335 CrPC)
  • s 372: if at inquiry it appears he was of unsound mind when the act was done, the Magistrate proceeds with the case.
  • s 373: on acquittal on that ground, the finding states whether he committed the act.
  • s 374: a person so acquitted is detained in safe custody or delivered to a relative or friend.
Subsequent provisions: ss 375–378 (ss 336–339 CrPC)
  • s 375: the State may empower the officer in charge of a jail to discharge functions under s 374.
  • s 376: procedure where a detained prisoner is reported capable of making his defence.
  • s 377: procedure where a detained person is declared fit for release.
  • s 378: delivery to the care of a relative or friend on security.
Case law
  • Bapu v State of Rajasthan (2007): only legal insanity, not medical insanity, excuses under BNS s 22 (s 84 IPC).
  • The burden of proving insanity at the time of the act lies on the accused (BSA s 108; s 105 Evidence Act).
  • Accused X v State of Maharashtra (2019): severe mental illness after conviction bars execution of a death sentence, which reflects the same fair-trial principle.

  • Ratan Lal v State of Madhya Pradesh (1970): the relevant time for insanity under BNS s 22 (s 84 IPC) is the moment the act was committed.

Topic 3.3

Judgement (ss 392–406)

Short Answers2 marks each

Define conviction and acquittal.

Neither is defined: conviction is a judicial finding of guilt followed by sentence; acquittal is a finding of not guilty (ss 255, 258, 271, 278 BNSS) that bars retrial (s 337).

What shall be the language and content of judgment?

s 393 BNSS (s 354 CrPC): in the language of the court; it states the points for determination, the decision and reasons, the offence, section and punishment, or the direction to set the accused at liberty.

Long Answers13 marks each

Explain the procedure for passing judgment by a criminal court.

Pronouncement: s 392 BNSS (s 353 CrPC)
  • Judgment is pronounced in open court immediately after the trial ends, or on a later date notified to the parties.
  • s 392(1) (new): pronouncement within 45 days of the termination of trial.
  • Modes: delivering the whole judgment, reading it out, or reading the operative part and explaining its substance.
  • The judgment is signed and dated by the presiding officer.
  • The accused, if in custody, is brought to court or appears by audio-video means.
  • s 392(7): a judgment is not invalid merely because a party was absent or notice was defective.
Hearing on sentence
  • ss 258(2), 271(2): after conviction the accused is heard on sentence, unless probation is granted.
  • Allauddin Mian v State of Bihar (1989): the hearing is substantive; the court considers mitigating and aggravating factors.
Language and contents: s 393
  • Written in the language of the court.
  • Contains the points for determination, the decision on them and the reasons.
  • On conviction, specifies the offence, the section of the BNS or other law and the punishment.
  • On acquittal, states the offence and directs that the accused be set at liberty.
  • Where it is doubtful under which of two sections the offence falls, the court states this and passes judgment in the alternative.
  • Reasons for the sentence awarded are stated; for life imprisonment or death, special reasons for death.
  • Where imprisonment of less than three months is imposed for an offence punishable with one year or more, reasons are recorded.
Ancillary orders
  • s 394 (s 356 CrPC): order requiring a previously convicted offender to notify his address.
  • s 395 (s 357 CrPC): compensation to the victim out of the fine or otherwise.
  • s 399 (s 358 CrPC): compensation to a person groundlessly arrested.
  • s 400 (s 359 CrPC): costs to the complainant in non-cognizable cases.
  • s 401 (s 360 CrPC): release on probation of good conduct or after admonition.
  • s 402 (s 361 CrPC): special reasons where probation is not given to an eligible offender.
After judgment
  • s 403 (s 362 CrPC): once signed, the judgment cannot be altered except to correct clerical or arithmetical errors.
  • s 404 (s 363 CrPC): a copy is given to the accused free of cost.
  • s 405 (s 364 CrPC): original judgment filed with the record; translation where needed.
  • s 406 (s 365 CrPC): the Court of Session sends a copy of its finding and sentence to the District Magistrate.
Authority
  • Anil Rai v State of Bihar (2001): inordinate delay in pronouncing judgment denies justice; the BNSS's 45-day limit gives statutory force to this.

Topic 3.4

Submission of death sentence for confirmation to the High Court (ss 407–412)

Situational6 marks each

Mr. Bhagat is convicted for an offence of murder with the death penalty. (a) Can he file an appeal against the conviction? Explain. (b) Explain the law relating to confirmation of the death penalty.

  • Issue: appeal by a person sentenced to death, and the confirmation procedure.
  • Law: s 415(2) BNSS (s 374(2) CrPC); ss 407–412 BNSS (ss 366–371 CrPC); Art 115(a), Limitation Act, 1963 (30 days); Bachan Singh v State of Punjab (1980).
  • Application (a): Bhagat may appeal to the High Court as of right against conviction and sentence; the appeal and the reference for confirmation are heard together.
  • Application (b): the Sessions Court submits the proceedings to the High Court and the sentence is not executed until confirmed (s 407); the High Court may direct further inquiry or evidence (s 408); it may confirm, pass another sentence, convict of another offence, order a new trial, or acquit, but not before the appeal period expires or the appeal is decided (s 409); confirmation is signed by at least two judges (s 410), with a difference referred under s 433 (s 411); the order is sent to the Sessions Court (s 412); death is imposed only in the "rarest of rare" case (Bachan Singh).
  • Conclusion: Bhagat has a statutory appeal, and his sentence cannot be executed without High Court confirmation; mercy petitions lie thereafter under s 472 and Arts 72, 161.

Topic 3.5

Appeals (ss 413–435)

Short Answers2 marks each

Define Appeal.

Not defined; a statutory remedy by which a superior court re-examines a lower court's decision; under s 413 BNSS (s 372 CrPC) no appeal lies except as provided by law.

Explain two kinds of appeal.

Appeal against conviction (s 415 BNSS; s 374 CrPC) by the convicted person; appeal against acquittal (s 419; s 378 CrPC) by the State, complainant or victim.

Whether a person can file an appeal against the order of a lower court under B.N.S.S., and what is the time limit for such an appeal?

Yes, where a provision such as s 415 or s 419 grants it; under the Limitation Act, 1963, 30 days (60 days to the High Court) against conviction (Art 115), and 90 days for a State appeal against acquittal (Art 114).

Short Notes6 marks each

Appeal from conviction.

  • s 413 BNSS (s 372 CrPC): no appeal lies except as provided by the Sanhita or other law.
  • s 415(1) (s 374(1) CrPC): conviction by the High Court in its extraordinary original criminal jurisdiction: appeal to the Supreme Court.
  • s 415(2): conviction by a Sessions Judge, or by another court with sentence over seven years: appeal to the High Court.
  • s 415(3): conviction by a Magistrate, or orders under s 136 or s 401: appeal to the Court of Session.
  • Appeals in rape cases are to be disposed of within six months of filing.
  • s 416 (s 375 CrPC): no appeal on a plea of guilty, except as to the extent or legality of the sentence.
  • s 417 (s 376 CrPC): no appeal in petty cases of small sentences.
  • s 421 (s 380 CrPC): where co-accused have an appeal, others convicted at the same trial may also appeal.
  • s 425 (s 384 CrPC): summary dismissal if there is no sufficient ground.
  • s 427(b) (s 386(b) CrPC): the appellate court may reverse and acquit or order retrial, alter the finding, or reduce the sentence, but may not enhance it.
  • s 430 (s 389 CrPC): suspension of sentence and bail pending appeal.
  • Limitation: 30 days, or 60 days to the High Court (Art 115, Limitation Act).

Situational6 marks each

Ram is tried for an offence of attempt to murder of Shyam punishable u/s 307 of IPC and is acquitted. (a) Can Shyam prefer an appeal against the said order? (b) To which court shall an appeal lie against the above order?

  • Issue: whether a victim may appeal against acquittal, and the forum.
  • Law: s 413 proviso BNSS (s 372 proviso CrPC): the victim may appeal against acquittal, conviction for a lesser offence, or inadequate compensation, to the court to which appeals ordinarily lie against conviction; s 419 (s 378 CrPC); Mallikarjun Kodagali v State of Karnataka (2018).
  • Application (a): Shyam, the injured person, is a victim (s 2(1)(y)) and may appeal as of right without leave.
  • Application (b): attempt to murder (BNS s 109 (s 307 IPC)) is tried by the Court of Session, against whose conviction an appeal lies to the High Court; Shyam's appeal therefore lies to the High Court; the State may also appeal to the High Court under s 419(1)(b).
  • Conclusion: Shyam may appeal to the High Court.

X and Y are tried for murder. X, the main accused, is convicted and sentenced to life imprisonment. However, the Court acquitted Y. The State filed an appeal against the acquittal of Y. X also filed an appeal against his conviction. Unfortunately, X and Y both died in an accident. (a) What is the status of the appeal filed by the State against the acquittal of Y? (b) Advise the relatives of X, who desire to prosecute the appeal filed by X.

  • Issue: abatement of appeals on the death of the accused and of the appellant.
  • Law: s 435 BNSS (s 394 CrPC).
  • Application (a): under s 435(1), an appeal against acquittal under s 419 finally abates on the death of the accused; the State's appeal against Y abates.
  • Application (b): under s 435(2), other appeals abate on the appellant's death; but by the proviso, where the appeal is against a sentence of death or imprisonment, a near relative (parent, spouse, lineal descendant, brother or sister) may, within 30 days of death, apply for leave to continue; X's relatives should so apply to clear his name.
  • Conclusion: the State's appeal ends; X's relatives may continue his appeal with leave.

Sanjay is convicted by the High Court in a trial before it by exercising its extraordinary original jurisdiction. (a) Explain the relevant provisions. (b) Where can Sanjay prefer an appeal?

  • Issue: forum of appeal from a High Court's original criminal trial.
  • Law: s 447 BNSS (s 407 CrPC) (High Court may try a case itself); s 415(1) (s 374(1) CrPC); Art 134.
  • Application (a): the High Court acquires extraordinary original jurisdiction by transferring a case to itself under s 447 and tries it as a Court of Session would.
  • Application (b): s 415(1) gives an appeal to the Supreme Court; Art 134(1) also provides for appeals in specified cases.
  • Conclusion: Sanjay's appeal lies to the Supreme Court.

Raj was convicted by the trial court under B.N.S.S. for an attempt to cause hurt and sentenced to 2 years. (a) What can the appellate court do in this case? (b) What will the appellate court look at before deciding?

  • Issue: the powers and approach of the appellate court in an appeal from conviction.
  • Law: s 415(3) BNSS (appeal from a Magistrate to the Sessions Court); s 427(b) (s 386(b) CrPC); ss 426, 432.
  • Application (a): the Sessions Court may reverse the conviction and acquit or discharge Raj, or order a retrial; alter the finding and maintain the sentence; or reduce the sentence; it cannot increase it in his own appeal, and in any event not beyond the trial court's powers.
  • Application (b): it peruses the record, hears Raj or his pleader and the Public Prosecutor (s 426), reappraises the evidence as a final court of fact, and may take further evidence (s 432); it also considers suspension of sentence and bail (s 430).
  • Conclusion: the appellate court may confirm, reduce or set aside the conviction after reappraising the evidence.

Long Answers13 marks each

What is an appeal? When can an appeal be filed in an appellate court? Explain.

Meaning
  • An appeal is a statutory remedy by which a superior court re-examines a lower court's decision on facts and law.
  • s 413 BNSS (s 372 CrPC): no appeal lies except as provided by the Sanhita or other law.
  • There is no inherent right of appeal; it is a creation of statute, but one appeal on facts is part of fair procedure.
Appeal against conviction
  • s 415(1): from the High Court's extraordinary original jurisdiction, to the Supreme Court.
  • s 415(2): from a Sessions Judge, or any court imposing more than seven years, to the High Court.
  • s 415(3): from a Magistrate, or orders under ss 136 and 401, to the Sessions Court.
  • s 416: no appeal on a plea of guilty, except on the extent or legality of sentence.
  • s 417: no appeal in petty cases.
Appeal against acquittal
  • s 419(1)(a) (s 378 CrPC): the District Magistrate may direct the PP to appeal to the Sessions Court against a Magistrate's acquittal in a cognizable, non-bailable offence.
  • s 419(1)(b): the State may appeal to the High Court against other acquittals.
  • s 419(3): appeal to the High Court only with its leave.
  • s 419(4): in a complaint case, the complainant may appeal with special leave of the High Court.
Victim's appeal
  • s 413 proviso: against acquittal, conviction for a lesser offence or inadequate compensation.
  • Mallikarjun Kodagali v State of Karnataka (2018): the victim needs no leave.
Appeal against sentence
  • s 418 (s 377 CrPC): the State may appeal against an inadequate sentence; the accused may plead for acquittal or reduction.
Other appeals
  • s 414 (s 373 CrPC): against orders for security or refusal of sureties.
  • s 420 (s 379 CrPC): where the High Court reverses an acquittal and sentences to death, life or ten years or more, appeal to the Supreme Court.
Procedure
  • s 423: petition of appeal with a copy of the judgment.
  • s 424: an appellant in jail presents it through the officer in charge.
  • s 425: summary dismissal after hearing, if there is no sufficient ground.
  • s 426: notice and hearing of the appellant and the PP.
  • s 427: powers to reverse, alter, reduce or increase the sentence (in an appeal for increase), or order retrial.
Ancillary matters
  • s 430: suspension of sentence and bail pending appeal.
  • s 432: additional evidence where necessary.
  • s 435: abatement on death of the accused or appellant, with near relatives' right to continue.
Limitation
  • Art 115 of the Limitation Act, 1963: 30 days, or 60 days to the High Court, against conviction; Art 114: 90 days for a State appeal against acquittal, which ensures finality while preserving a meaningful review.

Topic 3.6

Reference and revision (ss 436–445)

Short Answers2 marks each

What is the difference between Reference and Revision?

Reference is made by a subordinate court to the High Court on a question of law or validity of a statute (s 436 BNSS; s 395 CrPC); revision is the superior court's examination of a lower court's order for legality and propriety (s 438; s 397 CrPC).

Explain the references under BNSS, 2023.

s 436: mandatory reference where a pending case turns on the validity of an Act, Ordinance or Regulation that the court thinks invalid; discretionary reference of any question of law by a Court of Session; s 407: reference of death sentences for confirmation.

What is review?

Reconsideration of its own judgment by the same court; criminal courts have no such power, as s 403 BNSS (s 362 CrPC) allows only correction of clerical or arithmetical errors (State of Kerala v M.M. Manikantan Nair, 2001).

Short Notes6 marks each

Reference.

  • s 436(1) BNSS (s 395(1) CrPC): a court must refer a case to the High Court where four conditions are met.
  • The pending case involves a question about the validity of an Act, Ordinance or Regulation or a provision of one.
  • Determination of that question is necessary for disposal of the case.
  • The court is of opinion that the provision is invalid.
  • The provision has not already been declared invalid by the High Court or the Supreme Court.
  • The court states the case, records its opinion with reasons, and refers it.
  • s 436(2): a Court of Session may refer any question of law arising in a pending case.
  • s 436(3): pending the decision, the court may commit the accused to jail or release him on bail.
  • s 437 (s 396 CrPC): the High Court decides and sends a copy of its order; the lower court disposes of the case in conformity.
  • The High Court may direct who shall pay the costs of the reference.
  • Reference is distinct from the death-sentence reference under s 407 and the difference-of-opinion reference under s 433.
  • Its purpose is to secure an authoritative ruling on constitutional and legal questions, since subordinate courts cannot strike down statutes.

Reference and revision.

Point Reference Revision
Provision s 436 BNSS (s 395 CrPC) ss 438–443 BNSS (ss 397–402 CrPC)
Initiated by Subordinate court itself Party's application or the superior court suo motu
Court deciding High Court only High Court or Court of Session
Subject matter Validity of a statute or a question of law Correctness, legality or propriety of any finding, sentence or order
Stage Pending case, before decision After the order is made
Interlocutory orders Not relevant Excluded (s 438(2))

Situational6 marks each

X filed a complaint against Y for dishonour of cheque. The trial court convicted Y and sentenced him to 2 years of imprisonment. The court also directed Y to pay compensation of Rs. 70,000 to X. X preferred a revision against this order to the sessions court. X's revision application was allowed and compensation was increased to Rs. 1,00,000. (a) Can X file a revision against the order of the sessions court seeking further increase in compensation? (b) Can Y file a revision against the order of the sessions court?

  • Issue: whether a second revision lies after a Sessions Court's revisional order.
  • Law: s 438(3) BNSS (s 397(3) CrPC): once a person applies to either the High Court or the Sessions Judge, no further application by the same person is entertained by the other; s 440(3) (s 399(3) CrPC); s 528 (s 482 CrPC); Krishnan v Krishnaveni (1997).
  • Application (a): X chose the Sessions Court; a second revision by X to the High Court is barred; he may invoke s 528 only in a rare case of manifest miscarriage of justice (Krishnan).
  • Application (b): the bar applies only to "the same person"; Y did not apply earlier, so Y may seek revision of the Sessions Court's order before the High Court (s 442), or invoke s 528.
  • Conclusion: X is barred from a second revision; Y may approach the High Court.

Long Answers13 marks each

Discuss the provisions for revision and review of court under BNSS, 2023.

Nature of revision
  • Revision is a supervisory power to correct errors of jurisdiction, law or procedure resulting in miscarriage of justice.
  • It is discretionary and cannot be claimed as of right.
Calling for records: s 438 (s 397 CrPC)
  • The High Court or Sessions Judge may call for the record of any inferior criminal court within its jurisdiction.
  • The purpose is to examine the correctness, legality or propriety of any finding, sentence or order and the regularity of proceedings.
  • s 438(2): no revision against interlocutory orders.
  • s 438(3): an application to one forum bars a further application by the same person to the other.
Power to order inquiry: s 439 (s 398 CrPC)
  • The revisional court may direct further inquiry into a dismissed complaint.
  • It may direct inquiry into the case of a discharged accused, only after hearing him.
Sessions Judge and Additional Sessions Judge: ss 440, 441
  • s 440(1): the Sessions Judge has the revisional powers of the High Court under s 442(1).
  • s 440(3): his decision on a person's application is final as to that person.
  • s 441: an Additional Sessions Judge exercises these powers in cases transferred to him.
High Court's powers: s 442 (s 401 CrPC)
  • The High Court may exercise the powers of an appellate court under ss 427, 430, 432 and 433.
  • s 442(2): no order to the prejudice of the accused without hearing him.
  • s 442(3): no conversion of an acquittal into a conviction in revision.
  • s 442(4): where an appeal lies but none was brought, the party who could have appealed cannot seek revision.
  • s 442(5): a revision filed under a mistaken belief that no appeal lies may be treated as an appeal.
  • Enhancement of sentence in revision is permitted after notice to the accused.
Withdrawal: s 443 (s 402 CrPC)
  • The High Court may withdraw or transfer revision cases to itself.
Case law on revision
  • Amar Nath v State of Haryana (1977): "interlocutory order" means a purely interim order not deciding rights.
  • Madhu Limaye v State of Maharashtra (1977): intermediate orders that finally decide an issue are revisable.
  • Krishnan v Krishnaveni (1997): the High Court's inherent power survives the bar on a second revision.
Review
  • s 403 (s 362 CrPC): no court may alter or review its judgment once signed, except for clerical or arithmetical errors.
  • State of Kerala v M.M. Manikantan Nair (2001): criminal courts, including the High Court, have no power of review.
  • Hari Singh Mann v Harbhajan Singh Bajwa (2001): s 482 cannot be used to review a final order.
  • A court may recall an order made without jurisdiction or without hearing a party, which is not review.
  • The Supreme Court alone may review its criminal judgments under Art 137; the bar on review secures finality, while revision corrects error.

Topic 3.7

Transfer of criminal cases (ss 446–452)

Short Notes6 marks each

Power of High Court to transfer cases and appeals.

  • s 447 BNSS (s 407 CrPC): the High Court may transfer cases and appeals.
  • s 447(1)(a): where a fair and impartial inquiry or trial cannot be had in a subordinate court.
  • s 447(1)(b): where a question of law of unusual difficulty is likely to arise.
  • s 447(1)(c): where a provision requires it, or for the general convenience of parties and witnesses or for the ends of justice.
  • Order (i): an offence may be inquired into or tried by a court otherwise not competent.
  • Order (ii)–(iii): a case or appeal may be transferred to another subordinate court of equal or superior jurisdiction, or committed to the Court of Session.
  • Order (iv): the High Court may try the case itself.
  • s 447(2): action on the lower court's report, an interested party's application or the High Court's own initiative.
  • s 447(3), (5): the application is by motion supported by affidavit; an accused must give the Public Prosecutor 24 hours' notice.
  • s 447(6): the High Court may stay proceedings in the subordinate court pending the application.
  • s 447(7): a frivolous or vexatious application may be dismissed with compensation to the opposite party.
  • Maneka Sanjay Gandhi v Rani Jethmalani (1979): the test is a reasonable apprehension of injustice, not a mere allegation.

Procedure and grounds to transfer a criminal case.

  • s 446 (s 406 CrPC): the Supreme Court may transfer a case or appeal from one High Court or its subordinate court to another, when expedient for the ends of justice.
  • s 446: application by the Attorney-General or an interested party, by motion supported by affidavit.
  • s 447: the High Court's power, on the grounds of fair trial, difficult questions of law, convenience or the ends of justice.
  • s 448 (s 408 CrPC): the Sessions Judge may transfer cases within his division for the ends of justice.
  • s 449 (s 409 CrPC): the Sessions Judge may withdraw cases or appeals from Additional Sessions Judges or the CJM.
  • s 450 (s 410 CrPC): the CJM may withdraw or recall cases from subordinate Magistrates.
  • s 451 (s 411 CrPC): an Executive Magistrate may make over or withdraw cases.
  • s 452 (s 412 CrPC): reasons for such orders must be recorded.
  • Grounds recognised: bias or interest of the judge, hostile local atmosphere, threat to the accused or witnesses and convenience.
  • Procedure: motion with affidavit; notice to the PP; stay of proceedings may be granted.
  • Abdul Nazar Madani v State of Tamil Nadu (2000): apprehension must be reasonable, not imaginary.
  • Captain Amarinder Singh v Prakash Singh Badal (2009): transfer is ordered only where a fair trial is in real doubt, since it affects the forum chosen by law.

Topic 3.8

Disposal of property pending and at the conclusion of trial (ss 497–505)

Long Answers13 marks each

Discuss the provisions relating to disposal of property pending trial and at the conclusion of trial.

Pending trial: s 497 BNSS (s 451 CrPC)
  • When property is produced before a criminal court, the court may order its proper custody pending the conclusion of the inquiry or trial.
  • Property subject to speedy or natural decay may be sold or disposed of.
  • s 497(2)–(3) (new): within 14 days of production, the court prepares a statement of the property and has it photographed or videographed.
  • s 497(4): the statement, photographs and video are used as evidence at the trial.
  • s 497(5): within 30 days of preparing the statement, the court orders disposal, destruction, confiscation or delivery.
  • Explanation: "property" includes property and documents produced, in custody or used in an offence.
At conclusion of trial: s 498 (s 452 CrPC)
  • The court may order disposal by destruction, confiscation or delivery to the person entitled.
  • Delivery may be on a bond, with or without sureties, to restore the property if the order is modified.
  • A Court of Session may direct the CJM to deliver the property.
  • The order is not carried out for two months, or until an appeal is decided, except for livestock or perishable property.
  • "Property" includes property into which the original has been converted or exchanged.
Ancillary provisions
  • s 499 (s 453 CrPC): money found on the accused may be paid to an innocent purchaser of stolen property.
  • s 500 (s 454 CrPC): an aggrieved person may appeal against orders under ss 498 and 499.
  • s 501 (s 455 CrPC): destruction of libellous, obscene and similar matter on conviction.
  • s 502 (s 456 CrPC): on conviction for an offence involving force, criminal force or intimidation, the court may restore possession of immovable property.
  • s 502: the order must be made within one month of conviction.
  • s 503 (s 457 CrPC): property seized by police and not produced in court is reported to the Magistrate, who orders its disposal.
  • s 503(2): if the owner is unknown, a proclamation calls on claimants to appear within six months.
  • s 504 (s 458 CrPC): if no claimant appears, the property is at the State's disposal and may be sold.
  • s 505 (s 459 CrPC): perishable property or property worth less than the prescribed value may be sold at once.
Related provisions
  • s 107 (new): attachment and forfeiture of proceeds of crime by court order during investigation or trial.
  • Special statutes with their own disposal procedures, such as s 52A of the NDPS Act, prevail.
  • Article 300A requires that no person be deprived of property save by authority of law.
Case law
  • Basavva Kom Dyamangouda Patil v State of Mysore (1977): the object is to prevent property from being kept unused or misused.
  • General Insurance Council v State of Andhra Pradesh (2010): seized vehicles should be released promptly to owners or insurers.
  • Sunderbhai Ambalal Desai v State of Gujarat (2002): vehicles and valuables should be returned on panchnama, photographs and security, rather than left to rot in police stations; the BNSS's 14-day and 30-day limits give this direction statutory form.

Topic 3.9

Provisions as to bails and bonds (ss 478–496)

Short Answers2 marks each

Who can give bail in a bailable offence?

The officer in charge of the police station, or the court before which the accused appears (s 478 BNSS; s 436 CrPC); bail is a right.

What is an Anticipatory bail?

A direction by the High Court or Court of Session under s 482 BNSS (s 438 CrPC) that a person apprehending arrest for a non-bailable offence be released on bail if arrested.

What is the meaning of bail bond?

s 2(1)(d) BNSS: an undertaking for release with surety (a "bond", s 2(1)(e), is an undertaking without surety).

Short Notes6 marks each

Bailable and non-bailable offences.

Point Bailable offence Non-bailable offence
Definition s 2(1)(c): shown bailable in the First Schedule or by other law Any other offence
Nature of bail Right of the accused (s 478) Discretion of the court (ss 480, 483)
Who grants Police officer in charge or court Court only; police cannot grant
Gravity Generally less serious (up to 3 years, broadly) Serious offences (death, life, 7 years and more, broadly)
Conditions Personal bond or sureties; indigent released on own bond Mandatory conditions for grave offences (s 480(3))
Cancellation Only on later breach (s 478(2)); Rasiklal v Kishore Khanchand Wadhwani (2009) Court may cancel and order arrest (ss 480(5), 483(3))

Anticipatory Bail.

  • s 482(1) BNSS (s 438 CrPC): a person with reason to believe he may be arrested for a non-bailable offence may apply to the High Court or the Court of Session.
  • The court may direct that, in the event of arrest, he be released on bail.
  • The direction takes effect only on arrest; it is a pre-arrest legal process.
  • s 482(2)(i): condition to be available for interrogation by police as required.
  • s 482(2)(ii): condition not to induce, threaten or promise any person acquainted with the facts.
  • s 482(2)(iii): condition not to leave India without the court's permission.
  • s 482(2)(iv): any condition under s 480(3).
  • s 482(3): if arrested without warrant, he is released on bail on furnishing it; a Magistrate taking cognizance issues a bailable warrant.
  • s 482(4): not available for rape of a girl under 16 and gang rape of a girl under 18 (BNS ss 65, 70(2)).
  • Gurbaksh Singh Sibbia v State of Punjab (1980): the power is wide and should not be fettered by rigid rules.
  • Sushila Aggarwal v State (NCT of Delhi) (2020): protection need not be limited in time and may last till the end of trial.
  • Siddharam Satlingappa Mhetre v State of Maharashtra (2011): the court weighs the nature of the accusation, antecedents, risk of flight and motive of the accusation.

Special Powers of High Court and Court of Session regarding bail.

  • s 483(1)(a) BNSS (s 439(1)(a) CrPC): may direct release on bail of any person accused of an offence and in custody.
  • The restrictions of s 480(1) on Magistrates do not bind these courts.
  • May impose any condition necessary for the purposes in s 480(3).
  • s 483(1)(b): may set aside or modify any condition imposed by a Magistrate.
  • Proviso: notice to the Public Prosecutor before bail in offences exclusively triable by the Court of Session or punishable with life imprisonment.
  • Notice may be dispensed with where, for recorded reasons, it is not practicable.
  • s 483(2): in aggravated rape of children, notice to the PP within 15 days and the informant's presence at the hearing are mandatory.
  • s 483(3): may direct arrest and committal of any person released under the Chapter (cancellation).
  • Concurrent jurisdiction: an applicant ordinarily approaches the Sessions Court first.
  • s 482: these courts alone grant anticipatory bail.
  • Kalyan Chandra Sarkar v Rajesh Ranjan (2004): bail orders must reflect the relevant factors, not be mechanical.
  • Dolat Ram v State of Haryana (1995): cancellation requires supervening circumstances, such as tampering or misuse of liberty.

Situational6 marks each

Mr. Rana is arrested for an alleged offence of rape. (a) What is the nature of the offence committed by him? (b) Can he be released on bail? When? (c) Can he compound the offence? Why?

  • Issue: classification of rape, bail and compounding.
  • Law: BNS s 64 (s 376 IPC): rape, punishable with at least ten years, extending to life; First Schedule: cognizable, non-bailable, non-compoundable, triable by the Court of Session; ss 480, 483 BNSS; s 359; Shimbhu v State of Haryana (2014).
  • Application (a): rape is cognizable, non-bailable, non-compoundable and Sessions-triable.
  • Application (b): a Magistrate cannot grant bail as the offence is punishable with life (s 480(1)(i)), so Rana must apply to the Sessions Court or High Court under s 483, which hear the PP (and the informant in aggravated child rape cases) and weigh the gravity, evidence, risk of tampering with the victim and flight; bail is also available by default if the charge-sheet is not filed within 90 days (s 187(3)).
  • Application (c): rape is not listed in s 359, so it cannot be compounded; it is an offence against society, and a compromise cannot reduce the sentence (Shimbhu).
  • Conclusion: bail is possible only from the Sessions Court or High Court on merits; compounding is barred.

Mr. A is arrested and produced before the court for committing a non-bailable offence. (a) Can bail be given by the court? Explain. (b) What is the role of the court while granting bail? Explain relevant case laws.

  • Issue: discretion to grant bail in a non-bailable offence, and the factors.
  • Law: s 480 (s 437 CrPC), s 483 (s 439 CrPC); Gudikanti Narasimhulu v Public Prosecutor (1978); Prahlad Singh Bhati v NCT of Delhi (2001); Sanjay Chandra v CBI (2012); Satender Kumar Antil v CBI (2022).
  • Application (a): yes; a Magistrate may grant bail unless there are reasonable grounds for believing A guilty of an offence punishable with death or life, or A has the disqualifying previous convictions; the Sessions Court and High Court may grant it in any case.
  • Application (b): the court weighs the nature of the accusation and punishment, the evidence, the risk of tampering or flight, the accused's antecedents and the public interest, records reasons and imposes conditions (s 480(3)); bail is the rule and jail the exception (State of Rajasthan v Balchand, 1977).
  • Conclusion: bail may be granted in the court's judicial discretion on these factors.

A woman is accused of a heinous crime but pleads for bail, citing that she has a young child to care for. The prosecution opposes the bail, stating the severity of the offence. (a) What special provisions does BNSS, 2023 provide for bail to women? (b) Can the court deny bail solely based on the gravity of the offence?

  • Issue: bail for women accused of grave offences, and the weight of gravity.
  • Law: s 480(1) proviso BNSS (s 437(1) proviso CrPC); s 479; Sanjay Chandra v CBI (2012); P. Chidambaram v Directorate of Enforcement (2019).
  • Application (a): a court may release a woman even where the offence is punishable with death or life; her role as carer of a young child is a relevant humanitarian factor; a first-time undertrial is released after one-third of the maximum sentence (s 479).
  • Application (b): gravity is a relevant but not the sole factor; the court must also consider the evidence, the risk of flight or tampering and her personal circumstances; refusal on gravity alone, without these, is an improper exercise of discretion (Sanjay Chandra).
  • Conclusion: the court may grant bail with conditions; it cannot refuse it on gravity alone.

Mr. Danny believed that he could be arrested on an accusation of a non-bailable offence. (a) What remedy can you suggest to Mr. Danny? (b) What conditions can the court impose while granting bail to a person apprehending arrest?

  • Issue: remedy for apprehended arrest, and conditions.
  • Law: s 482 BNSS (s 438 CrPC); Gurbaksh Singh Sibbia v State of Punjab (1980); Sushila Aggarwal v State (NCT of Delhi) (2020).
  • Application (a): Danny should apply to the Court of Session or High Court for anticipatory bail, showing specific facts that justify his belief of arrest.
  • Application (b): to make himself available for interrogation; not to induce or threaten witnesses; not to leave India without permission; any condition under s 480(3); and other proportionate conditions such as reporting to the police station or surrendering his passport.
  • Conclusion: anticipatory bail under s 482 is the appropriate remedy.

Long Answers13 marks each

What is bail? Explain the law relating to bails.

Meaning
  • s 2(1)(b) BNSS (new definition): release of a person accused or suspected of an offence from custody on conditions, on execution of a bond or bail bond.
  • s 2(1)(d), (e): bail bond is an undertaking with surety; bond is an undertaking without surety.
  • State of Rajasthan v Balchand (1977): the basic rule is bail, not jail.
Bailable offences
  • s 2(1)(c): offences shown as bailable in the First Schedule.
  • s 478(1) (s 436 CrPC): bail is a right; the police or court must release on bail.
  • A person unable to furnish bail within a week of arrest is presumed indigent and released on his own bond.
  • s 478(2): a person who breached bail conditions may be refused bail later in the same case.
Non-bailable offences
  • s 480(1) (s 437 CrPC): a court other than the High Court or Sessions Court may grant bail.
  • Not where there are reasonable grounds to believe the accused guilty of an offence punishable with death or life, or he has disqualifying previous convictions.
  • Proviso: a child, a woman, or a sick or infirm person may be released despite these bars (the CrPC said "under the age of sixteen years").
  • s 480(2): release where there are sufficient grounds for further inquiry into guilt.
  • s 480(3): mandatory conditions for offences of seven years or more: attendance, no similar offence, no interference with witnesses.
  • s 480(6): release where a Magistrate's trial is not concluded within 60 days of the first date for evidence.
Superior courts
  • s 483 (s 439 CrPC): special powers of the High Court and Sessions Court in any case.
  • Notice to the PP before bail in Sessions-triable or life-punishable offences.
  • s 482: anticipatory bail by these courts.
Statutory release
  • s 187(3): default bail if the charge-sheet is not filed within 60 or 90 days (Bikramjit Singh v State of Punjab, 2020).
  • s 479 (s 436A CrPC): release after half the maximum sentence, or one-third for first-time offenders.
  • s 430 (s 389 CrPC): suspension of sentence and bail pending appeal.
Bonds
  • s 484 (s 440 CrPC): the amount of the bond must not be excessive (Moti Ram v State of MP, 1978).
  • ss 485–490: execution of bonds, declarations by sureties, discharge from custody and deposit in lieu.
  • s 491 (s 446 CrPC): forfeiture of bond and recovery of the penalty.
Cancellation
  • ss 480(5), 483(3): the court that granted bail, or a superior court, may order re-arrest.
  • Dolat Ram v State of Haryana (1995): cancellation requires supervening misconduct.
Governing principles
  • Gudikanti Narasimhulu v Public Prosecutor (1978): bail is a matter of personal liberty under Article 21.
  • Satender Kumar Antil v CBI (2022): bail is to be decided by categories of offence, with directions to avoid unnecessary detention.

When may bail be taken in case of non-bailable offences?

Introduction
  • A non-bailable offence is any offence not bailable under s 2(1)(c).
  • Bail is discretionary, governed by ss 480 and 483 BNSS.
Bail by a Magistrate: s 480 (s 437 CrPC)
  • s 480(1): a person arrested without warrant or appearing before a court other than the High Court or Sessions Court may be released.
  • (i): not if there are reasonable grounds for believing him guilty of an offence punishable with death or life.
  • (ii): not if previously convicted of an offence punishable with death, life or seven years or more, or twice of a cognizable, non-bailable offence punishable with 3 to seven years.
  • Proviso: a child, a woman, or a sick or infirm person may be released despite (i) and (ii).
  • Proviso: the need for identification by witnesses is not alone a ground to refuse bail.
  • Proviso: the PP must be heard where the offence is punishable with death, life or seven years or more.
  • s 480(2): release where there are no reasonable grounds but sufficient grounds for further inquiry.
  • s 480(3): mandatory conditions for offences of seven years or more and listed offences.
  • s 480(4): reasons recorded.
  • s 480(6): release if the Magistrate's trial is not concluded within 60 days of the first date fixed for evidence.
  • s 480(7): release on bond after trial and before judgment, if there are reasonable grounds to believe him not guilty.
High Court and Court of Session: s 483
  • s 483(1)(a): bail in any case, without the s 480 restrictions.
  • s 483(1)(b): modification of conditions imposed by a Magistrate.
  • Proviso: notice to the PP in Sessions-triable or life-punishable offences.
  • s 483(2): informant's presence in aggravated child rape cases.
Anticipatory and statutory bail
  • s 482: anticipatory bail before arrest.
  • s 187(3): default bail for failure to file the charge-sheet in 60 or 90 days.
  • s 479: release of undertrials after half (first-timers, one-third) of the maximum sentence.
  • s 430: bail pending appeal.
Factors
  • Prahlad Singh Bhati v NCT of Delhi (2001): nature of accusation, severity of punishment, evidence, risk of tampering and public interest.
  • Kalyan Chandra Sarkar v Rajesh Ranjan (2004): prima facie case and reasons must appear in the order.
  • Sanjay Chandra v CBI (2012): gravity alone does not justify refusal.
Cancellation and principle
  • ss 480(5), 483(3): bail may be cancelled for misuse.
  • Gudikanti Narasimhulu (1978): the discretion protects personal liberty under Article 21.

What is the procedure for granting bail under the CrPC, and what factors should the court consider before granting bail?

Procedure
  • In bailable offences, the police officer in charge or the court must release on bail (s 478 BNSS; s 436 CrPC).
  • In non-bailable offences, the accused applies to the Magistrate (s 480 BNSS; s 437 CrPC) or to the Sessions Court or High Court (s 483 BNSS; s 439 CrPC).
  • Anticipatory bail is sought from the Sessions Court or High Court (s 482 BNSS; s 438 CrPC).
  • Notice is given to the Public Prosecutor in grave offences (s 483 proviso BNSS; s 439 proviso CrPC).
  • The court hears both sides and records reasons (s 480(4) BNSS; s 437(4) CrPC).
  • The court fixes the amount of the bond, which must not be excessive (s 484 BNSS; s 440 CrPC).
  • The accused and sureties execute the bond (s 485 BNSS; s 441 CrPC).
  • Sureties declare the number of persons they have stood surety for (s 486 BNSS; s 441A CrPC).
  • If the sureties are insufficient, the court may require fresh sureties (s 488 BNSS; s 443 CrPC).
  • On execution, the court issues an order of release to the jail officer (s 487 BNSS; s 442 CrPC).
  • The court may accept a deposit of money instead of a bond (s 490 BNSS; s 445 CrPC).
  • Conditions are imposed under s 480(3) BNSS (s 437(3) CrPC).
  • On acquittal or conviction, a bond to appear before the appellate court may be required (s 481 BNSS; s 437A CrPC).
  • On breach, the bond is forfeited and the penalty recovered (s 491 BNSS; s 446 CrPC).
Factors
  • Nature and gravity of the accusation.
  • Severity of the punishment on conviction.
  • Character and strength of the evidence.
  • Reasonable apprehension of tampering with evidence or threatening witnesses.
  • Likelihood of the accused absconding.
  • Antecedents and previous convictions.
  • Age, sex, health and infirmity of the accused.
  • Period already spent in custody and likely delay in trial.
  • Existence of a prima facie case.
  • Larger interests of the public or the State.
Authority
  • Prahlad Singh Bhati v NCT of Delhi (2001) and Kalyan Chandra Sarkar v Rajesh Ranjan (2004) set out these factors.
  • Satender Kumar Antil v CBI (2022): bail applications are to be decided within two weeks, and the presumption of innocence guides the decision.

Define bail and bond. State the powers of courts to grant different types of bails. Explain the grounds for denying bail.

Definitions
  • s 2(1)(b) BNSS: bail is release from custody on conditions, on execution of a bond or bail bond.
  • s 2(1)(d): bail bond is an undertaking for release with surety.
  • s 2(1)(e): bond is a personal bond or undertaking for release without surety.
Powers of courts and types of bail
  • s 478: police officer in charge or any court, in bailable offences (regular bail as of right).
  • s 480: Magistrate, in non-bailable offences, subject to restrictions.
  • s 483: Sessions Court and High Court, in any case, without the s 480 restrictions.
  • s 482: Sessions Court and High Court, anticipatory bail.
  • s 187(3): Magistrate, default bail for failure to file the charge-sheet in time.
  • s 479: court, release of undertrials after the prescribed portion of the maximum sentence.
  • s 430(1): appellate court, suspension of sentence and bail pending appeal.
  • s 430(3): trial court, release of a convict intending to appeal where the sentence is 3 years or less.
  • s 480(6): Magistrate, release where trial is not concluded within 60 days.
  • s 480(7): court, release after trial and before judgment.
  • s 481: bond to appear before the appellate court.
  • Interim bail: a judicial practice pending decision of the main application (Lal Kamlendra Pratap Singh v State of UP, 2009).
Grounds for denying bail
  • Reasonable grounds to believe guilt of an offence punishable with death or life (s 480(1)(i)).
  • Disqualifying previous convictions (s 480(1)(ii)).
  • Risk of the accused absconding.
  • Risk of tampering with evidence or influencing witnesses.
  • Likelihood of committing further offences.
  • Gravity of the offence, weighed with other factors.
  • Breach of conditions of earlier bail (s 478(2)).
  • Identity or address not established.
  • Threat to public order or to the victim's safety.
Principles
  • Sanjay Chandra v CBI (2012): bail is not to be withheld as punishment.
  • Satender Kumar Antil v CBI (2022): unnecessary detention of undertrials violates Article 21.

Define Bail and bond. State types of bails. State the conditions on which bail can be given.

Definitions
  • s 2(1)(b): bail is release from custody on conditions, on a bond or bail bond.
  • s 2(1)(d): bail bond is an undertaking with surety.
  • s 2(1)(e): bond is an undertaking without surety.
Types of bail
  • Regular bail in bailable offences (s 478).
  • Regular bail in non-bailable offences (ss 480, 483).
  • Anticipatory bail (s 482).
  • Interim bail pending the main application.
  • Default or statutory bail (s 187(3)).
  • Bail pending appeal (s 430).
  • Release of undertrials after the maximum period (s 479).
  • Bail after trial and before judgment (s 480(7)), and bond to appear in appeal (s 481).
Conditions
  • s 480(3)(a): attend in accordance with the bond.
  • s 480(3)(b): not commit a similar offence.
  • s 480(3)(c): not induce, threaten or promise any person acquainted with the facts or tamper with evidence.
  • s 482(2)(i): anticipatory bail: be available for interrogation.
  • s 482(2)(ii): not induce or threaten witnesses.
  • s 482(2)(iii): not leave India without permission.
  • s 482(2)(iv): any condition under s 480(3).
  • Surrender of passport.
  • Reporting to the police station at stated intervals.
  • Not entering a specified area or contacting the victim.
  • Residing at a stated address and informing the court of changes.
  • Conditions must be proportionate and related to securing attendance and a fair trial (Parvez Noordin Lokhandwalla v State of Maharashtra, 2020).
  • Onerous conditions that amount to denial of bail are impermissible (Moti Ram v State of MP, 1978).
Amount and principle
  • s 484: the bond amount is fixed with regard to the case and is not excessive; the Sessions Court or High Court may reduce it.
  • Satender Kumar Antil v CBI (2022): conditions that the accused cannot meet defeat the purpose of bail.

Topic 3.11

Limitation for taking cognizance and miscellaneous provisions (ss 513–530)

Short Answers2 marks each

Commencement of Period of limitation.

s 515 BNSS (s 469 CrPC): from the date of the offence; or the date it came to the knowledge of the aggrieved person or police; or the date the offender's identity became known.

Explain the limitation for taking cognisance.

s 514 BNSS (s 468 CrPC): six months for fine-only offences, one year for imprisonment up to one year, three years for imprisonment of 1 to three years; no limit for graver offences.

Short Notes6 marks each

Inherent Powers of the High Court.

  • s 528 BNSS (s 482 CrPC): nothing in the Sanhita limits the inherent powers of the High Court.
  • Purpose (i): to give effect to any order under the Sanhita.
  • Purpose (ii): to prevent abuse of the process of any court.
  • Purpose (iii): otherwise to secure the ends of justice.
  • The section saves, and does not create, these powers; they belong to the High Court alone.
  • The power is used to quash FIRs, complaints and proceedings.
  • R.P. Kapur v State of Punjab (1960): quashing where there is a legal bar, no offence on the allegations or no evidence.
  • State of Haryana v Bhajan Lal (1992): seven illustrative categories for quashing.
  • Gian Singh v State of Punjab (2012): quashing of private-character offences on settlement.
  • The power cannot be used to do what the Sanhita expressly bars, such as review (s 403).
  • Neeharika Infrastructure v State of Maharashtra (2021): no blanket "no coercive steps" orders while declining to quash.
  • s 529 (s 483 CrPC): the related duty of continuous superintendence over subordinate criminal courts.

Situational6 marks each

An offence is committed for which the punishment is 2 (two) years. (a) Within what period can cognizance of the offence be taken? (b) From what date does the period of limitation commence? Cite relevant case law.

  • Issue: the limitation period and its starting point for an offence punishable with two years.
  • Law: s 514(2)(c) BNSS (s 468(2)(c) CrPC) (3 years for offences punishable with more than 1 and up to three years); s 515 (s 469 CrPC); Sarah Mathew v Institute of Cardio Vascular Diseases (2014); Japani Sahoo v Chandra Shekhar Mohanty (2007).
  • Application (a): cognizance must be taken within three years; the court may extend this under s 519 if the delay is explained or justice requires.
  • Application (b): time runs from the date of the offence, or from when it became known to the aggrieved person or the police or from when the offender's identity became known; for computing the period, the relevant date is the date of filing the complaint or recording the information, not the date on which the court takes cognizance (Sarah Mathew; Japani Sahoo).
  • Conclusion: three years, counted from the s 515 date to the filing of the complaint.

Long Answers13 marks each

Explain in detail the provisions relating to limitation for taking cognizance of offences under the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), 2023.

Rationale
  • Limitation prevents stale prosecutions, when evidence is lost and memories fade.
  • State of Punjab v Sarwan Singh (1981): limitation is part of the right to speedy justice.
Definition: s 513 (s 467 CrPC)
  • "Period of limitation" is the period specified in s 514 for taking cognizance.
Bar on cognizance: s 514 (s 468 CrPC)
  • s 514(1): no court takes cognizance after the period of limitation expires.
  • s 514(2)(a): six months, if the offence is punishable with fine only.
  • s 514(2)(b): one year, if punishable with imprisonment up to one year.
  • s 514(2)(c): three years, if punishable with imprisonment of more than 1 and up to three years.
  • s 514(3): where offences are tried together, the period is fixed by the most severely punishable offence; offences above three years have no limitation.
Commencement: s 515 (s 469 CrPC)
  • From the date of the offence.
  • If the offence was not known, from the date it first came to the knowledge of the aggrieved person or the police, whichever is earlier.
  • If the offender was not known, from the date his identity first became known; the day of commencement is excluded.
Exclusion of time: s 516 (s 470 CrPC)
  • Time spent prosecuting the offender with due diligence in another court that lacked jurisdiction.
  • Time during which the prosecution was stayed by an injunction or order.
  • Time of notice or sanction required by law.
  • Time during which the offender was absent from India or absconding.
Court closed: s 517 (s 471 CrPC)
  • If the period expires when the court is closed, cognizance may be taken on the day it reopens.
Continuing offence: s 518 (s 472 CrPC)
  • A fresh period begins at every moment the offence continues.
  • Bhagirath Kanoria v State of MP (1984): non-payment of employer's provident fund contribution is a continuing offence.
Extension: s 519 (s 473 CrPC)
  • The court may take cognizance after the period if the delay is properly explained or it is necessary in the interests of justice.
  • State of Himachal Pradesh v Tara Dutt (2000): reasons for condonation must be recorded.
  • Vanka Radhamanohari v Vanka Venkata Reddy (1993): a liberal approach applies to matrimonial offences against women.
Special laws
  • Special statutes may prescribe their own limitation, e.g. s 142 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881.
  • The chapter does not apply where a special law provides otherwise (s 5 BNSS).
Relevant date and case law
  • Sarah Mathew v Institute of Cardio Vascular Diseases (2014): the relevant date is the filing of the complaint or institution of prosecution, not the date of cognizance.
  • Japani Sahoo v Chandra Shekhar Mohanty (2007): a complainant is not to suffer for the court's delay.
  • The BNSS adopts this rule, so that the limitation provisions protect accused persons from stale claims without penalising diligent complainants.

Module 4

Topic 4.1

The Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015

Short Answers · Definitions and Institutions2 marks each

Who has jurisdiction in cases of Juveniles?

The Juvenile Justice Board, exclusively, for children in conflict with law (s 8(1) JJ Act); the Children's Court for a child of 16–18 transferred for trial as an adult (ss 18(3), 19); the Child Welfare Committee for children in need of care (s 29).

Who is juvenile?

s 2(35): a child below 18 years of age; age is reckoned on the date of the offence (s 2(13)).

Explain the term "juvenile in conflict with law".

s 2(13): a child alleged or found to have committed an offence who had not completed 18 years on the date of the offence.

What is meant by "heinous offences" under the JJ Act?

s 2(33): offences for which the minimum punishment under any law is imprisonment for seven years or more (Shilpa Mittal v State (NCT of Delhi), 2020).

Define children Home.

s 2(19): a home established or maintained under s 50 for the care, treatment, education and rehabilitation of children in need of care and protection.

Define observation home.

s 2(40): a home established under s 47 for the temporary reception, care and rehabilitation of a child in conflict with law during the pendency of an inquiry.

What is 'children's court'?

s 2(20): a court under the Commissions for Protection of Child Rights Act, 2005 or a POCSO Special Court; where neither exists, the Court of Session.

What is the role of the Juvenile Justice Board (JJB)?

s 8: exclusive power to inquire into and dispose of cases of children in conflict with law, with legal aid, social investigation and rehabilitative orders (s 18).

What is the role of the Child Welfare Committee?

ss 29, 30: final authority for the care, protection, treatment, development and rehabilitation of children in need of care and protection, including declaring them free for adoption.

What is 'adoption'?

s 2(2): the process by which an adopted child is permanently separated from his biological parents and becomes the lawful child of the adoptive parents with all rights and responsibilities.

Corporal punishment.

s 2(24): subjecting a child to physical punishment involving deliberate infliction of pain as retribution or discipline; punishable under s 82.

What is social reintegration?

Returning a child to family and community life through restoration, adoption, foster care, sponsorship or aftercare (ss 39–46), with institutional care as a last resort.

Short Notes6 marks each

Child in need of care and Protection.

  • s 2(14) JJ Act: a child falling within any of the categories below.
  • Without home or settled place and without ostensible means of subsistence.
  • Found working in breach of labour laws, or begging or living on the street.
  • Residing with a person who has injured, exploited, abused or neglected the child or threatened to do so.
  • Mentally ill, mentally or physically disabled, or suffering from a terminal or incurable disease, with no one to support him.
  • With a parent or guardian unfit or incapacitated to care for him; or orphaned, abandoned, surrendered, missing or a runaway.
  • Abused, tortured or exploited for sexual abuse or illegal acts or vulnerable to drug abuse or trafficking; or a victim of armed conflict, civil unrest or natural calamity; or at imminent risk of child marriage.
  • s 31: produced before the Child Welfare Committee within 24 hours by police, a public servant, Childline, an NGO, a social worker or the child himself.
  • s 36: inquiry completed within four months; the child is placed in a Children's Home, fit facility or with a fit person meanwhile.
  • s 37: orders include restoration to family, placement, foster care, sponsorship and declaration as legally free for adoption.
  • s 39: rehabilitation is family-based; institutional care is a last resort.
  • Sampurna Behrua v Union of India (2018): the Court directed States to make CWCs and child care institutions fully functional.

What are the powers of the Juvenile Justice Board? What orders may it pass?

  • s 8(1): exclusive power to deal with children in conflict with law.
  • s 8(3): ensure the informed participation of the child and parents, legal aid and an interpreter.
  • Direct a social investigation by a probation officer or social worker within 15 days.
  • Adjudicate and dispose of inquiries, including preliminary assessment for heinous offences (s 15).
  • Transfer to the CWC any matter of care and protection.
  • Inspect residential facilities monthly, direct the police to register FIRs for offences against children and inspect adult jails for children wrongly lodged.
  • s 18(1)(a): advice or admonition after counselling.
  • s 18(1)(b)–(c): group counselling; community service.
  • s 18(1)(d): fine, payable by the child or parent.
  • s 18(1)(e)–(f): release on probation of good conduct under a parent, guardian, fit person or fit facility.
  • s 18(1)(g): placement in a special home for up to three years.
  • s 18(3): after preliminary assessment, transfer of a child of 16–18 to the Children's Court for trial as an adult.

Children welfare committee and its functions.

  • s 27: one or more Committees per district, of a Chairperson and four members, including at least one woman and one child-matters expert.
  • Members need seven years' work in child health, education or welfare or a professional degree in a relevant discipline.
  • Term of three years; the Committee sits at least 20 days a month.
  • s 29: it is the final authority for children in need of care and protection, with exclusive power where constituted.
  • s 30(i)–(ii): take cognizance of and receive children produced; inquire into all matters about them.
  • s 30(iii): direct social investigation by Child Welfare Officers or the District Child Protection Unit.
  • s 30(iv)–(v): declare fit persons and direct foster care.
  • s 30(vi): ensure care, protection and rehabilitation through an individual care plan.
  • s 30(viii): inspect residential facilities at least twice a month.
  • s 30(ix), (xi): certify surrender deeds and declare children legally free for adoption.
  • s 30(xiii): rehabilitate sexually abused children reported by the police under POCSO.
  • s 37: pass orders on restoration, placement, foster care and sponsorship after inquiry.

Situational6 marks each

A 13-year-old girl is detained by police for suspected theft without informing her parents or producing her before the Juvenile Justice Board. During interrogation she allegedly confesses. (a) Examine whether the police action is valid under the Juvenile Justice Act, 2015. (b) Provide the legality of the confession under the JJ Act and constitutional protections.

  • Issue: legality of detaining and interrogating a child, and admissibility of her confession.
  • Law: ss 10, 12, 13 JJ Act (production within 24 hours, never in a lock-up; bail; information to parents and probation officer); s 3(i) (presumption of innocence); s 107 (Child Welfare Police Officer); Art 20(3), 21; BSA s 23 (ss 25, 26 Evidence Act).
  • Application (a): she should have been placed with the Child Welfare Police Officer, her parents informed and produced before the Board within 24 hours; detention in police custody and failure to inform violate ss 10 and 13; theft is a petty offence, so release on bail was the norm (s 12).
  • Application (b): a confession to police is inadmissible under BSA s 23; obtained by interrogation of a child in custody, it also violates Art 20(3) and the protective scheme of the Act.
  • Conclusion: the detention is illegal and the confession inadmissible; the officers are liable to action.

A 16-year-old is accused of committing theft and is produced before the Juvenile Justice Board. The Board is considering whether to try the child as a juvenile or as an adult. (a) Can the child be tried as an adult under the Juvenile Justice Act? (b) What are the criteria for deciding whether a juvenile can be tried as an adult?

  • Issue: whether a 16-year-old accused of theft may be tried as an adult.
  • Law: ss 15, 18(3), 19 JJ Act; s 2(33), 2(45); theft (BNS s 303(2), up to three years) is a petty offence; Shilpa Mittal v State (NCT of Delhi) (2020); Barun Chandra Thakur v Master Bholu (2022).
  • Application (a): only a heinous offence (minimum seven years) by a child of 16–18 permits assessment for adult trial; theft is petty, so the Board must inquire and pass orders under s 18.
  • Application (b): the child must be 16–18 at the offence; the offence must be heinous; the Board's preliminary assessment (within three months) considers mental and physical capacity, ability to understand consequences, and the circumstances, with help from psychologists; the Children's Court then decides (s 19).
  • Conclusion: the child cannot be tried as an adult.

Digesh, aged 16.5 years, commits a heinous crime. (a) Can he be tried as an adult? (b) Define heinous crime under the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015.

  • Issue: adult trial of a child of 16.5 for a heinous offence.
  • Law: s 2(33); ss 15, 18(3), 19, 21 JJ Act; Barun Chandra Thakur v Master Bholu (2022).
  • Application (a): yes, if after a preliminary assessment of his mental and physical capacity, understanding of consequences and the circumstances, the Board transfers the case and the Children's Court finds adult trial necessary; even then he cannot be sentenced to death or life without release (s 21) and stays in a place of safety till 21.
  • Application (b): a heinous offence is one with a minimum punishment of seven years or more under any law (s 2(33)).
  • Conclusion: Digesh may be tried as an adult only after these safeguards.

Long Answers13 marks each

What is the Juvenile Justice Board? Explain its constitution and powers under the Juvenile Justice Act.

Constitution: s 4
  • s 4(1): the State Government constitutes one or more Boards for every district.
  • s 4(2): a Metropolitan Magistrate or JMFC (not the CMM or CJM) with at least three years' experience, designated the Principal Magistrate and two social workers.
  • At least one social worker must be a woman.
  • s 4(3): social workers need seven years' work in child health, education or welfare, or a professional degree in child psychology, psychiatry, sociology or law.
  • s 4(4): persons with records of human-rights or child-rights violations, convictions for moral turpitude, or dismissal from service are disqualified.
  • s 4(5): members receive induction training and sensitisation within 60 days.
  • s 4(6): the term of office is as prescribed by rules; s 4(7): a member other than the Principal Magistrate may be removed after inquiry.
  • s 7(4): decisions by majority; where there is no majority, the Principal Magistrate's opinion prevails.
Procedure
  • s 7: the Board sits in a child-friendly setting, not like a court, and may act with one member absent.
  • s 9: a Magistrate not empowered must forward a child to the Board.
  • s 10: the police produce the child before the Board within 24 hours, and never place him in a lock-up or jail.
  • s 12: the child is released on bail unless release would expose him to danger or defeat justice.
Powers and functions: s 8
  • s 8(1): exclusive power over children in conflict with law, notwithstanding any other law.
  • s 8(2): the High Court and Children's Court exercise the Board's powers in appeal and revision.
  • s 8(3)(a): ensure informed participation of the child and parents.
  • s 8(3)(b)–(c): protect the child's rights; provide legal aid.
  • s 8(3)(d): provide an interpreter if needed.
  • s 8(3)(e): direct a social investigation report within 15 days.
  • s 8(3)(f)–(g): adjudicate and dispose of cases; transfer care-and-protection matters to the CWC.
  • s 8(3)(h): pass final orders with an individual care plan.
  • s 8(3)(j)–(k): monthly inspection of residential facilities; direct the police to register FIRs for offences against children.
  • s 8(3)(m): inspect adult jails to detect children wrongly lodged.
Inquiry and orders
  • s 14: inquiry within four months, extendable by two months; petty-offence inquiries not completed are terminated.
  • s 15: preliminary assessment for heinous offences by children of 16–18, within three months.
  • ss 17, 18: orders of release, or of admonition, counselling, community service, fine, probation or special home.
Authority
  • Barun Chandra Thakur v Master Bholu (2022): the preliminary assessment is a delicate task requiring expert help; the Board's role is protective, not punitive.

Explain the Child Welfare Committee's constitution and powers under the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2000.

Statutory change
  • The 2000 Act was repealed by the JJ Act, 2015 (s 111); the answer below states the current law, which continues the Committee.
  • Under the 2000 Act (s 29) the Committee had a Chairperson and four members, with similar powers.
Constitution: s 27 (2015 Act)
  • One or more Committees for every district, notified by the State Government.
  • A Chairperson and four members.
  • At least one woman and one expert on matters concerning children.
  • s 27(4) (2021): members need a degree in child psychology, psychiatry, law, social work, sociology, human health, education, human development or special education, and seven years' work in child health, education or welfare; or be practising professionals with such a degree.
  • Disqualifications as for Board members; no political office.
  • Term of three years; induction training within two months.
  • The District Magistrate reviews the Committee's functioning quarterly (2021 amendment).
Procedure: s 28
  • s 28(1), (5): the Committee meets at least 20 days a month; at least three members must be present at final disposal.
  • Decisions are by majority; the Chairperson's opinion prevails in a tie.
Powers: s 29
  • Authority to dispose of cases for the care, protection, treatment, development and rehabilitation of children in need of care and to provide for their basic needs.
  • Where constituted, it has exclusive power to deal with such children.
Functions: s 30
  • Take cognizance of and receive children produced before it.
  • Inquire into all matters about the child; direct social investigation.
  • Inquire into and declare fit persons.
  • Direct placement in foster care.
  • Ensure care, protection and rehabilitation through an individual care plan.
  • Inspect residential facilities at least twice a month.
  • Certify surrender deeds and declare children legally free for adoption.
  • Rehabilitate sexually abused children reported under POCSO.
Production and orders
  • s 31: production by police, public servants, Childline, NGOs, social workers or the child himself.
  • s 31: within 24 hours, excluding journey time.
  • s 36: inquiry completed within four months.
  • s 37: orders of restoration, placement, foster care, sponsorship or declaration as free for adoption.
Authority
  • Sampurna Behrua v Union of India (2018): the Court directed that Committees be constituted and staffed in every district so that the Act functions.

State the orders that may be passed regarding a Juvenile by the Juvenile Justice Board.

Inquiry preceding orders
  • s 14: the Board inquires within four months, extendable by two months.
  • It considers the social investigation report and the individual care plan.
  • It decides whether the child committed the offence.
Where no offence is found: s 17
  • The Board passes an order to that effect.
  • If the child appears to need care and protection, it refers him to the CWC.
  • Otherwise the child is released.
Orders where an offence is found: s 18(1)
  • (a) advice or admonition after counselling the child and parents.
  • (b) participation in group counselling.
  • (c) community service under supervision.
  • (d) fine, payable by the child or parent (subject to labour laws for working children).
  • (e) release on probation of good conduct under a parent, guardian or fit person.
  • (f) release on probation under a fit facility.
  • (g) placement in a special home for up to three years for reformative services.
Additional orders: s 18(2)
  • Attend school.
  • Attend a vocational training centre.
  • Attend a therapeutic centre.
  • Not to visit or frequent specified places.
  • Undergo a de-addiction programme.
Heinous offences by children of 16–18
  • s 15: preliminary assessment of capacity, understanding and circumstances.
  • s 18(3): transfer to the Children's Court if adult trial is needed.
  • s 19: the Children's Court decides on adult trial, or itself passes s 18 orders.
Limits
  • s 21: no sentence of death or life imprisonment without possibility of release.
  • s 22: no proceedings under the security chapter of the CrPC (now BNSS) against a child.
  • s 24: no disqualification attaches to a finding against a child, and records are destroyed.
Appeal and authority
  • s 101: appeal against the Board's order to the Children's Court within 30 days.
  • Shilpa Mittal v State (NCT of Delhi) (2020): the classification of offences (petty, serious, heinous) determines the orders available, which keeps the Board's response proportionate.

State the General Principles to be followed in the administration of the Juvenile Justice (Care & Protection of Children) Act.

Basis
  • s 3 JJ Act: governments, Boards, Committees and other agencies are guided by fundamental principles in implementing the Act.
  • The principles draw on Arts 15(3), 39(e)–(f), 45 and 47, the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child (1989) and the Beijing Rules (1985).
The sixteen principles: s 3(i)–(xvi)
  • (i) Presumption of innocence: a child is presumed innocent of mala fide or criminal intent up to 18.
  • (ii) Dignity and worth: every child is treated with equal dignity and rights.
  • (iii) Participation: the child's right to be heard and to participate in decisions.
  • (iv) Best interest: decisions are based on the child's best interest and full potential.
  • (v) Family responsibility: primary responsibility of care lies with the biological, adoptive or foster family.
  • (vi) Safety: the child is protected from harm, abuse and maltreatment within the system.
  • (vii) Positive measures: resources are mobilised to promote well-being and reduce vulnerability.
  • (viii) Non-stigmatising semantics: adversarial or accusatory words are not used.
  • (ix) Non-waiver of rights: no waiver of the child's rights is permissible.
  • (x) Equality and non-discrimination: no discrimination on any ground.
  • (xi) Privacy and confidentiality: protected throughout the judicial process.
  • (xii) Institutionalisation as last resort: only after reasonable inquiry.
  • (xiii) Repatriation and restoration: the child is restored to family at the earliest.
  • (xiv) Fresh start: past records are erased except in special circumstances.
  • (xv) Diversion: measures for dealing with children in conflict with law without judicial proceedings are promoted.
  • (xvi) Natural justice: fair hearing, rule against bias, and review are observed.
Application in the Act
  • Individual care plans give effect to best interest and participation (ss 8, 30).
  • s 24: removal of disqualification and destruction of records implements the fresh-start principle.
  • s 74: prohibition on disclosing identity implements privacy.
  • s 39: family-based care before institutional care implements principles (v) and (xii).
  • s 21: bar on death or life without release reflects dignity and the reformative aim.
Case law
  • Sheela Barse v Union of India (1986): children must not be kept in jails, and their cases must be decided quickly.
  • Sampurna Behrua v Union of India (2018): the State must make the Act's institutions functional.
  • Barun Chandra Thakur v Master Bholu (2022): the best-interest principle guides even the assessment for adult trial.

Salient features and importance of the JJ Act in the protection and rehabilitation of juvenile delinquents.

Background
  • The JJ Act, 2015 replaced the JJ Act, 2000 (s 111).
  • It followed public debate on serious crimes by older children after the 2012 Delhi gang rape.
  • It implements India's obligations under the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child.
Salient features
  • Two categories: children in conflict with law and children in need of care and protection.
  • Offences classified as petty (up to three years), serious (3–7 years) and heinous (minimum seven years) (s 2(33), (45), (54)).
  • s 4: Juvenile Justice Board for every district.
  • s 27: Child Welfare Committee for every district.
  • s 15: preliminary assessment of children of 16–18 for heinous offences.
  • ss 18(3), 19: Children's Court may try such a child as an adult.
  • s 21: no death sentence or life imprisonment without release.
  • s 12: bail as a rule, with exceptions.
  • s 14: inquiry within four months.
  • s 18: graded rehabilitative orders.
  • ss 47–52: observation homes, special homes, places of safety, children's homes, fit facilities and fit persons.
  • ss 56–73: adoption chapter; the Central Adoption Resource Authority becomes statutory (s 68).
  • ss 44, 45: foster care and sponsorship.
  • s 46: aftercare for children leaving institutions.
  • s 41: compulsory registration of child care institutions.
  • ss 74–89: offences against children, including cruelty, corporal punishment and use by militant groups.
  • s 94: age determination by documents, then medical tests; s 107: Child Welfare Police Officers and Special Juvenile Police Units.
Importance in protection and rehabilitation
  • The approach is reformative, not punitive.
  • Family-based care takes priority over institutions.
  • Records are erased so that the child has a fresh start (s 24).
  • Individual care plans tailor rehabilitation to each child.
Debate and case law
  • Critics argue that adult trial of 16–18-year-olds departs from the Convention; supporters cite public safety.
  • Salil Bali v Union of India (2013) and Subramanian Swamy v Raju (2014) upheld uniform treatment of under-18s under the 2000 Act; the 2015 Act's change is the legislature's response.

Who are children in conflict with law? Discuss the procedure in relation to children in conflict with law.

Meaning
  • s 2(13): a child alleged or found to have committed an offence, who had not completed 18 years on the date of the offence.
  • s 94: age is determined by school or matriculation certificate, then municipal birth certificate, then medical test.
  • s 9(2): a claim of juvenility may be raised at any stage, even after disposal (Abuzar Hossain v State of West Bengal, 2012).
Apprehension
  • s 10(1): the child is placed with the Special Juvenile Police Unit or the Child Welfare Police Officer.
  • He is produced before the Board within 24 hours, excluding journey time.
  • He is never placed in a police lock-up or jail.
  • s 13: the police inform the parents or guardian and the probation officer.
  • Under the Model Rules, 2016, an FIR is registered only for heinous offences or offences committed jointly with adults; otherwise a daily diary entry suffices.
Bail
  • s 12: the child is released on bail, with or without surety, or under supervision, notwithstanding the BNSS.
  • Bail is refused only if release would bring him into association with criminals, expose him to danger or defeat justice; he is then kept in an observation home.
Inquiry
  • s 7: the Board sits in a child-friendly manner.
  • s 8(3): legal aid, an interpreter and the child's informed participation are ensured.
  • A social investigation report is obtained within 15 days.
  • s 14: inquiry completed within four months, extendable by two months.
  • Inquiries into petty offences that remain inconclusive are terminated.
  • s 15: preliminary assessment within three months for heinous offences by children of 16–18.
Orders
  • s 17: release, or referral to the CWC, if no offence is found.
  • s 18(1): admonition, counselling, community service, fine, probation or special home up to three years.
  • s 18(2): directions to attend school, vocational training, therapy or de-addiction.
  • An individual care plan accompanies the final order.
Adult trial
  • s 18(3): transfer to the Children's Court after preliminary assessment.
  • s 19: the Children's Court decides; the child stays in a place of safety until 21.
  • s 21: no death sentence or life imprisonment without release.
Protections
  • s 23: no joint proceedings with adults.
  • s 24: no disqualification; records destroyed.
  • s 74: identity not to be disclosed in any media, which secures the child's fresh start.

Examine the procedure relating to children in need of care and protection under the JJ Act, 2015.

Meaning
  • s 2(14): includes children without home or subsistence, working or begging in breach of law, abused or exploited, orphaned, abandoned, surrendered, missing or runaway.
  • It also includes children with unfit parents, disabled or terminally ill children without support, and children at risk of child marriage, trafficking or drug abuse.
  • It also includes victims of armed conflict, civil unrest or natural calamity.
Production and reporting
  • s 31: produced before the CWC by police, a public servant, Childline, an NGO, a Child Welfare Officer, a social worker, a doctor or the child himself.
  • Production within 24 hours, excluding journey time.
  • s 32: a person or institution finding a child separated from guardians must report within 24 hours.
  • s 33: failure to report is an offence.
  • s 35: parents may surrender a child before the CWC, with two months to reconsider.
Inquiry: s 36
  • The CWC holds an inquiry on the child's production.
  • It directs a social investigation report within 15 days.
  • Pending inquiry, the child is placed in a Children's Home, fit facility or with a fit person.
  • The inquiry is completed within four months.
  • An orphaned, abandoned or surrendered child under 6 is placed in a Specialised Adoption Agency.
Orders: s 37
  • Declaration that the child is in need of care and protection.
  • Restoration to parents, guardian or family, with directions to them.
  • Placement in a Children's Home, fit facility or Specialised Adoption Agency.
  • Placement with a fit person or in foster care.
  • Sponsorship orders.
  • Declaration that the child is legally free for adoption.
Adoption
  • s 38: procedure for declaring an orphaned, abandoned or surrendered child legally free for adoption.
  • s 56: adoption to ensure the right to family for such children.
  • s 61: adoption orders are now made by the District Magistrate (2021 amendment).
Rehabilitation
  • s 39: family-based care is preferred; institutional care is a last resort.
  • An individual care plan is prepared and reviewed periodically.
Authority
  • Sampurna Behrua v Union of India (2018): the Court required States to staff and run CWCs and institutions effectively.
  • The procedure places the child's best interest (s 3(iv)) above formality.

Explain the rehabilitation measures provided for children in need of care and protection under the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015. Include the role of observation home and after-care organisations.

Principles
  • s 39(1): rehabilitation and social reintegration are undertaken on the basis of an individual care plan.
  • Family-based care (restoration, adoption, foster care, sponsorship) is preferred.
  • Institutional care is a last resort, for the shortest period.
Family-based measures
  • s 40: restoration to the family is the prime objective of every child care institution.
  • The CWC orders restoration after satisfying itself of the family's suitability.
  • s 44: foster care with a selected family, individual or group.
  • Foster families are inspected monthly by the Child Welfare Officer.
  • s 45: sponsorship provides financial support for education, health and development.
  • ss 56–58: adoption, in-country and inter-country.
  • s 43: open shelters for children needing short-term community support.
Institutional measures
  • s 41: all child care institutions must be registered.
  • s 50: Children's Homes for care, education and rehabilitation of children in need of care.
  • s 51: fit facilities for temporary care.
  • s 52: fit persons for temporary custody.
  • s 53: services include food, clothing, education, skill development, therapy, counselling and recreation.
  • s 54: inspection committees monitor institutions.
  • s 47: observation homes provide temporary reception, care and rehabilitation of children in conflict with law during inquiry.
  • In observation homes children are segregated by age, gender, physical and mental status and nature of offence.
  • s 48: special homes provide reformative services for children in conflict with law after orders.
  • s 49: places of safety hold children above 16 accused of heinous offences, and those sentenced by Children's Courts until 21.
Aftercare
  • s 46: a child leaving an institution at 18 may receive financial support for reintegration into mainstream society.
  • Aftercare organisations provide group housing, stipends, vocational training and counselling (up to 21 years, extendable to 23 under the Model Rules).
  • The aim is a transition to independent adult life.
Monitoring
  • s 106: State Child Protection Society and District Child Protection Unit coordinate implementation.
  • s 109: the National and State Commissions for Protection of Child Rights monitor the Act.
Authority
  • Sampurna Behrua v Union of India (2018): rehabilitation depends on functioning institutions and trained staff, which the Court ordered the States to secure.

Topic 4.2

The Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act, 2012

Short Answers2 marks each

What is the punishment for penetrative sexual assault under POCSO?

s 4: imprisonment of either description for at least ten years, extendable to life and fine; if the child is below 16, at least 20 years, extendable to imprisonment for the remainder of natural life (2019 amendment).

What is meant by "penetrative sexual assault"?

s 3: penetration to any extent of the penis, an object or a body part into the vagina, mouth, urethra or anus of a child, manipulation to cause such penetration, or application of the mouth or making the child do so.

What do you mean by sexual assault under the POCSO Act?

s 7: touching the vagina, penis, anus or breast of a child, or making the child touch them, or any other act involving physical contact without penetration, with sexual intent (Attorney General for India v Satish, 2021: skin-to-skin contact not required).

What is the punishment prescribed for sexual harassment under POCSO?

s 12: imprisonment of either description up to three years, and fine.

Explain 'child pornography' under the POCSO Act, 2012.

s 2(1)(da) (2019): any visual depiction of sexually explicit conduct involving a child, including photographs, videos and digital or computer-generated images indistinguishable from a child; storage and transmission are punishable under s 15.

What is meant by "Use of child for pornographic purposes" under the POCSO Act?

s 13: using a child in any media for sexual gratification, including representation of sexual organs, real or simulated sexual acts or indecent representation; punishable under s 14 with at least five years.

Short Notes6 marks each

Aggravated Penetrative Sexual Assault under POCSO.

  • s 5: penetrative sexual assault becomes aggravated by the status of the offender or the circumstances.
  • By a police officer, a member of the armed or security forces or a public servant.
  • By staff of a jail, remand home, protection home, observation home, hospital or educational or religious institution.
  • By a relative (blood, adoption, marriage, guardianship or foster care), or a person in a position of trust or authority.
  • By a gang, or using deadly weapons, fire, heated or corrosive substances.
  • Causing grievous hurt, injury to sexual organs, pregnancy or HIV or other life-threatening disease.
  • On a child below 12, or a child with mental or physical disability.
  • Repeatedly; or knowing the child is pregnant; or by a person previously convicted of a POCSO offence.
  • During communal or sectarian violence or a natural calamity; or followed by stripping or parading the child naked.
  • Administering drugs or hormones to attain early sexual maturity (2019 amendment).
  • s 6 (2019): rigorous imprisonment of at least 20 years, extendable to life for the remainder of natural life and fine; or death.
  • Nawabuddin v State of Uttarakhand (2022): offences of this gravity call for strict sentencing with no undue leniency.

What is meant by aggravated sexual assault?

  • s 9: sexual assault (s 7) committed in the aggravating circumstances listed in the section.
  • By a police officer, a member of the armed or security forces or a public servant.
  • By staff of a jail, remand home, observation home, hospital or educational or religious institution.
  • By a relative, or a person in a position of trust or authority.
  • By a gang, or using deadly weapons, fire, heated or corrosive substances.
  • Causing grievous hurt, injury to sexual organs or pregnancy.
  • On a child below 12, or a child with mental or physical disability.
  • Repeatedly; or by a person previously convicted of a POCSO offence.
  • During communal violence or a natural calamity; or stripping or parading the child naked.
  • s 10: imprisonment of at least five years, extendable to seven years and fine.
  • s 29: the Special Court presumes guilt unless the contrary is proved; s 30: culpable mental state is presumed.
  • Attorney General for India v Satish (2021): sexual intent, not skin-to-skin contact, is the test of sexual assault.

Difference between sexual assault and sexual harassment in POCSO.

Point Sexual assault Sexual harassment
Provision s 7; punished under s 8 s 11; punished under s 12
Physical contact Essential (touching, or making the child touch) Not required
Acts covered Touching vagina, penis, anus or breast, or other contact with sexual intent Words, sounds, gestures, exhibiting objects or body parts, stalking, threats, enticement for pornography
Punishment 3 to 5 years and fine Up to 3 years and fine
Aggravated form Aggravated sexual assault (ss 9, 10) None
Presumption s 29 presumption of guilt applies s 29 does not apply (only ss 3, 5, 7, 9); s 30 culpable mental state applies

Sexual harassment under POCSO.

  • s 11: a person commits sexual harassment of a child when, with sexual intent, he does any of the acts listed.
  • Utters a word, makes a sound or gesture, or exhibits an object or body part, intending the child to hear or see it.
  • Makes a child exhibit his or her body so that it is seen by him or another.
  • Shows any object to a child in any form or media for pornographic purposes.
  • Repeatedly or constantly follows, watches or contacts a child, directly or electronically.
  • Threatens to use a real or fabricated depiction of any part of the child's body or of the child in a sexual act.
  • Entices a child for pornographic purposes or gives gratification for that purpose.
  • Explanation: any question involving sexual intent is a question of fact.
  • s 12: punishment up to three years and fine.
  • s 19: any person who knows of the offence must report it to the police or the Special Juvenile Police Unit.
  • s 28: tried by the Special Court; s 30: culpable mental state is presumed.
  • Attorney General for India v Satish (2021): courts must read POCSO provisions to advance their protective purpose.

Situational6 marks each

A child victim under the POCSO Act is repeatedly called to the police station for recording a statement, causing trauma. (a) Whether such procedure is permissible. (b) What safeguards are provided for recording the statement of a child?

  • Issue: whether repeated summoning of a child victim to the police station is lawful.
  • Law: ss 24–26, 33(5), 36, 37 POCSO; s 179(1) BNSS proviso (women and persons under 15 are not required to attend the police station); Art 21.
  • Application (a): impermissible; s 24 requires the statement to be recorded at the child's residence or place of choice, and the child must not be repeatedly called; repeated summoning causes secondary victimisation.
  • Application (b): recorded by a woman police officer not below Sub-Inspector, as far as practicable, not in uniform; the child is kept away from the accused and not detained at the station at night; identity is protected; a parent or trusted person is present; recorded by audio-video means with an interpreter or special educator where needed (s 26); the Magistrate's recording under s 25 is in the presence of the parent; at trial the child is not called repeatedly (s 33(5)) and is shielded from the accused (s 36).
  • Conclusion: the procedure violates s 24; officers are liable to action and the statement should be recorded afresh with these safeguards.

Long Answers13 marks each

What is the object of the POCSO Act? Explain the procedure for reporting a case and the procedure for recording evidence under the POCSO Act.

Object
  • To protect children (below 18, s 2(1)(d)) from sexual assault, sexual harassment and pornography.
  • To provide child-friendly procedures for reporting, recording evidence, investigation and trial through Special Courts.
  • The Act is gender-neutral and implements Art 15(3) and Art 39(f).
  • India's accession to the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child (1992) required such legislation.
Reporting
  • s 19(1): any person, including the child, who apprehends or knows of an offence must inform the Special Juvenile Police Unit or local police.
  • s 19(2): the report is recorded in writing, given an entry number and read over to the informant.
  • s 19(5): the police arrange the child's care and protection, including shelter or hospital, within 24 hours.
  • s 19(6): the police report the matter to the CWC and the Special Court within 24 hours.
  • s 20: media, studios and photographic facilities must report material involving sexual exploitation of children.
  • s 21: failure to report is punishable; for persons in charge of institutions, more severely.
  • s 22: a false complaint made to humiliate or extort is punishable, but not one made by a child.
Recording the child's statement
  • s 24(1): at the child's residence or a place of his choice.
  • s 24(2): by a woman police officer not below Sub-Inspector, as far as practicable, not in uniform.
  • s 24(3): the child does not come into contact with the accused.
  • s 24(4): the child is not detained at the police station at night.
  • s 25: the Magistrate records the statement in the presence of the parent or trusted person.
  • s 26: audio-video recording where possible; interpreter, translator or special educator as needed.
Recording evidence at trial
  • s 28: trial by a Special Court (a Court of Session) designated for each district.
  • s 33(2): questions are put to the child through the judge.
  • s 33(3)–(4): frequent breaks and a child-friendly atmosphere with family present.
  • s 33(5): the child is not called repeatedly to testify.
  • s 33(6): no aggressive questioning or character assassination.
  • s 33(7): the child's identity is not disclosed.
  • s 35: evidence recorded within 30 days of cognizance; trial completed within one year.
  • ss 36, 37: the child is shielded from the accused by screens or video, and trial is in camera.
Authority
  • Alakh Alok Srivastava v Union of India (2018): the Court directed child-friendly courts and adherence to the Act's time limits, which give effect to its object.

Discuss the several offences under the POCSO Act.

Scope
  • s 2(1)(d): a child is a person below 18.
  • The offences are gender-neutral as to both victim and offender.
Penetrative sexual assault
  • s 3: penetration by penis, object or body part, manipulation or application of the mouth.
  • s 4: at least ten years, extendable to life and fine.
  • s 4(2): at least 20 years if the child is below 16.
Aggravated penetrative sexual assault
  • s 5: by police, armed forces, public servants, staff of institutions, relatives, gangs or on children below 12.
  • Also where grievous hurt, pregnancy or disability results, or the offender is a repeat offender.
  • s 6: at least 20 years, extendable to life for natural life or death.
Sexual assault
  • s 7: touching with sexual intent, without penetration.
  • s 8: 3 to five years and fine.
Aggravated sexual assault
  • s 9: sexual assault in the aggravating circumstances of s 5.
  • s 10: 5 to seven years and fine.
Sexual harassment
  • s 11: words, gestures, exhibition, stalking, threats or enticement with sexual intent.
  • s 12: up to three years and fine.
Pornography
  • s 2(1)(da): child pornography defined (2019).
  • s 13: use of a child for pornographic purposes.
  • s 14: at least five years (7 years for a subsequent conviction) and fine.
  • s 15: storing child pornography without deleting or reporting it, transmitting it, or storing it for commercial purposes, each punishable with graded penalties.
Abetment and attempt
  • s 16: abetment by instigation, conspiracy or intentional aid.
  • s 17: the abettor receives the punishment for the offence.
  • s 18: attempt is punishable with up to half of the longest term for the offence.
Related offences
  • s 21: failure to report or record an offence.
  • s 22: false complaint or false information.
  • s 23: media disclosure of the child's identity.
Presumptions and authority
  • ss 29, 30: presumption of guilt for ss 3, 5, 7, 9 and of culpable mental state.
  • Just Rights for Children Alliance v S. Harish (2024): viewing or storing child sexual abuse material is an offence, and the term "child sexual exploitative and abuse material" is to be preferred.

Discuss in detail the provisions relating to abetment of and attempt to commit sexual offences under the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act, 2012.

Abetment: s 16
  • A person abets an offence if he instigates any person to commit it.
  • Or engages with others in a conspiracy, if an act or illegal omission follows in pursuance of it.
  • Or intentionally aids its commission by an act or illegal omission.
  • Explanation I: wilful misrepresentation or concealment of a material fact that procures the offence is instigation.
  • Explanation II: doing anything to facilitate the offence, before or at the time, is aiding.
  • Explanation III: employing, harbouring, receiving or transporting a child by threat, force, fraud, deception or payment, for the purpose of an offence, is abetment by aid.
  • The abettor need not himself perform any physical act on the child.
Punishment for abetment: s 17
  • If the offence is committed in consequence of the abetment, the abettor receives the punishment for that offence.
  • Explanation: an act is committed in consequence of abetment if done because of the instigation, conspiracy or aid.
  • The Act draws no distinction between abettor and principal in punishment.
  • Where the abetted offence is not committed, the general law of abetment in the BNS applies, as POCSO operates in addition to other laws (s 42A).
Attempt: s 18
  • Whoever attempts to commit an offence under the Act, or to cause it to be committed, and does an act towards it, commits an offence.
  • Punishment: imprisonment up to one-half of imprisonment for life, or one-half of the longest term provided for the offence, or fine or both.
  • Three stages are distinguished: intention, preparation and attempt; preparation alone is not punishable.
  • State of Maharashtra v Mohd Yakub (1980): an attempt begins when preparation ends and the accused does an act towards commission.
  • Koppula Venkat Rao v State of Andhra Pradesh (2004): an attempt to rape requires acts beyond preparation showing determination to proceed despite resistance.
  • Attempt to commit penetrative sexual assault may itself amount to sexual assault (s 7) where physical contact with sexual intent occurs.
Procedure and presumptions
  • s 19: reporting extends to an apprehension that an offence is likely to be committed.
  • s 29: the Special Court presumes guilt where a person is prosecuted for committing, abetting or attempting offences under ss 3, 5, 7 and 9.
  • s 30: culpable mental state is presumed; the accused must rebut it beyond reasonable doubt.
  • s 28: abetment and attempt are tried by the Special Court.
  • Attorney General for India v Satish (2021): sexual intent is the determining factor, which applies equally to attempt.
Interaction with general law
  • s 42: where an act is an offence under POCSO and under the IPC provisions listed in the section (now read as their BNS equivalents), the offender is punished under the law providing the greater punishment.
  • s 42A: the Act is in addition to other laws and prevails in case of inconsistency.
Assessment
  • Equal punishment for abettors reflects that harm to children often involves facilitators such as family members or institutions.
  • Nawabuddin v State of Uttarakhand (2022): offences against children require strict sentencing, and the abetment and attempt provisions extend that strictness to those who facilitate or attempt them.

Appendix

Appendix

Probation of Offenders Act, 1958

The Act refers to IPC sections; under s 8 of the General Clauses Act, 1897, those references are read as references to the corresponding BNS provisions (e.g. BNS s 303(2) (s 379 IPC); BNS s 305 (s 380 IPC)). No court has yet settled this reading; state it as the probable position.

Short Answers2 marks each

Who is a Probation officer?

s 2(b): an officer appointed or recognised under s 13, who inquires into offenders' circumstances and supervises persons released on probation (s 14).

Admonition means?

A formal warning by the court, under s 3, after which an offender is released instead of being sentenced, for listed minor offences where he has no previous conviction.

Short Notes6 marks each

Powers of the court to release an offender on probation.

  • s 3: release after due admonition for offences under BNS ss 303(2), 305, 306, 315 or 318(4) (ss 379, 380, 381, 404 or 420 IPC), or offences punishable with up to two years or fine, where no previous conviction is proved.
  • In deciding under s 3, the court considers the circumstances, the nature of the offence and the offender's character.
  • s 4(1): release on probation of good conduct for any offence not punishable with death or life imprisonment.
  • The offender enters a bond, with or without sureties, to appear and receive sentence when called, and to keep the peace for up to three years.
  • s 4(2): the court first considers the probation officer's report, if any.
  • s 4(3): a supervision order places the offender under a probation officer for at least one year.
  • s 4(4): conditions for supervision may be imposed in the order.
  • s 5: the court may order compensation to the victim and costs of the proceedings.
  • s 6: an offender under 21 shall not be imprisoned unless the court, after a probation officer's report, records reasons.
  • s 11: appellate and revisional courts, and the High Court, may also exercise these powers.
  • s 12: a person released under s 3 or 4 suffers no disqualification attached to conviction.
  • s 401 BNSS (s 360 CrPC): a parallel power exists in the Sanhita; s 19 of the Act displaces it (as s 562 of the 1898 Code) where the Act is in force.

Probation Officer.

  • s 2(b): an officer appointed or recognised under s 13.
  • s 13(1): appointed or recognised by the State Government, provided by a recognised society, or in an exceptional case any person the court thinks fit.
  • s 13(3): he acts under the control of the District Magistrate.
  • s 14(a): inquires, as directed by the court, into the circumstances and home surroundings of an accused, to assist the court.
  • s 14(b): supervises probationers and other persons placed under his supervision.
  • s 14(b): helps them to find suitable employment where necessary.
  • s 14(c): advises and assists offenders in paying compensation or costs ordered.
  • s 14(d): advises and assists persons released under s 4, as prescribed.
  • s 7: his report is confidential, though the court may give the substance to the offender.
  • s 4(2), s 6(2): his report guides the decision to release.
  • s 15: he is a public servant.
  • s 16: he is protected for acts done in good faith under the Act.

Salient features of the Probation of Offenders Act.

  • Reformative object: offenders, especially first and young offenders, are kept out of prison.
  • s 3: release after admonition for listed minor offences.
  • s 4: release on probation of good conduct for offences not punishable with death or life.
  • s 4(3): supervision orders through probation officers.
  • s 5: compensation to victims and costs.
  • s 6: restriction on imprisoning offenders under 21.
  • s 7: confidential reports of probation officers.
  • s 8: variation of conditions of probation.
  • s 9: on breach, the offender may be arrested and sentenced for the original offence.
  • s 12: no disqualification attaches to the finding of guilt.
  • ss 13, 14: appointment and duties of probation officers.
  • Rattan Lal v State of Punjab (1965): the Act is a beneficial reform statute and applies even to pending appeals.

Situational6 marks each

X was tried for theft of gold ornaments from a jeweller's shop. On a complaint filed by the shop owner, X was arrested. The Judge found him guilty of an offence committed under sec. 380 of IPC. Further, the Court ordered X's release after admonition under the Probation of Offenders Act, 1958, because there was no previous conviction of the accused X and the theft was committed due to sudden temptation without any premeditation. (a) Define Probation. Is probation valid in this case? Give reasons. (b) Explain the powers of the Court to release certain offenders on probation.

  • Issue: whether admonition is valid for theft in a dwelling house (BNS s 305 (s 380 IPC)).
  • Law: ss 3, 4 Probation of Offenders Act; BNS s 305 (s 380 IPC); Rattan Lal v State of Punjab (1965).
  • Application (a): probation is the conditional release of a convicted offender under supervision, instead of imprisonment, to reform him; s 3 expressly includes theft in a dwelling house (BNS s 305 (s 380 IPC)), and X has no previous conviction and acted on sudden temptation, so admonition is valid.
  • Application (b): the court may release after admonition (s 3), or on probation of good conduct on a bond up to three years (s 4), with supervision (s 4(3)), compensation (s 5) and special protection for those under 21 (s 6).
  • Conclusion: the order of admonition is lawful.

Ashok is sentenced for committing an offence under section 379 of the Indian Penal Code. (a) Can he be released on Probation? What is admonition? (b) Explain the relevant provisions.

  • Issue: eligibility of a person convicted of theft for admonition or probation.
  • Law: ss 3, 4, 6 Probation of Offenders Act; BNS s 303(2) (s 379 IPC).
  • Application (a): yes; theft is listed in s 3 and is not punishable with death or life, so Ashok may be admonished (if no previous conviction) or released on probation of good conduct; admonition is a formal warning followed by release.
  • Application (b): s 3 (admonition for listed offences), s 4 (bond up to three years and supervision), s 5 (compensation), s 6 (if under 21, imprisonment only with recorded reasons), s 12 (no disqualification).
  • Conclusion: the court may substitute admonition or probation for the sentence, even in appeal (s 11).

Long Answers13 marks each

Explain the reformative nature of the Probation of Offenders Act, 1958.

Background
  • The Act replaced the limited power in s 562 CrPC, 1898 with a full scheme of probation.
  • It rests on the reformative theory: crime is treated as a social maladjustment to be corrected.
  • Short prison terms expose first offenders to hardened criminals; the Act avoids this.
Provisions showing the reformative aim
  • s 3: release after admonition for minor offences.
  • s 4(1): release on probation of good conduct for offences not punishable with death or life.
  • s 4(3): supervision by a probation officer.
  • s 4(4): conditions suited to the offender, such as residence or abstention from intoxicants.
  • s 5: compensation to the victim, which joins reform with restitution.
  • s 6: offenders under 21 are not imprisoned save for recorded reasons.
  • s 7: the probation officer's report gives the court the offender's background.
  • s 8: conditions may be varied as the offender progresses.
  • s 9: sentence is imposed only if the offender breaks his bond.
  • s 11: appellate and revisional courts may grant probation.
  • s 12: no disqualification attaches to the conviction, which permits a fresh start.
  • ss 13, 14: probation officers inquire, supervise and help find employment.
  • s 17: the State Government frames rules for implementation.
  • s 401 BNSS (s 360 CrPC): the Sanhita contains a parallel power, displaced where the Act applies (s 19).
Judicial approach
  • Rattan Lal v State of Punjab (1965): a beneficial statute, applied even to cases pending on appeal.
  • Ishar Das v State of Punjab (1972): courts must consider s 6 for young offenders before imposing imprisonment.
  • Jugal Kishore Prasad v State of Bihar (1972): the object is to prevent young and first offenders from becoming hardened criminals.
  • Mohd Aziz Mohd Nasir v State of Maharashtra (1976): s 6 is mandatory for offenders under 21 in eligible cases.
  • Chhanni v State of Uttar Pradesh (2006): probation is discretionary and depends on the nature of the offence and the offender.
  • Courts must record reasons when refusing probation to an eligible offender (s 402 BNSS; s 361 CrPC).
Limits
  • Not available for offences punishable with death or life imprisonment.
  • s 18: excluded for certain offences under specified statutes.
  • The reformative purpose is balanced against deterrence, so probation remains a matter of judicial discretion.

Explain the duties of a Probation Officer with reference to the Probation of Offenders Act, 1958.

Status and appointment
  • s 2(b): an officer appointed or recognised under s 13.
  • s 13(1)(a): a person appointed, or recognised, by the State Government.
  • s 13(1)(b): a person provided by a society recognised by the State.
  • s 13(1)(c): in an exceptional case, any person the court thinks fit for the particular case.
  • s 13(3): he works under the control of the District Magistrate.
  • s 15: he is a public servant.
Duties under s 14
  • (a): inquire, as directed by the court, into the circumstances or home surroundings of an accused, to help the court choose the method of dealing with him.
  • (b): supervise probationers and other persons placed under his supervision.
  • (b): find them suitable employment where necessary.
  • (c): advise and assist offenders in paying compensation or costs ordered by the court.
  • (d): advise and assist persons released under s 4, in prescribed cases.
  • (e): perform other duties prescribed by rules.
  • Report to the court any breach of the bond's conditions, which may lead to action under s 9.
  • Keep his report confidential, as s 7 requires.
Reports
  • s 4(2): report considered before a probation order.
  • s 6(2): report mandatory before sentencing an offender under 21 to imprisonment.
  • s 7: the report is confidential; the court may communicate its substance to the offender.
  • The court may allow the offender to produce evidence on matters in the report.
  • s 8: he may apply for variation of the conditions of the bond.
Role in supervision
  • He is named in the supervision order under s 4(3).
  • He monitors compliance with conditions on residence, intoxicants and conduct.
  • He visits the probationer and his family periodically.
  • He reports non-compliance, which may lead to a warrant and sentence under s 9.
Protection and rules
  • s 16: no suit or prosecution lies for acts done in good faith under the Act.
  • s 17: State rules prescribe qualifications and further duties.
Assessment
  • The probation officer links the court and the community, and the Act's reformative purpose (Rattan Lal v State of Punjab, 1965) depends on his supervision.

Explain the salient features of the Probation of Offenders Act.

Nature
  • A reformative statute enacted in 1958 to keep first and young offenders out of prison.
  • It applies throughout India and replaces s 562 CrPC, 1898.
Release after admonition: s 3
  • For theft, theft in a dwelling house, theft by clerk or servant, dishonest misappropriation of a deceased person's property and cheating (BNS ss 303(2), 305, 306, 315, 318(4); ss 379, 380, 381, 404, 420 IPC), or offences punishable up to two years or fine.
  • Only where no previous conviction is proved.
  • After considering the circumstances, the nature of the offence and the offender's character.
Release on probation: s 4
  • For any offence not punishable with death or life imprisonment.
  • On a bond, with or without sureties, for up to three years.
  • The offender must appear and receive sentence when called, and keep the peace.
  • s 4(2): the probation officer's report is considered.
  • s 4(3)–(4): supervision for at least a year, with conditions.
Compensation: s 5
  • Compensation to the victim and costs of the proceedings.
Young offenders: s 6
  • An offender under 21 is not imprisoned unless reasons are recorded.
  • The probation officer's report is called for.
Report and variation: ss 7, 8
  • The report is confidential.
  • Conditions of the bond may be varied.
Breach: s 9
  • On failure to observe conditions, the court may issue a warrant.
  • The court may then sentence the offender for the original offence or impose a penalty.
Sureties and courts: ss 10, 11
  • The Code's provisions on bonds and sureties apply (s 10).
  • Appellate and revisional courts may pass orders under the Act (s 11).
Removal of disqualification: s 12
  • No disqualification attaches to the finding of guilt.
Probation officers: ss 13, 14
  • Appointment or recognition by the State Government.
  • Duties of inquiry, supervision and assistance.
Application and exclusion: ss 18, 19
  • s 18: the Act does not apply to certain offences under specified statutes.
  • s 19: s 562 of the 1898 Code (now s 360 CrPC; s 401 BNSS) ceases to apply where the Act is in force.
Authority
  • Rattan Lal v State of Punjab (1965): the Act's benefit extends to pending appeals.
  • Jugal Kishore Prasad v State of Bihar (1972): its object is to reform offenders before they become hardened criminals.

Top 25 questions for revision

The 20 questions with three or more asterisks come first. They are followed by the five most recently set two-asterisk questions: two set in both 2025 and 2026, then three set in 2026. Within each asterisk count, questions follow the order of the compilation.

Rank Asterisks Topic Block and no. Question
1 7 1.2 Short Answer 15 Define "place" and "victim"
2 7 4.1 Short Note 1 Child in need of care and protection
3 6 1.2 Short Answer 6 Cognizable and non-cognizable offence
4 6 1.10 Short Note 1 FIR
5 5 1.2 Short Answer 14 Police report
6 5 1.4 Long Answer 1 Powers of police to arrest; rights of arrested person
7 5 2.2 Short Answer 1 What is meant by charge
8 5 3.1 Short Answer 2 Compounding of offences
9 5 3.9 Situational 1 Mr. Rana: rape, bail and compounding
10 5 4.1 Short Answer 6 Observation home
11 4 1.3 Short Answer 1 Who is a Public Prosecutor
12 4 1.5 Long Answer 1 Processes to compel appearance; consequences of non-appearance
13 4 2.4 Short Note 1 Plea bargaining
14 4 4.1 Long Answer 1 Juvenile Justice Board: constitution and powers
15 3 1.2 Short Answer 1 Define "inquiry"
16 3 1.5 Short Answer 1 When a search warrant may issue
17 3 2.3 Short Answer 4 Summary trial
18 3 3.5 Situational 1 Ram acquitted of attempt to murder: victim's appeal
19 3 3.11 Situational 1 Limitation for an offence punishable with 2 years
20 3 Appendix Short Answer 1 Who is a probation officer
21 2 1.1 Short Answer 1 Object of the BNSS
22 2 4.1 Short Answer 2 Who is a juvenile
23 2 1.2 Short Answer 11 Summons case and warrant case
24 2 1.4 Short Answer 1 Procedure of arrest
25 2 1.10 Short Note 2 Confession before Magistrate

Four other two-asterisk questions were also set in 2026: Topic 2.3 Short Answer 1 (types of trial), Topic 2.3 Long Answer 1 (Sessions trial), Topic 2.4 Short Answer 1 (plea bargaining) and Topic 3.8 Long Answer 1 (disposal of property). They tie with ranks 23–25 and should be revised alongside them.

Index of provisions and cases

Every section of the six principal statutes cited in the answers, with its heading as printed in the statute and the topics in which it is cited. Headings are taken from the India Code text of each Act; a dash marks a section number that does not match a section of that Act. Repealed provisions (CrPC, IPC, Evidence Act) appear only as cross-references in the answers.

Index

Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023

Section Heading CrPC Cited in
2 Definitions 2 1.1, 1.2, 1.3, 1.10, 2.1, 2.2, 2.3, 3.5, 3.9
5 Saving 3.11
6 Classes of Criminal Courts 6 1.3
7 Territorial divisions 1.3, 1.7
8 Court of Session 9 1.3
9 Courts of Judicial Magistrates. aC 1.3
10 Chief Judicial Magistrate and Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, etc 1.3
11 Special Judicial Magistrates 1.3
13 Subordination of Judicial Magistrates 1.3
14 Executive Magistrates 20 1.3, 3.8
15 Special Executive Magistrates 1.3
18 Public Prosecutors 24 1.2, 1.3
19 Assistant Public Prosecutors 25 1.3
20 Directorate of Prosecution 25A 1.3
22 Sentences which High Courts and Sessions Judges may pass 28 1.3
23 Sentences which Magistrates may pass 29 1.3, 2.3
24 Sentence of imprisonment in default of fine 30 1.3
25 Sentence in cases of conviction of several offences at one trial 31 1.3
26 Mode of conferring powers 1.3
29 Powers of Judges and Magistrates exercisable by their successors-in-office 1.3
31 Public when to assist Magistrates and police 37 1.3, 1.10
32 Aid to person, other than police officer, executing warrant 38 1.3
33 Public to give information of certain offences 39 1.3, 1.10
34 Duty of officers employed in connection with affairs of a village to make certain 40 1.3
35 When police may arrest without warrant 41 1.1, 1.4, 1.10
36 Procedure of arrest and duties of officer making arrest 41B 1.4, 1.10
37 Designated police officer 1.1, 1.4, 1.10
38 Right of arrested person to meet an advocate of his choice during interrogation 41D 1.4
39 Arrest on refusal to give name and residence 42 1.4
40 Arrest by private person and procedure on such arrest 1.4
43 Arrest how made. aC 46 1.1, 1.4, 1.10
45 Pursuit of offenders into other jurisdictions 3.3
46 No unnecessary restraint 49 1.4
47 Person arrested to be informed of grounds of arrest and of right to bail 50 1.4, 1.10
48 Obligation of person making arrest to inform about arrest, etc., to relative or friend 50A 1.4, 1.10
49 Search of arrested person 51 1.4, 1.10
50 Power to seize offensive weapons 1.10
51 Examination of accused by medical practitioner at request of police officer 53 1.2, 1.4, 1.10
52 Examination of person accused of rape by medical practitioner 53A 1.4, 1.10
53 Examination of arrested person by medical officer 54 1.4, 1.10
55 Procedure when police officer deputes subordinate to arrest without warrant 1.4
56 Health and safety of arrested person 1.4, 1.10
58 Person arrested not to be detained more than twenty-four hours 57 1.4, 1.10
62 Arrest to be made strictly according to Sanhita 60A 1.4
63 Form of summons 61 1.5
64 Summons how served 62 1.1, 1.5
65 Service of summons on corporate bodies, firms, and societies 63 1.5
66 Service when persons summoned cannot be found 64 1.5
67 Procedure when service cannot be effected as before provided 65 1.5
68 Service on Government servant 66 1.5
69 Service of summons outside local limits 67 1.5
70 Proof of service in such cases and when serving officer not present 68 1.5
71 Service of summons on witness 69 1.1, 1.5
72 Form of warrant of arrest and duration 70 1.5
73 Power to direct security to be taken 1.5
74 Warrants to whom directed 1.5, 3.1
76 Warrant directed to police officer 1.5
77 Notification of substance of warrant 1.5
78 Person arrested to be brought before Court without delay 1.5
79 Where warrant may be executed 1.5
81 Warrant directed to police officer for execution outside jurisdiction 1.5
82 Procedure on arrest of person against whom warrant issued 1.5
83 Procedure by Magistrate before whom such person arrested is brought 1.5
84 Proclamation for person absconding 82 1.4, 1.5, 2.2
85 Attachment of property of person absconding 83 1.4, 1.5
86 Identification and attachment of property of proclaimed person 1.1, 1.4, 1.5
87 Claims and objections to attachment 84 1.4, 1.5
89 Appeal from order rejecting application for restoration of attached property 1.5
90 Issue of warrant in lieu of, or in addition to, summons 87 1.5
91 Power to take bond or bail bond for appearance 1.5
92 Arrest on breach of bond or bail bond for appearance 1.5
93 Provisions of this Chapter generally applicable to summons and warrants of arrest 1.5
94 Summons to produce document or other thing 91 1.5, 1.10
96 When search-warrant may be issued 93 1.5
97 Search of place suspected to contain stolen property, forged documents, etc 1.5
101 Power to compel restoration of abducted females 2.2
103 Persons in charge of closed place to allow search 2.2
105 Recording of search and seizure through audio video electronic means 1.1, 1.5, 1.10, 2.2
106 Power of police officer to seize certain property 1.5, 1.10, 2.2
107 Attachment, forfeiture or restoration of property 1.1, 1.10, 3.8
110 Reciprocal arrangements regarding processes 1.5
125 Security for keeping peace on conviction 1.7
126 Security for keeping peace in other cases 1.3, 1.9, 3.1
127 Security for good behaviour from persons disseminating certain matters 108 1.6
129 Security for good behaviour from habitual offenders 1.3
130 Order to be made 111 1.6
135 Inquiry as to truth of information 116 1.6
136 Order to give security 1.6, 3.5
137 Discharge of person informed against 1.6
141 Imprisonment in default of security 122 1.6
144 Order for maintenance of wives, children and parents 125 1.2, 1.7
145 Procedure 1.7, 1.8
146 Alteration in allowance 1.7
147 Enforcement of order of maintenance 1.7
148 Dispersal of assembly by use of civil force 1.2, 1.3
152 Conditional order for removal of nuisance 133 1.2, 1.3, 1.8
163 Power to issue order in urgent cases of nuisance or apprehended danger 1.3
164 Procedure where dispute concerning land or water is likely to cause breach of peace 145 1.3, 1.8
166 Dispute concerning right of use of land or water 147 1.8
168 Police to prevent cognizable offences 1.9, 1.10
169 Information of design to commit cognizable offences 1.9
170 Arrest to prevent commission of cognizable offences 151 1.4, 1.9, 1.10
171 Prevention of injury to public property 1.9
172 Persons bound to conform to lawful directions of police 1.1, 1.9, 1.10
173 Information in cognizable cases 154 1.1, 1.2, 1.10
174 Information as to non-cognizable cases and investigation of such cases 1.2
175 Police officer’s power to investigate cognizable case 156 1.2, 1.10
176 Procedure for investigation 157 1.1, 1.2, 1.10
178 Power to hold investigation or preliminary inquiry 159 1.10
179 Police officer's power to require attendance of witnesses 1.4, 1.10, 4.2
180 Examination of witnesses by police 161 1.2, 1.10
181 Statements to police and use thereof 162 1.2, 1.10
182 No inducement to be offered 163 1.10
183 Recording of confessions and statements 164 1.2, 1.10
184 Medical examination of victim of rape 1.1, 1.10
185 Search by police officer 1.1, 1.5, 1.10
186 When officer in charge of police station may require another to issue search-warrant 166 1.10
187 Procedure when investigation cannot be completed in twenty-four hours 1.1, 1.4, 1.10, 3.9
189 Release of accused when evidence deficient 1.10
190 Cases to be sent to Magistrate, when evidence is sufficient 1.10
192 Diary of proceedings in investigation 1.10
193 Report of police officer on completion of investigation 1.1, 1.2, 1.10
194 Police to enquire and report on suicide, etc 174 1.2, 1.10
195 Power to summon persons 175 1.10
196 Inquiry by Magistrate into cause of death 176 1.2, 1.10
197 Ordinary place of inquiry and trial 177 1.11, 2.2
198 Place of inquiry or trial 178 1.11, 2.2
199 Offence triable where act is done or consequence ensues 179 1.11, 2.2
206 High Court to decide, in case of doubt, district where inquiry or trial shall take place 1.11
208 Offence committed outside India 3.1
209 Receipt of evidence relating to offences committed outside India 1.3
210 Cognizance of offences by Magistrate 190 2.1
212 Making over of cases to Magistrates 2.2
213 Cognizance of offences by Court of Session 193 1.3, 2.1, 2.3
215 Prosecution for contempt of lawful authority of public servants, for offences against public justice 2.1
218 Prosecution of Judges and public servants 197 1.4, 2.1
222 Prosecution for defamation 2.1
223 Examination of complainant 200 1.2, 1.10, 2.1
224 Procedure by Magistrate not competent to take cognizance of case 201 2.1
225 Postponement of issue of process 202 2.1
226 Dismissal of complaint 203 2.1
227 Issue of process 204 2.1
228 Magistrate may dispense with personal attendance of accused 205 2.1
229 Special summons in cases of petty offence 206 1.2, 2.1
230 Supply to accused of copy of police report and other documents 207 1.1, 1.2, 1.4, 2.1, 2.3
231 Supply of copies of statements and documents to accused in other cases triable by Court of Session 2.1
232 Commitment of case to Court of Session when offence is triable exclusively by it 209 2.1, 2.3
233 Procedure to be followed when there is a complaint case and police investigation in respect of same 2.1
234 Contents of charge 211 2.2
235 Particulars as to time, place and person 212 2.2
236 When manner of committing offence must be stated 2.2
237 Words in charge taken in sense of law under which offence is punishable 2.2
238 Effect of errors 215 2.2
239 Court may alter charge 216 2.2
240 Recall of witnesses when charge altered 2.2
241 Separate charges for distinct offences 218 2.2
242 Offences of same kind within year may be charged together 219 2.2
243 Trial for more than one offence 220 2.2, 3.1
244 Where it is doubtful what offence has been committed 221 2.2, 3.1
246 What persons may be charged jointly 223 2.2
248 Trial to be conducted by Public Prosecutor 225 1.2, 1.3, 2.3
249 Opening case for prosecution 2.3
250 Discharge 227 1.1, 2.2, 2.3
251 Framing of charge 228 1.1, 2.2, 2.3
252 Conviction on plea of guilty 2.3
253 Date for prosecution evidence 2.3
254 Evidence for prosecution 1.1, 2.3
255 Acquittal 2.3, 3.3
256 Entering upon defence 2.3
257 Arguments 2.3
258 Judgment of acquittal or conviction 1.1, 2.3, 3.3
259 Previous conviction. aC 2.3
260 Procedure in cases instituted under sub-section (2) of section 222 1.2, 1.3, 2.3
261 Compliance with section 230 1.2, 2.3
262 When accused shall be discharged 1.1, 1.2, 2.2, 2.3
263 Framing of charge 1.1, 1.2, 2.2, 2.3
264 Conviction on plea of guilty 2.3
265 Evidence for prosecution 2.3
266 Evidence for defence 2.3
267 Evidence for prosecution 2.3
268 When accused shall be discharged 1.2, 2.2, 2.3
269 Procedure where accused is not discharged 2.2, 2.3
270 Evidence for defence 2.3
271 Acquittal or conviction 2.3, 3.3
272 Absence of complainant 249 1.2, 2.3
273 Compensation for accusation without reasonable cause 250 1.2, 2.3
274 Substance of accusation to be stated 251 1.2, 2.2, 2.3
278 Acquittal or conviction 3.3
279 Non-appearance or death of complainant 1.2, 2.3
281 Power to stop proceedings in certain cases 3.1
282 Power of Court to convert summons-cases into warrant-cases 1.2, 2.3
283 Power to try summarily 260 1.3, 2.3
284 Summary trial by Magistrate of second class 261 2.3
285 Procedure for summary trials 262 2.3
286 Record in summary trials 263 2.3
287 Judgment in cases tried summarily 264 2.3
288 Language of record and judgment 2.3
289 Application of Chapter 265A 2.4
290 Application for plea bargaining 265C 2.4
291 Guidelines for mutually satisfactory disposition 2.4
292 Report of mutually satisfactory disposition to be submitted before Court 2.4
293 Disposal of case 2.4
294 Judgment of Court 2.4
295 Finality of judgment 2.4
297 Period of detention undergone by accused to be set off against sentence of imprisonment 2.4
299 Statements of accused not to be used 2.4
300 Non-application of Chapter 2.4
303 Power of State Government or Central Government to exclude certain persons from operation of 3.1
316 Record of examination of accused 1.10, 3.1
317 Interpreter to be bound to interpret truthfully 2.3
318 Record in High Court 3.1
331 Affidavit in proof of conduct of public servants 2.3
337 Person once convicted or acquitted not to be tried for same offence 300 1.4, 3.1, 3.3
338 Appearance by Public Prosecutors 301 1.3
339 Permission to conduct prosecution 302 1.3
341 Legal aid to accused at State expense in certain cases 304 1.4
342 Procedure when corporation or registered society is an accused 305 2.1
343 Tender of pardon to accomplice 306 2.1, 2.3, 3.1
344 Power to direct tender of pardon 2.3
345 Trial of person not complying with conditions of pardon 308 2.1
346 Power to postpone or adjourn proceedings 1.1, 2.3
349 Power of Magistrate to order person to give specimen signatures or handwriting, etc 1.10
351 Power to examine accused 313 2.3
352 Oral arguments and memorandum of arguments 2.3
355 Provision for inquiries and trial being held in absence of accused in certain cases 317 1.2, 1.5, 2.1
356 Inquiry, trial or judgment in absentia of proclaimed offender 1.1, 1.2, 1.4, 1.5, 3.1
359 Compounding of offences 320 3.1, 3.9
360 Withdrawal from prosecution 321 1.1, 1.2, 1.3, 2.1, 3.1
366 Court to be open 327 2.3, 3.1
367 Procedure in case of accused being person of unsound mind 328 3.2
368 Procedure in case of person of unsound mind tried before Court 3.2
369 Release of person of unsound mind pending investigation or trial 3.2
370 Resumption of inquiry or trial. aC 3.2
371 Procedure on accused appearing before Magistrate or Court 3.2
372 When accused appears to have been of sound mind 3.2, 3.5
373 Judgment of acquittal on ground of unsoundness of mind 3.2
374 Person acquitted on ground of unsoundness of mind to be detained in safe custody 3.2
375 Power of State Government to empower officer in charge to discharge 3.2
376 Procedure where prisoner of unsound mind is reported capable of making his defence 3.2
377 Procedure where person of unsound mind detained is declared fit to be released 3.2
378 Delivery of person of unsound mind to care of relative or friend 3.2
392 Judgment 353 3.3
393 Language and contents of judgment 354 3.3
394 Order for notifying address of previously convicted offender 356 1.4, 3.3
395 Order to pay compensation 357 1.2, 3.3
396 Victim compensation scheme 1.2, 1.10
397 Treatment of victims 1.2, 1.10
398 Witness protection scheme 1.1, 1.2
399 Compensation to persons groundlessly arrested 358 3.3
400 Order to pay costs in non-cognizable cases 359 3.3
401 Order to release on probation of good conduct or after admonition 360 2.3, 3.3, 3.5, App.
402 Special reasons to be recorded in certain cases 361 3.3, App.
403 Court not to alter judgment 362 3.3, 3.6, 3.11
404 Copy of judgment to be given to accused and other persons 363 3.3
405 Judgment when to be translated 364 3.3
406 Court of Session to send copy of finding and sentence to District Magistrate 365 3.3
407 Sentence of death to be submitted by Court of Session for confirmation 1.3, 2.3, 3.4, 3.6
408 Power to direct further inquiry to be made or additional evidence to be taken 3.4
409 Power of High Court to confirm sentence or annul conviction 3.4
410 Confirmation or new sentence to be signed by two Judges 3.4
411 Procedure in case of difference of opinion 3.4
412 Procedure in cases submitted to High Court for confirmation 1.3, 3.4
413 No appeal to lie unless otherwise provided 372 1.2, 3.5
414 Appeal from orders requiring security or refusal to accept or rejecting surety for keeping peace or 373 3.5
415 Appeals from convictions 374 1.3, 3.4, 3.5
416 No appeal in certain cases when accused pleads guilty 375 3.5
417 No appeal in petty cases 376 2.3, 3.5
418 Appeal by State Government against sentence 377 3.5
419 Appeal in case of acquittal 378 1.3, 3.5
420 Appeal against conviction by High Court in certain cases 379 3.5
421 Special right of appeal in certain cases 380 3.5
423 Petition of appeal 3.5
424 Procedure when appellant in jail 3.5
425 Summary dismissal of appeal 384 3.5
426 Procedure for hearing appeals not dismissed summarily 3.5
427 Powers of Appellate Court 386 3.5, 3.6
430 Suspension of sentence pending appeal; release of appellant on bail 389 3.5, 3.6, 3.9
432 Appellate Court may take further evidence or direct it to be taken 3.5, 3.6
433 Procedure where Judges of Court of appeal are equally divided 3.4, 3.6
435 Abatement of appeals 394 3.5
436 Reference to High Court 395 3.6
437 Disposal of case according to decision of High Court 396 3.6, 3.9
438 Calling for records to exercise powers of revision 397 1.3, 2.3, 3.6
439 Power to order inquiry 3.6, 3.9
440 Sessions Judge's powers of revision 399 1.3, 3.6
441 Power of Additional Sessions Judge 3.6
442 High Court's powers of revision 1.3, 3.6
443 Power of High Court to withdraw or transfer revision cases 3.6
446 Power of Supreme Court to transfer cases and appeals 406 3.7
447 Power of High Court to transfer cases and appeals 407 1.3, 3.5, 3.7
448 Power of Sessions Judge to transfer cases and appeals 408 3.7
449 Withdrawal of cases and appeals by Sessions Judges 409 3.7
450 Withdrawal of cases by Judicial Magistrates 410 3.7
451 Making over or withdrawal of cases by Executive Magistrates 411 3.7
452 Reasons to be recorded 412 3.7
472 Mercy petition in death sentence cases 3.4
478 In what cases bail to be taken 436 1.2, 3.9
479 Maximum period for which under-trial prisoner can be detained 436A 1.1, 3.9
480 When bail may be taken in case of non-bailable offence 437 1.2, 3.9
481 Bail to require accused to appear before next Appellate Court 3.9
482 Direction for grant of bail to person apprehending arrest 438 1.3, 3.6, 3.9
483 Special powers of High Court or Court of Session regarding bail 439 1.3, 1.5, 3.9
484 Amount of bond and reduction thereof 440 3.9
485 Bond of accused and sureties 3.9
486 Declaration by sureties 3.9
487 Discharge from custody 3.9
488 Power to order sufficient bail when that first taken is insufficient 3.9
490 Deposit instead of recognizance 3.9
491 Procedure when bond has been forfeited 446 1.5, 3.9
497 Order for custody and disposal of property pending trial in certain cases 451 3.8
498 Order for disposal of property at conclusion of trial 3.8
499 Payment to innocent purchaser of money found on accused 453 3.8
500 Appeal against orders under section 498 or section 499 454 3.8
501 Destruction of libellous and other matter 455 3.8
502 Power to restore possession of immovable property 456 3.8
503 Procedure by police upon seizure of property 457 3.8
504 Procedure where no claimant appears within six months 458 3.8
505 Power to sell perishable property 459 3.8
510 Effect of omission to frame, or absence of, or error in, charge 464 2.2
513 Definitions. aC 3.11
514 Bar to taking cognizance after lapse of period of limitation 468 3.11
515 Commencement of period of limitation 469 3.11
516 Exclusion of time in certain cases 3.11
517 Exclusion of date on which Court is closed 3.11
518 Continuing offence 3.11
519 Extension of period of limitation in certain cases 3.11
528 Saving of inherent powers of High Court 482 1.3, 3.1, 3.6, 3.11
529 Duty of High Court to exercise continuous superintendence over Courts 483 3.11
530 Trial and proceedings to be held in electronic mode 1.1
531 Repeal and savings 1.1

Index

Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023

Section Heading Cited in
4 Punishments 1.3
22 Act of a person of unsound mind 3.2
64 Punishment for rape 3.1, 3.9
65 Punishment for rape in certain cases 3.9
68 Sexual intercourse by a person in authority 3.1
70 Gang rape 3.1, 3.9
71 Punishment for repeat offenders 3.1
72 Disclosure of identity of victim of certain offences, etc 3.1
84 Enticing or taking away or detaining with criminal intent a married woman 2.2
100 Culpable homicide 2.2
101 Murder 2.2
105 Punishment for culpable homicide not amounting to murder 2.2
106 Causing death by negligence 2.2
109 Attempt to murder 2.4, 3.1, 3.5
115 Voluntarily causing hurt 3.1
152 Act endangering sovereignty, unity and integrity of India 1.6
196 Promoting enmity between different groups on grounds of religion, race, place of birth, aC residence, language, etc., and doing acts prejudicial to maintenance of harmony 1.6
197 Imputations, assertions prejudicial to national integration 1.6
198 Public servant disobeying law, with intent to cause injury to any person 1.4
200 Punishment for non-treatment of victim 1.10
208 Non-attendance in obedience to an order from public servant 1.5
209 Non-appearance in response to a proclamation under section 84 of Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 1.4, 1.5
222 Omission to assist public servant when bound by law to give assistance 1.3
239 Intentional omission to give information of offence by person bound to inform 1.3
270 Public nuisance 1.8
294 Sale, etc., of obscene books, etc 1.6
299 Deliberate and malicious acts, intended to outrage religious feelings of any class by insulting its religion or religious beliefs 1.6
303 Theft 1.10, 2.3, 4.1, App.
305 Theft in a dwelling house, or means of transportation or place of worship, etc 2.3, App.
306 Theft by clerk or servant of property in possession of master 2.3, App.
310 Dacoity 2.3
315 Dishonest misappropriation of property possessed by deceased person at the time of his death App.
318 Cheating App.

Index

Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023

Section Heading Cited in
6 Motive, preparation and previous or subsequent conduct 2.2
22 Confession caused by inducement, threat, coercion or promise, when irrelevant in criminal proceeding 1.10
23 Confession to police officer 1.10, 4.1
26 Cases in which statement of relevant fact by person who is dead or cannot be found, etc., is relevant 1.10
108 Burden of proving that case of accused comes within exceptions 3.2
119 Court may presume existence of certain facts 3.1
138 Accomplice 3.1
148 Cross-examination as to previous statements in writing 1.10
160 Former statements of witness may be proved to corroborate later testimony as to same fact 1.10

Index

Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015

Section Heading Cited in
2 Definitions 4.1
3 General principles to be followed in administration of Act 4.1
4 Juvenile Justice Board 4.1
7 Procedure in relation to Board 4.1
8 Powers, functions and responsibilities of the Board 4.1
9 Procedure to be followed by a Magistrate who has not been empowered under this Act 4.1
10 Apprehension of child alleged to be in conflict with law 1.4, 4.1
12 Bail to a person who is apparently a child alleged to be in conflict with law 4.1
13 Information to parents, guardian or probation officer 4.1
14 Inquiry by Board regarding child in conflict with law 4.1
15 Preliminary assessment into heinous offences by Board 4.1
17 Orders regarding a child not found to be in conflict with law 4.1
18 Orders regarding child found to be in conflict with law 4.1
19 Powers of Children’s Court 4.1
21 Order that may not be passed against a child in conflict with law 4.1
22 Proceeding under Chapter VIII of the Code of Criminal Procedure not to apply against child 4.1
23 No joint proceedings of child in conflict with law and person not a child 4.1
24 Removal of disqualification on the findings of an offence 4.1
27 Child Welfare Committee 4.1
28 Procedure in relation to Committee 4.1
29 Powers of Committee 4.1
30 Functions and responsibilities of Committee 4.1
31 Production before Committee 4.1
32 Mandatory reporting regarding a child found separated from guardian 4.1
33 Offence of non-reporting 4.1
35 Surrender of children 4.1
36 Inquiry 4.1
37 Orders passed regarding a child in need of care and protection 4.1
38 Procedure for declaring a child legally free for adoption 4.1
39 Process of rehabilitation and social re-integration 4.1
40 Restoration of child in need of care and protection 4.1
41 Registration of child care institutions 4.1
43 Open shelter 4.1
44 Foster care 4.1
45 Sponsorship 4.1
46 After care of children leaving child care institution 4.1
47 Observation homes 4.1
48 Special homes 4.1
49 Place of safety 4.1
50 Children’s Home 4.1
51 Fit facility 4.1
52 Fit person 4.1
53 Rehabilitation and re-integration services in institutions registered under this Act and management 4.1
54 Inspection of institutions registered under this Act 4.1
56 Adoption 4.1
58 Procedure for adoption by Indian prospective adoptive parents living in India 4.1
61 Procedure for disposal of adoption proceedings 4.1
68 Central Adoption Resource Authority 4.1
73 Accounts and audit of Authority 4.1
74 Prohibition on disclosure of identity of children 4.1
82 Corporal punishment 4.1
89 Offence committed by child under this Chapter 4.1
94 Presumption and determination of age 4.1
101 Appeals 4.1
106 State Child Protection Society and District Child Protection Unit 4.1
107 Child Welfare Police Officer and Special Juvenile Police Unit 4.1
109 Monitoring of implementation of Act 4.1
111 Repeal and savings 4.1

Index

Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012

Section Heading Cited in
2 Definitions 4.2
3 Penetrative sexual assault 4.2
4 Punishment for penetrative sexual assault 2.4, 3.1, 4.2
5 Aggravated penetrative sexual assault 4.2
6 Punishment for aggravated penetrative sexual assault 3.1, 4.2
7 Sexual assault 4.2
8 Punishment for sexual assault 3.1, 4.2
9 Aggravated sexual assault 4.2
10 Punishment for aggravated sexual assault 3.1, 4.2
11 Sexual harassment 4.2
12 Punishment for sexual harassment 4.2
13 Use of child for pornographic purposes 4.2
14 Punishment for using child for pornographic purposes 4.2
15 Punishment for storage of pornographic material involving child 4.2
16 Abetment of an offence 4.2
17 Punishment for abetment 4.2
18 Punishment for attempt to commit an offence 4.2
19 Reporting of offences 4.2
20 Obligation of media, studio and photographic facilities to report cases 4.2
21 Punishment for failure to report or record a case 4.2
22 Punishment for false complaint or false information 4.2
23 Procedure for media 4.2
24 Recording of statement of a child 4.2
25 Recording of statement of a child by Magistrate 4.2
26 Additional provisions regarding statement to be recorded 4.2
28 Designation of Special Courts 4.2
29 Presumption as to certain offences 4.2
30 Presumption of culpable mental state 4.2
33 Procedure and powers of Special Court 4.2
35 Period for recording of evidence of child and disposal of case 4.2
36 Child not to see accused at the time of testifying 4.2
37 Trials to be conducted in camera 3.1, 4.2
42 Alternative punishment 4.2
42A Act not in derogation of any other law 4.2

Index

Probation of Offenders Act, 1958

Section Heading Cited in
2 Definitions App.
3 Power of court to release certain offenders after admonition App.
4 Power of court to release certain offenders on probation of good conduct App.
5 Power of court to require released offenders to pay compensation and costs App.
6 Restrictions on imprisonment of offenders under twenty-one years of age App.
7 Report of probation officer to be confidential App.
8 Variation of conditions of probation App.
9 Procedure in case of offender failing to observe conditions of bond App.
10 Provision as to sureties App.
11 Courts competent to make order under the Act, appeal and revision and powers of courts in appeal and revision App.
12 Removal of disqualification attaching to conviction App.
13 Probation officers App.
14 Duties of probation officers App.
15 Probation officers to be public servants App.
16 Protection of action taken in good faith App.
17 Power to make rules App.
18 Saving of operation of certain enactments App.
19 Section 562 of the Code not to apply in certain areas App.

Index

Cases cited

Case Year Point for which cited Cited in
Abdul Nazar Madani v State of Tamil Nadu 2000 apprehension must be reasonable, not imaginary 3.7
Abuzar Hossain v State of West Bengal 2012 a claim of juvenility may be raised at any stage, even after final disposal 4.1
Accused X v State of Maharashtra 2019 severe mental illness after conviction bars execution of a death sentence, which reflects the same fair-trial principle 3.2
Ahmed Noormohmed Bhatti v State of Gujarat 2005 preventive arrest under s 151 CrPC upheld, subject to its limits 1.9
Alakh Alok Srivastava v Union of India 2018 the Court directed child-friendly courts and adherence to the Act's time limits, which give effect to its object 4.2
Allauddin Mian v State of Bihar 1989 the hearing on sentence is a real hearing, and its omission vitiates the sentence 2.3, 3.3
Amar Nath v State of Haryana 1977 "interlocutory order" means a purely interim order not deciding rights 3.6
Anil Rai v State of Bihar 2001 inordinate delay in pronouncing judgment denies justice 3.3
Arnesh Kumar v State of Bihar 2014 checklist before arresting for offences up to seven years 1.4
Attorney General for India v Satish 2021 skin-to-skin contact not required 4.2
Babubhai Udesinh Parmar v State of Gujarat 2006 a confession must be voluntary; the magistrate must ensure freedom from police influence 1.10
Bachan Singh v State of Punjab 1980 death sentence only in the "rarest of rare" case 3.4
Badshah v Urmila Badshah Godse 2014 a woman deceived into a bigamous marriage may claim maintenance as a wife 1.7
Bapu v State of Rajasthan 2007 only legal insanity, not medical insanity, excuses under BNS s 22 (s 84 IPC) 3.2
Barun Chandra Thakur v Master Bholu 2022 the preliminary assessment is a delicate task requiring expert help 4.1
Basavva Kom Dyamangouda Patil v State of Mysore 1977 the object is to prevent property from being kept unused or misused 3.8
Bhagirath Kanoria v State of MP 1984 non-payment of employer's provident fund contribution is a continuing offence 3.11
Bhagwant Singh v Commissioner of Police 1985 the informant must be heard before a closure report is accepted 1.10
Bikramjit Singh v State of Punjab 2020 default bail is an indefeasible right once the period expires 3.9
Captain Amarinder Singh v Prakash Singh Badal 2009 transfer is ordered only where a fair trial is in real doubt, since it affects the forum chosen by law 3.7
Chanmuniya v Virendra Kumar Singh Kushwaha 2011 "wife" is construed broadly to advance social justice 1.7
Chhanni v State of Uttar Pradesh 2006 probation is discretionary and depends on the nature of the offence and the offender App.
Citizens for Democracy v State of Assam 1995 handcuffs only with the Magistrate's permission and recorded reasons 1.4
D.K. Basu v State of West Bengal 1997 eleven requirements on arrest and custody, now largely codified in ss 36–53 and enforced by contempt and compensation 1.4
Danial Latifi v Union of India 2001 upheld the Muslim Women (Protection of Rights on Divorce) Act, 1986 consistently with fair provision 1.7
Delhi Judicial Service Association v State of Gujarat 1991 guidelines for the arrest of a judicial officer 1.4
Dolat Ram v State of Haryana 1995 cancellation requires supervening circumstances, such as tampering or misuse of liberty 3.9
General Insurance Council v State of Andhra Pradesh 2010 seized vehicles should be released promptly to owners or insurers 3.8
Gian Singh v State of Punjab 2012 the High Court may quash non-compoundable offences of a private character on settlement under s 482 CrPC (now s 528 BNSS) 3.1, 3.11
Gudikanti Narasimhulu v Public Prosecutor 1978 bail is a matter of personal liberty under Article 21 3.9
Gurbaksh Singh Sibbia v State of Punjab 1980 the power is wide and should not be fettered by rigid rules 3.9
H.N. Rishbud v State of Delhi 1955 investigation ends with the report 1.2
Hardeep Singh v State of Punjab 2014 inquiry is distinct from trial 1.2
Hari Singh Mann v Harbhajan Singh Bajwa 2001 s 482 cannot be used to review a final order 3.6
Hussainara Khatoon v State of Bihar 1979 speedy trial is part of Article 21 1.1, 1.4
Ishar Das v State of Punjab 1972 courts must consider s 6 for young offenders before imposing imprisonment App.
Japani Sahoo v Chandra Shekhar Mohanty 2007 a complainant is not to suffer for the court's delay 3.11
Joginder Kumar v State of UP 1994 arrest must be justified by necessity, not merely by power 1.4
Joseph Shine v Union of India 2018 adultery (s 497 IPC) struck down as unconstitutional 2.2
Jugal Kishore Prasad v State of Bihar 1972 the object is to prevent young and first offenders from becoming hardened criminals App.
Just Rights for Children Alliance v S. Harish 2024 viewing or storing child sexual abuse material is an offence, and the term "child sexual exploitative and abuse material" is to be preferred 4.2
Kachhia Patel Shantilal Koderlal v State of Gujarat 1980 informal plea bargains disapproved before the statutory scheme 2.4
Kalyan Chandra Sarkar v Rajesh Ranjan 2004 bail orders must reflect the relevant factors, not be mechanical 3.9
Kedar Nath Singh v State of Bihar 1962 sedition confined to incitement to violence or public disorder 1.6
Khatri v State of Bihar 1981 free legal aid must be provided from the accused's first production 1.4
King-Emperor v Khwaja Nazir Ahmad 1945 investigation is the police's domain 1.10
Kirtikant D. Vadodaria v State of Gujarat 1996 a childless step-mother may claim maintenance from her step-son 1.7
Kolla Veera Raghav Rao v Gorantla Venkateswara Rao 2011 s 300 CrPC is wider than Art 20(2), since it bars a second trial even where no punishment followed 3.1
Koppula Venkat Rao v State of Andhra Pradesh 2004 an attempt to rape requires acts beyond preparation showing determination to proceed despite resistance 4.2
Krishnan v Krishnaveni 1997 the High Court's inherent power survives the bar on a second revision 3.6
Lal Kamlendra Pratap Singh v State of UP 2009 interim bail may be granted pending the decision of a regular bail application 3.9
Lalita Kumari v Govt of UP 2014 registration is mandatory if information discloses a cognizable offence 1.10
Madhu Limaye v State of Maharashtra 1977 intermediate orders that finally decide an issue are revisable 3.6
Mallikarjun Kodagali v State of Karnataka 2018 the victim needs no leave 1.2, 3.5
Maneka Sanjay Gandhi v Rani Jethmalani 1979 the test is a reasonable apprehension of injustice, not a mere allegation 3.7
Maqbool Hussain v State of Bombay 1953 proceedings before customs authorities are not a prosecution 3.1
Meters and Instruments Pvt Ltd v Kanchan Mehta 2017 cheque-dishonour cases suit summary trial 2.3
Mohd Abdul Samad v State of Telangana 2024 the remedy extends to Muslim women 1.7
Mohd Ahmed Khan v Shah Bano Begum 1985 s 125 overrides personal law 1.7
Mohd Aziz Mohd Nasir v State of Maharashtra 1976 s 6 is mandatory for offenders under 21 in eligible cases App.
Moti Ram v State of MP 1978 excessive bail bonds and sureties defeat the right to bail 3.9
Nandini Satpathy v P.L. Dani 1978 the right to silence under Art 20(3) extends to police interrogation 1.4
Naresh Shridhar Mirajkar v State of Maharashtra 1966 courts have inherent power to hold proceedings in camera where justice requires 3.1
Narinder Singh v State of Punjab 2014 guidelines for quashing on settlement, including for attempt to murder (BNS s 109 (s 307 IPC)) 3.1
Nawabuddin v State of Uttarakhand 2022 offences of this gravity call for strict sentencing with no undue leniency 4.2
Neeharika Infrastructure v State of Maharashtra 2021 no blanket "no coercive steps" orders while declining to quash 3.11
Nilabati Behera v State of Orissa 1993 public-law compensation for custodial death 1.4
Nipun Saxena v Union of India 2018 the victim's identity must not be revealed in any form 3.1
P. Chidambaram v Directorate of Enforcement 2019 gravity of the offence is relevant to bail but not the sole factor 3.9
Parbatbhai Aahir v State of Gujarat 2017 summary of principles for quashing 3.1
Parmanand Katara v Union of India 1989 every doctor must give immediate emergency aid to the injured 1.10
Parvez Noordin Lokhandwalla v State of Maharashtra 2020 bail conditions must be proportionate to their purpose 3.9
Pedda Narayana v State of Andhra Pradesh 1975 the inquest is limited to the apparent cause of death, not the identity of the assailant 1.10
Pepsi Foods Ltd v Special Judicial Magistrate 1998 summoning an accused is a serious matter requiring application of mind 2.1
Prahlad Singh Bhati v NCT of Delhi 2001 nature of accusation, severity of punishment, evidence, risk of tampering and public interest 3.9
Prakash Singh v Union of India 2006 directions on police reform and accountability 1.10
Prem Shankar Shukla v Delhi Administration 1980 handcuffing is prima facie inhuman 1.4
Pyare Lal v State of Rajasthan 1963 a retracted confession needs corroboration in material particulars 1.10
R.H. Bhutani v Mani J. Desai 1968 proceedings on land disputes decide possession for keeping the peace, not title 1.8
R.P. Kapur v State of Punjab 1960 quashing where there is a legal bar, no offence on the allegations or no evidence 3.11
Rajender Singh Pathania v State (NCT of Delhi) 2011 preventive arrest only where a designed cognizable offence cannot otherwise be prevented 1.9
Rajnesh v Neha 2020 maintenance is payable from the date of application 1.7
Rameshwar v State of Rajasthan 1952 the rule of prudence has hardened into a rule of law in practice 3.1
Ramgopal v State of MP 2021 the power extends to cases after conviction, for private offences 3.1
Rasiklal v Kishore Khanchand Wadhwani 2009 bail in a bailable offence is a right 3.9
Ratan Lal v State of Madhya Pradesh 1970 the relevant time for insanity under BNS s 22 (s 84 IPC) is the moment the act was committed 3.2
Rattan Lal v State of Punjab 1965 the Act is a beneficial reform statute and applies even to pending appeals App.
S.G. Vombatkere v Union of India 2022 s 124A IPC kept in abeyance pending review 1.6
Sakiri Vasu v State of UP 2008 statutory remedies against refusal of an FIR should be used before a writ 1.10
Salil Bali v Union of India 2013 the age of 18 under juvenile justice law upheld 4.1
Sampurna Behrua v Union of India 2018 the Court directed States to make CWCs and child care institutions fully functional 4.1
Sanjay Chandra v CBI 2012 gravity alone does not justify refusal 3.9
Sarah Mathew v Institute of Cardio Vascular Diseases 2014 the relevant date is the filing of the complaint or institution of prosecution, not the date of cognizance 3.11
Sarwan Singh v State of Punjab 1957 the evidence must first be credible, and then corroborated 3.1
Satender Kumar Antil v CBI 2022 non-compliance with s 41A CrPC (now s 35(3) BNSS) entitles the accused to bail 1.4, 3.9
Satvinder Kaur v State (Govt of NCT of Delhi) 1999 police may not refuse an FIR for lack of territorial jurisdiction 1.10
Selvi v State of Karnataka 2010 compelled testimonial techniques violate Art 20(3); physical evidence does not 1.5
Shailja v Khobbanna 2018 a wife's capacity to earn does not alone defeat her claim to maintenance 1.7
Sheela Barse v State of Maharashtra 1983 separate lock-ups for women, guarded by women constables 1.4
Sheela Barse v Union of India 1986 children must not be kept in jails, and their cases must be decided quickly 4.1
Sheonandan Paswan v State of Bihar 1987 withdrawal must be in good faith and in the public interest 1.3
Shilpa Mittal v State (NCT of Delhi) 2020 the classification of offences (petty, serious, heinous) determines the orders available, which keeps the Board's response proportionate 4.1
Shimbhu v State of Haryana 2014 a compromise in a rape case cannot reduce the sentence 3.1, 3.9
Shiv Kumar v Hukam Chand 1999 the PP must present the case fairly and not seek a conviction at any cost 1.3
Shivappa v State of Karnataka 1995 police must be absent from the chamber, and time given for reflection 1.10
Siddharam Satlingappa Mhetre v State of Maharashtra 2011 the court weighs the nature of the accusation, antecedents, risk of flight and motive of the accusation 3.9
Smt Nagawwa v Veeranna Shivalingappa Konjalgi 1976 the accused has no role at this stage, and dismissal lies only where the complaint is absurd or discloses no offence 2.1
State of AP v Rayavarapu Punnayya 1976 distinction between murder and culpable homicide not amounting to murder 2.2
State of Bihar v Basawan Singh 1958 a trap witness is not an accomplice 3.1
State of Gujarat v Natwar Harchandji Thakor 2005 plea bargaining recognised as part of speedy justice 2.4
State of Gujarat v Shyamlal Mohanlal Choksi 1965 the power to summon production of documents does not extend to the accused 1.5
State of Haryana v Bhajan Lal 1992 the High Court may quash investigation only in the categories it laid down, which balances police autonomy with judicial control 1.10, 3.11
State of Himachal Pradesh v Tara Dutt 2000 reasons for condonation must be recorded 3.11
State of Kerala v M.M. Manikantan Nair 2001 criminal courts, including the High Court, have no power of review 3.6
State of Maharashtra v Christian Community Welfare Council 2003 the sunset rule is directory in exceptional cases, if reasons are recorded 1.4
State of Maharashtra v Mohd Ajmal Kasab 2012 the right to counsel arises on first production before a Magistrate 1.4
State of Maharashtra v Mohd Yakub 1980 an attempt begins when preparation ends and the accused does an act towards commission 4.2
State of Maharashtra v Som Nath Thapa 1996 at framing, strong suspicion on the material suffices 2.2
State of Punjab v Gurmit Singh 1996 in-camera trial of rape cases is mandatory and preserves the victim's dignity 3.1
State of Punjab v Sarwan Singh 1981 limitation is part of the right to speedy justice 3.11
State of Rajasthan v Balchand 1977 the basic rule is bail, not jail 3.9
Subramanian Swamy v Raju 2014 uniform treatment of all under-18s under the 2000 Act upheld 4.1
Sunderbhai Ambalal Desai v State of Gujarat 2002 vehicles and valuables should be returned on panchnama, photographs and security, rather than left to rot in police stations 3.8
Sunil Batra v Delhi Administration 1978 bar fetters violate Article 21 unless absolutely necessary 1.4
Sushila Aggarwal v State (NCT of Delhi) 2020 protection need not be limited in time and may last till the end of trial 3.9
Tahsildar Singh v State of UP 1959 only statements that contradict, not mere omissions, may be put to the witness 1.10
Thulia Kali v State of Tamil Nadu 1972 unexplained delay in lodging an FIR may cast doubt on the prosecution 1.10
Union of India v Prafulla Kumar Samal 1979 discharge tests whether there is grave suspicion, not proof 2.3
Vanka Radhamanohari v Vanka Venkata Reddy 1993 a liberal approach applies to matrimonial offences against women 3.11
Vijay Dhanuka v Najima Mamtaj 2014 inquiry is mandatory where the accused resides beyond the Magistrate's jurisdiction 2.1
Vinay Tyagi v Irshad Ali 2013 further investigation may be ordered after the police report 1.10
Willie (William) Slaney v State of Madhya Pradesh 1956 the test of a defective charge is prejudice to the accused, which ties framing directly to fairness 2.2
Yamunabai Anantrao Adhav v Anantrao Shivram Adhav 1988 a woman in a void (bigamous) marriage is not a "wife" for maintenance 1.7